1-07-7666\2 · Court dismissed enforcement of foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects. (Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement application against a foreign judgment, citing a lack of jurisdiction and procedural irregularities. The applicant sought to enforce a decision from another jurisdiction, but the respondent argued that the foreign court lacked proper jurisdiction over the matter. The court ruled that the domestic court could not enforce the foreign judgment without first addressing these fundamental jurisdictional and procedural issues.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Enforcement Act 1993; s. 10 of the Civil Procedure Code: A foreign judgment cannot be enforced if the enforcing court lacks jurisdiction or if the judgment was obtained through procedural defects.

Keywords

AI generated

foreign judgment enforcement lack of jurisdiction procedural defects enforcement act civil procedure code

Cited Legislation

AI generated

s. 10 of the Enforcement Act 1993

s. 10 of the Civil Procedure Code

Full text

! " # $ $% &$# '( $

) )* $ ++, ( # #$# ' $ #

# - ())# . $ # . / # # !" 1 & $ 2 # . / # # 1 3333333333333333333333333334 , 333333333333 #!" ##$ % &'()*+&',(-,+ .

/ ! 0 1 (*- (22)-- *32)32* *2 4 5 ' 4 5 / / - -# #. -- #)# # ($ # , # -- #/ )-#. 2 # )-#. 2 . , . -- # # , .(),# ,

6%6#!"7%6 $!"8

! #$#'

++,& !!! #$

5! 5! $ -$ # ( # # 5 $ # , . $ 6# . $ # ./, #$2 , ! )-#. . 2 - , # 7 )-#. . $ 5 7 $ 5 8 $ ! # ,# # # & 9! !9! #$ ( #, # - , 2 7 , !8 )-#. . $ , # # . # ( #, )-#. . $ ( :! ++, . #$ $ !!! ## ()#/!8! 5 $)! # -- .;

#$#' ,!! #$# ' . # ,# 1 :77! <-.# '

) 5 97 $ ! ) 2 9 -$ . / , # $ # # $ 4 !779 <-.#'

) 597 $!)2!29 -$ , . / , # # # $ 4 9!7877: <-.#'

) 57 $!)!2925 $2597 $!)2! 5! $ -$9 . / , # ',#, <-.#'

779 #$ ( #, # , 2 . / , # 2 () # 9 . / , # 4 9! & ) 5! -$,. $ 4 () # 5 7 $ -$ 9 , + , , - $ ! 2 # (, #($ #- .( #! 4 8!9! & ) 5! -$,. $ : # # $

$ (, #($ #- .( # 4 8! & ) 5! -$!,. $ 2 57 $ #

# , ,. $ !

+ , $ - $ ! 2 # (, #($ #- .( #: , ## ,# # / #$# ' $ #

# - #$ . / , # # -- , ##/ ##) # -- #$# ' # # # . , #2 , # -,

. / # # #.(.( #

.# # 2.( (,# # .( )# #. / # +# , -$ $$ # +. , (,#, # , , # # # #, #. $#, ++, ( # #$# ' , # # #2 # . / # # . #/

# . # ,# 3333333333333333333333333333333333 ,#

# / . + . #/ # # <(.= 2 . # # # ,& / , # # . # . 2 . 2)## - % ## #

.# #$#' /# 9 2 # ,# <-.# -#/ .,# # ++ & $ # , $ #$# ' $ #

# - #$ . / #

. # . , ,2 # , # # # ##$#' #

#- #$ # . / $ # #2#($# # # , ,

)## . # -

2 # () -- ,.-# #$ %* . , # 2 # = #, #,#$#' #

#- #$ # . / #

# 2 , 9 , . $ )* # # #$# ' $ #

# - #$ . / 2 ' #

)/ ## 2 #, $ ' )

9 #

. .( # #. # ,2 . # ,. , /# # #) # ### # # ,- (,#, $ #)

,## # #$#' ++,

,# # ## #) # # 5 $ ) ! # .(/ # # # # #) # # ++, ( #, # $ $ #

# - #$ . $ # . / , 2 ++, ( # #$# -

, ,.-# ) # ( #,

2, #.-# ,-# #.

#$#' # # ( #,

, ,- .-# ) # #.-# , ##$ -,#, # , # # ( . .- ## $ . $ # #

#- #$ # . / # 5 $ 9 -$ # $ $ #

# - #$ . $ # . / # # .# / # #) # # ,2 ++, ( # 2. # # - $ - # , # 2 # # $ #, $ -$2 , .(/

++, ( # # $ #

#- #$ # . / # # 2##$#' # #. / , $ #

#- #$ & / , # #$#' # #. .($ / #. #, $ #,# )# $ , #

#- #$ #. / ### -# $# . # / . . (#+ , # . # 2 , # ,# # # , . # , ' ($ # ' # , , 5! -$2

##$ # . # ) , . # ' #)# . )/ ## 2 . 2 # -# # .## , # #$ #$# # 2 # # # # #, #

#- #$ # . / , #$#' -/ 2 $ + # #

/>##. , / # /, 2 / #, #$# . / # # )# #!8/& # -- ,+ , ,) # - ,2 # # ) ## $ ## ' ? ) # #) # # ,

, #

#- #$ # . / # # 2 ,+ #$#' $ # ,. #, ## # ) # # , . ), # $ # (# #>. / , # ),/# # ..($ # )# / $ -#, # # 0.# ,# ' # / # . # .--# ),/ .# , 2 # # #$ # #/ @# ,# # / 2 # #$# ' $ #

# - #$ . / # #

, # # #)( # , , -- ##$# # , 5! $ 259! $ 9258 25 " # $A A ) ($# 1

Court dismissed enforcement of foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text