Court dismissed appeal regarding excessive fines for illegal possession of firearms and ammunition.
Estonia (EE)
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the first-instance judgment imposing fines for illegal firearm possession. The appellant argued that the fines were excessive and violated their rights, while the prosecution maintained the penalties were legally justified under the Criminal Code. The court upheld the original decision, ruling that the fines were proportionate to the severity of the offense and the circumstances of the case.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedCriminal Code § 140; Criminal Procedure Code § 259: The court may impose fines for criminal offenses, and such fines are not excessive if they are proportionate to the gravity of the crime and the offender's circumstances.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedFull text
!"#$ %!&'()
* +
#$,-.$/$
)#$0##,($$1,(")-,"
$$#'
),(),
(,#02)$330$,40, 5(16
"57"/1$#$#1$,#$#$330$,4
0,57"8 8"/1$
9((,'
(,#02)$$0:8;;<,$
.$$1$0#$<,-,,(),#,,,(<7'$$0,1*
($+<==70.<,(:<),-$-$#(
$-<',#0)$-$#,<(,!! !
#0,0)()
$,#$#>$$0:8%; 5<,$
.$$1$0#$<,-,,(),#,,,(<7'$$0,1*
($+<==70.<,(:<),-$-$#(
$0&'()%!! !,14
8(1"/1$($,)#1$,1$#1$-$$ ,
,"1<',#0>)$-$#,<(,!! !
#0,0)(($0,
!"
*+
(,#02)"$,#$#'$1,-'$457"/1$($,(<!!
!7-$,7$$#)()$$$(!
(,#02)'$1,-'$4 "/1$($,(<!!!)//(,-$,!
$,#$#'$1,-'$48 8"/1$<!!!,)/1$)(($-,7#,-$,!
(,#02)330$##$04 "/1$"$0,0*+($,
)#1$,1!
(,#02)330$##$04 5(1"/1$"$0,0*+
($,)#1$,1!
(,#02)330$##$0457"/1$"$0,08*(-,$+
,)#1$,1!
48(1 (,((1,0,1,-0$,0,,$-$,1#$#1
-'$(,#02)$($$$,$,10,1-$,,8*(-,$+
)#1$!
4;(1(,(),,()#1$,)$$.$0,1>5!!! !<!87/,)"
8!5!! !<! 7/,)$"(#$#1(1,0(,#02)$(
#0-$,(,() *,$+*3,$+0" 7/,))#1$!
($0',#0"/--#$#1),0(,#02)$)#1$,#0-$,
"(1,-)$-$,<!(,!! !!
$,#$#330$##$0457"/1$"$0,08*(-,$+
,)#1$,1!
40,(1 "%5(1(,(,#00-'$,0$&'()
%!! !,1-'$,0$,/#0-0" ;7/,)
)#1$)'#$#1-'$$,#$#$($$$,,"/1$8
*(-,$+*)$$+0" ;7/,))#1$!
4;(1(,(),,()#1$,)$$.$0,1>!;!! !<!87/,)"
8!5!! !<! 7/,)$"(#$#1(1,0$,#$#$(
#0-$,(,()8*(-,$+*)$$+0" 87/,))#1$!
($0',#0"/--#$#1),0$,#$#$)#1$,#0-$,"
(1,-)$-$,<!(,!! !!
/("-'$(,#02)$($$1$,,(),,:
+*3,+#$#0,6
+%;*,$,)$$0,3--,#0+#$-//0$"(,-0
,6
8+88 *)$$(-0(-3--,#0+#$",#$($,
,7,$$$(0,,6
5+85 *(-#,($3--,#0+#$",#$.$(1$
,7,$$$(0,,6
+; *3,$,03--,#0)$$+#$73$$
73(1$,7,$$$(0,,6
+8;*(-03,3--,#0,+#$5,#$$"(,$-$#($-$
-,"($7$,1,-$,(0,,!
/("-'$$,#$#$($$1$,,(),,:
+*3,+#$#0,6
8*+
+%%*,$,,$,03--,#0+#$-//0$"(,-0
,6
8+85 *(-#,($03,3--,#0+#$",#$($
,7,$$$(,6
5+85 *(-#,($3--,#0+#$",#$.$(1$
,7,$$$(0,,6
+; *3,$,03--,#0)$$+#$73$$
73(1$,7,$$$(0,,6
+8;*(-03,3--,#0,+#$5,#$$"(,$-$#($-$
-,"($7$,1,-$,(0,,!
$-$#(-,#,(,
(0
0
#0-$#$,,$-$
),(0),(,
#
85;%,$9$7#1*)$$,#-., ;5;%5+"((,
,"'-$,!
/("-'$(,#02)$("$,#$#$(($0,(88*(-
(-0+#$!!-,(0,,!
3#0-(/)',00,$7("<-$)0'#&($,$7,?,$
&'()7($,$"##$',#0$,$-$</)$0!
3#0-0$1$((),,1*@A+7("/$-$#(""0,!
7,(($#$'$1,-$,)$(,.&'()-"(,,0
$"($( ;!! %!!
,7,(,)'$.,$07,(($#$$#1##(,
&'()-"07/,)"((,7/,)<-$(-,#,(,7(,(#
)'$-($)0,1<)$0330$))'$,-$"1)'$.
