Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
4-07-1246\3 AI generated

Court dismissed execution of foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects.

Case Number 4-07-1246\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tartu Regional Court dismissed the application to enforce a foreign judgment against the applicant. The applicant argued that the foreign court lacked jurisdiction and failed to observe due process, while the opposing party sought enforcement based on the judgment's validity. The court ruled that the foreign proceedings were flawed and the domestic court could not recognize the judgment under the applicable legal framework.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 18 ust. 1 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment may not be enforced if the foreign court lacked jurisdiction or if the judgment was obtained in violation of fundamental procedural rights.

Keywords

AI generated
foreign judgment enforcement lack of jurisdiction procedural defects due process violation recognition and enforcement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 18 ust. 1 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           

          ! "  #     $%%$&     #' '  (   ) *   + ,' #  - '   ,' ' ('

   * + .)*/''+0       % '  '1#  %  '/ - -  $ 2   ,'  *2       !   1- +    ,' ' ('

 ,' #    ,'   *   ,'    #  34345 ) *   ' &  #' '#+'! ' #  '  +      4   (  ,,    $%434! '(  6'

'  '    '  ' ''#-  ' ' ,   ##   74 ,,   #  4&  , ,,  ,

 ' +  ) * !  %  '  ' 1#   !   ,'  *        ,,  -  '  -,  ! -,  !' ,,  '  '+

    ,,    +  ''-'+'  +   !' + ,,          +   "# $%   ) *  #   ' #+  +!  - + - +  ('

 ,' #  ) * ,,   # $%434 '  ' ''#-  ' ' ,   ##   874 (  # 4& ,,    +6   ', (' '  + 9 & (   ,, '  +   46' 7 #')* '+      4   (  ,,    # $%434 ,#+ '  '  ! ,

 -' ' 

/2 &  #'   ,'     ('  +  +    ' #+#+  7 

'      ''#)*- #( #   ,'  ','+ # ,' #   

+   &4! (   +  ,' #      ,'   ##   ' !' +   ('-'    4 (' '

 + #' - #(   ''#' 7  '#('+ ,'  ''#('+! ( 

,' #   ' '#+ #    9  (  -    ,'   (#' ,



'   ,' '   #'#( ,' #   '     ''  ' ' # ,'+ +

,' #   ' '#('+! '   ,'  (#',

 ,' '  #'#( (   ,' #   #/ 9$(2 * + ,' ' ,' '  + ( ' '+  ,

 #+'* ' + ##  6 ('  + ##  ,' #   ' (     ''   '   + +  #(   ')* '# ''/ 2! 7 #  ,'  *  +   ' +)*- #(  :;<'- #(  #    9% 55 (  ' ,' #  ,,     ' #   + +  ' '#+'   ,'  ' ,' '  + +  #+    '  ,'#       ,'  ','+  #, !  ,' #   

'  ,'#  %'  ' ''#-  ' ' ,   ##    8  74   # 4&  &4    ' #+   #+  ,' #       '+ '

      

  -+

,' #   ' +' !#  #  9(  ,' ' 6#  #+  #+! ' #  ', ( * +  ' !   ,'  ' # - + #   '''

  '    +  )*  -== +   ,'  ' -!  '+ + ,' #       - +  - '    9  (  ! '     ,' #  ,,     +  ,' #     '     ,, +  ' '#+ -

 ,' ' ('

!'  '''# + '  + '9% 7, 

+ ,    ,'   &4 ' # &5  !  ,  )*   +  #     9%  7 - 4 '      ,'  ! ' ,,     +    '   # ==+#+   '  + ), '  '  ,    ' ' #   +  ,' #     4  - ,,   # $% 434   ('

 #'#(   

+ #   - +  1, +  +   ('#+ 9(-$!9!9!(#'#(97(-   +  - + '  ' ''#-  ' ' ,   ##   874   # 4&  

+ ,' #  ) *    ,,    +6   ', (' '  + 9 &  (    ' 4 6'   7  #' '#+'#'#(   + '''

  ' )*- #(  :;<'- #(         % '  '1#  %  '   ,'  * ' ) *  +  ' #+   $  #     $%    )*#$4    ' #+   ,'  ' (- # ) *  $4        '

+  +    ,'  ' ( -   ' 

+'# ! + '' ' (#+ +  #   ,'  ' (-   97

'  9   +#  ,' # - ' 

,' ' ('

! , '   44 ,, ( )*  +,'(   # '  +    #+ ,- ' (   -,    ,, 

4/2 ,

 ' '   ('   + !     -  # + ,  #+

,- ' '

+  +  ,' # - '  + 

,' ' ('

)* ' ,, ,

& !'+ -  # +

,    #  ' ,- #+ (  #+    ('  #   +  

#, + ''('' 

($& ,, ( )*  + # 

  

,' ' #'  ,, #   + ,' # - ' 

,' ' ('

 

'#+   +- #+  6# !' -+  ,'# - '   ,' ' ('

  ,'  '' #  34345    +# '+  / %+ $%72 #, !   5&4   #   ,'  '  #+   ''#-  '  +    ''#-  '  74    ,,    #  4&  ,' '! '(  ) *  '  '

+  +6   ', (' '  + 9 &% (     '(  4

'6' 7 #'( &4 #  ,'   ' #+ ,'     ,'  ' , ' ' / %+5%42'(' ,'  ''   '#, 

,'   ,

 ' '# (#'! #   ## ,'   ,

 ' '  

,'  '   + / 42 # +  # ##  ! &&4  ' )*   !  ''#-  ' # '+

+

8 ()*#   +, '#+ #,   ,'  '' !')* -   ''#-  '74  ,,   # 4&    '+ #+ 7$$  #   ''#-    +  #+   ,'  '      4    ,,    $%434! '(    ' 

6'

'   ''#-  '  74    ,,    #  4&  +   '    ) *  ' ,,   ' '6' & #'!'+  '#,, ' ' '         ' !    '(   ''  -,  ' +  #'/ %+4%4&2  ) *  ,,    '#+  #  ''   !    ! '   ''#-   '      #+ ,' '   ,'  '  ,' #   

'! ' #+ ,'#     #+  ,'  ''

+ ,'#    -+'('  ', (!''#  

  '#+" 9% $(/4  

+ +  '#'2 )* ' '+6   ', (' '  + 9 &% (        $  ! '        4    (  ' ,' #   >  ''  

+     ,' #        ' !   #    ''#-   '    ,'  ' 5&4   ,' #    ! ' -#+  #+! -+

,' #   '#  ,' +# &554    + ,' #   + '/''# '#'& 2(-&  ' ,' +#+'   ,'#   ,,   ' # '  +  '#+'('   '#+   9  ,

+ / '#  ,    '     9  ,   2 '

,- #+!  ,' ''

+ #+-    #+2!' #+  

,' +# '+#       ++      #+'+ /   '+! ' ,' '# '('

#, +'''

 2 '#-'  #" 9% (!'    ,'#    ,, #'#(   ,, -==  ,' '!' #  #+ ' ,' '-== ' '+ '6 + 

   + '9% 5 *# (''' # #+  ''('&$ ,,  '''  # 4% %%%$!  '  '+  '   ', (   #+#+! '+ ('        ,' '6' ''('  !  ,'   9$4(   6#  #+  '+!,  + !'    + 

$/2

# '  #+'  '''

 ,' )    --+

,' +# ! '  ,' #   ,' ''  #'#( (

+ ,' #   - + '(' 9%4'(# ' , 

+ ,' # - ' #    '#' ! '  #!   ,' +#+'#  '

+   #+'  ' ' ,' !

#('' ''' 9$4(%  

(  #      ,'  * ,' # )* - + ! '  '  +'  #+ ,' ' '

+    '

  ' ! - +    ,'  + ' '#+,'  '   +  #,  #  ,'   , ('+

,'  ''#(+ '#+ 5 !   '+ (#' - #( # +  :  - #( #   ''# 6(' '!#  '

+  +'##' #+ )* + ,'  ''#(  ('  ,'  '' (  ,'  '   +  '#,   #  ,' #   '#4 ' '#+ +' !' ! ,     #+ '   ,

 

  #+ ''#(+! ' ''  ' /  ,'    '# (#'2 ''  ' ,' #    +  7$$ ! '    ''#-   '  ,'  '   4  /''  #+ $ 2*'#  ,'  ''#(- + ##+)*- #( # +  ''# 5     9 7(  - 4 /#'  '#+ +  '#'2,  !   '  

,'  !',,    ' #==+#+6   97(-4 '  +  '#'  '     ,'  !',,    +   ' # ==+#+  ' +   9% 7 (  -%+ % $ # ++  +! ' '#'     ,' ' ('#- 8''- ,,    +  ,' ' ('# !''' '+      + +  '   #+'  ' ' !  ! ' ''  + + '  ,' '-== '##+ '6 +' '  ,' ' , ( # -'#+ +! !'''#,' ''('  + ' # , ' + ' ,  #+    '## #(  !        4    '   + ) *  '    ' ' &       ' !  '   ++  #  9%7(-4#'

+  #  '  ,' '#' '','   ,' ' -== ' + '6 '#  ' ,' ' -'#+ '#    9 7 (  - 4 ' #'  (' - ' #   '  ' ' ,' ' -== '  '+   9% 7 (    +  '+ '## #(    '''#+    + + !  )*    '  '     '+#+!     ,'    -  - #( # +  ''    6(' '  '     '#+ 6 (' ''#(  ' '#+' ''('   +('    &$    #  4%4%%%$ ' !   ' '   '+'#' '#+ 6# '     ''

 '! '+  ' 66+   ''  ( !'  '   ,'  ' ,' #  + ', 

+ '+  + ,'  % '  ,' #      ' , '

 ' #  ,'  ' ' '   +    + ' , 

+  '+!   -==  '# (#'  '  +    ' #+ '   '(   ,'  '# , ('%#+ #+ ,' ' %   ' '(! (      +  # '+ '+   !, ('-,   '( (   +   # , (' +!  '  

,' ' (' ( '# #', '!   ,' '#' ' ' '  -'  -,   '' '  + ! ,'  '  '''#+ '+   + , 

+ ,    + +   % '  ,' #    

,' ' 

/2       4    ) *  ,,      $   '#('+  '+! ' ''+      ,' ' (' - '!    ' '#

(  #   ,'   + '   6       ' *#+'+ !   ,'  -  +' ,' +#+'  ' $  - ''  #+  ,' '  ,' #  + '

#, +  / #+)* #+ ,'  !# '#+   '  + / (' ' '  2 ,'  '' '#,  #( # +  ''    ''  9%7(-4, 

+6  # , ( ==+#+#   ,' ' , ( ==+    # '!-+  + +    '   #+7% '  , (   " 94(,  !  #+' '-==  ,' '(  ,'+ !'#==+#+   9 7 (  -% 4 , 

+ , (   ,' #     '   

,' '-== ' '+ '6 + 9(  -

 ,' #  ,,     + ,'#   '   ,, +  ' '#+ ,' ' ('

!'  '''# + '  + '9% 7, 

+ ,   9(,  !   ' ,' ' ('



,' # - ' #  ,'  ''(#'  + #+ '  +

,' ' #',,  #  ) *  ,,     +    '  # ==+#+   '  

 #'#( -+    + !      ,' '#  #    9 7 (  -%+ !   $ , 

+ ( , #+- #+!''' !   ,' ' 

+ ,' #   9(  97(-4 - +  ,' ' ('

  )* '

+  +'

+,'+ !  ,' # ,''''''##' - + ,' #  + '#  !'-+  +(#' ,'   ' ! (#'   '' !' ,   '## #(  #+ )*  +# + #  6#   ! ' -+  ,' #  - '    ,' ' ('

  

 ,   ,'

   )*  ,    '

+ #+  

- #( '''

  '    '(' #6'( !'  ,'  ' -  ,' # - ' #+    ,'  ' (   '+ +  9% + 7, 

+