,$07,(($#$330$)(,,7$/,#0-$,(,"/1#,)7/,)
7/,)"(!
$-$#(-,#,(,(0,3)$-$,,)'$.)$0(0,,(0$
3-#,7/,)"((,,(-$,-//,.,,$-$,,,(
&'()-"(,!
!
####################################$
!!!
4(1,(),.$,-'$-$,(7,(,$$33),,(
,1,#0)$0",#0)$0"($0<)'$-(-'"0330(,07$0$$0-
33,10,$-,7#,-$,"'$1$-$,)$$0!
$,#$#$#),-$-$#($0((,$-,,-,$,
,,(#,)(-$,(.0)"-$,,,*06(8;%8;;<8;8+!-$#,0
0)($0)//,10,,,<",((,-'$,0)$0#$$#$
-*06(8+!
5*+
!,#$#$$,1,#0)0"(070)0<$0,-$,#0)
-$,,$($,"(#4;7(,(33,$-,7#,-$#,17$7(<
!!2)$1!
#$-,7##0,"(($(-,$,<-$((,,,#,0#0"
$,#,,#/$#0; ,)#1$,)'$,(,1,)#1$,!
),0,"(<,!,#$##$-,)/1,$$),$,,-0,(<
,((,7/(,$.<,,0#.,$0,07$0$,33,10,
$-,7#,-$,$0-$,"'$1$-$,)$0,/"($,)#1$,1<-$((,
7$7,"//-,((,,-$,-//(/,0(,!
#!,#$##$-,7##0-')7/&'()%!! !,
(-$<!),(,"(1,<$$(,.((,-'$($$$(/0,
40,(1 " #$#1%5(1/,,!
!,#$##,,()#1$,)$$.$#0!;!! !*06(%+<!87/,)"
8!5!! !*06(88%+<! 7/,)#$#1,,'(,.7/,),,()#1$
(1,04;(1(,(,-$"(!
(,#02)$,$(,),-$-$#($0<$0,0#),-0)(
$0)//,10,,,*06(5 58+!
!2)$$,1,#0)0"(070)0<$0,-$,#0)
-$,,$($,"(#4;70,8"(,(33,$-,7#,-$#,
,0)(#,-,$,,$,$$,>$,1#,$",$//$
,#$#1-')$-,7#,-$#,17$7(!
/0,,,(#,)"),0,$,10,,-0,$-,7#,-$<(,$.<,!
2)$(,.$0,07$0$,33,10,$-,7#,-$,$0-$,"'$1
$-$,)$0,-$/"($,)#1$,1<-$((,7$7,"//-,((,,-$,
-//(/,0(,!
!2)#,,()#1$,)$$.$#05!!! !*06(85+<!87/,)"
8!5!! !*06( ; +<! 7/,)#$#1,,'(,.7/,),,()#1$
(1,04;(1(,(,-$"(!
!%
!!#,$#01$ 330$),)!!-,(0,>88#$
3)$-$,!
(,$.<,#01$#7'",#00"(.(0-$,(,B40, (1" 6
8%(1658#$#15(17(,(!330$)0,$(,))$,(#0-,(0,
,(,!
,,1(,.!!$!!-,($0#0#0$$(,-'(,-(330$)(
($0,()/("-'$88#$,$0",!
%
3#0-(<!!,$<)',00,$7("<-$)0'#
&($,$7,?,$&'()7($,$"##$',#0$,$-$<()0/)$-$,(,
4 (1875"(1(,($)//,0"0!
*+
3#0-0$1$((),,1*@A+7((,."/$-$#(""0,4
(187(,(!
%!
/,(,)$-$#(",$#,)0"/1-$,0-,#,((0<-$#,0330$)
!2)$1:330$-'$),1#,)#0>#$<$$1$
'$1.$-//0$",(,-0>%;*0<(58 <585+#$<
($0,7,$$$(0>88 <*;5C;: D88 <60<(860<(
85+#$<.$(1$,7,$$$(0>85 <*;: D85 <60<( ;"
;%+#$<73$$73(1$,7,$$$(0>; * 8: D; 6
0<( 5+#$#$#1$"(,$-$#($-$-,"($7$,1,-$,(0>
8;<5*0<(%+#$!
/,(,)$-$#(",$#,)0"/1-$,0-,#,((0<-$#,0330$)
!,#$#$1:330$-'$),1#,)#0>#$<$$1$
'$1.$-//0$",(,-0>%%*5C8C5D%%6
0<(8;8; <58<55%+#$<($,7,$$$(>85 <*;: D
85 <60<(8+#$<.$(1$,7,$$$(0>85 <*;: D
85 <60<( ;" ;%+#$<73$$73(1$,7,$$$(0>
; * 8: D; 60<( 5+#$#$#1$"(,$-$#($-$-,"($
7$,1,-$,(0>8;<5*0<(%+#$!
#4;(1,(3)$.330$-'$),(-,#,((0
330$-'$,<,((,7/-'$.4%(170,8<5<"#$#14%(1
7(,(-'(,-(330$)()/(",,(-/1$0$-$#(-,#,(,(0/$,($(!
,,1,-$,("$#040,8>88!
#$:
)#$0: