1-07-4214\2 · Court dismissed execution request against a foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects. (Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tartu Regional Court dismissed the execution request filed by a foreign creditor against a respondent in Estonia. The court found that the foreign court lacked jurisdiction over the respondent and that the original proceedings contained significant procedural defects. Consequently, the court refused to recognize and enforce the foreign judgment under Estonian law.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment shall not be recognized or enforced if the foreign court lacked jurisdiction or if the judgment was obtained through procedural defects.

Keywords

AI generated

foreign judgment recognition lack of jurisdiction procedural defects execution request dismissal civil procedure law

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.

Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Full text

! " # $ $% ! &' $

( () $ &# #( + ' #, ' -' $ #

# . ! '((# / $ # / 0 #

# - $ 3 # / 0 # # - 444444444444444445 +44444444444 !"#$%&"" '()*+,-'(.)+.- /

0 1 2 ,3+ )44*++ '*5+) ,6 7 0 + ! .# #/ .. #(# # '$ # + #! .. #0 (.#/ ! 3 # (.#/ 3 / + / .. # # + /'(+# +

"#$8 !!%#$!9& , '

+2

#$ 6

! 6 7 #((# # # # 89! 8!.$! # ' # # 86

$ .## + #$ #/ $ ' #+ # + 867 $

# 2 6

#$ ' #+ + # 7 /# / $ #/' ! # #

#!.$ ' #* / $ 8 7 $ ( # ' #, ' # # '+! '$ #. /' # 6

!' 6 + / #$ $ 6! ## '(#0 86 $ ( # .. /: ! , ' + , ' / # + # 3 # *# # # / $ #$ 3 # + 9 7 7 2 ##$ #( ++ ## ####

#$ ' #+ $ # + # ! 3 # ! 2 $ # , ' $ #

# . ! '((# / $ # / 0 # # / + ' # , ' + # # #3 # / 0 # # / #0

)) #3 #( ! 3 + /#!

3/.###/' '(( #+ 0# /## # 3

# 2 # #!+#!.. # # 0 # '$# ### #3 # / ! # / # #$# %

#; ! 7 # #

/+# , ' / # # '( $ + / # + 3# ##+#+ '0 + # +3## ' )# + 2 #+ . (! (. ' '0 ## 3 /.$ (! , ' / # #0 # (0 ## $ #! ' ! ( ##())+ # (# 2 $ # + ! $ # 3 # , ' # # /

/'$ 3# /(##3)) # # (

! / 0 + %) / + # 3 # , ' / # + #+ ( ++ # # ! + # (0 ## +# '3 / + / # ' #$+# '/ # ( ++ /..#$3 #

# # $ ##

0 / 3 # #$+# #( # #!.0 < '# / # , (0 ## $ # #3 +# .#, + # # # /'$ # + / 0 # ## + # '$ # =# ('! # ## ()#

#. #$ #/ 0 , ' #(

+! +

+# # ## #( # # 8 6 $ ( # /'0 # # # # #( # # + ' #+ # ! $ $ #

#. #$ / $ # / 0 + 3 + ' # #$# .

+ +/.# ( # ' #+ ! 3+ #/.# + .# #/ ! , ' # # ' #+ ! + +. /.# ( #! #/.# + ##$ .+#+ # + # # ' //. ## $ / $ # #

#. #$ # / 0 # 86 $ !.$ # ! $ $ #

#. #$ / $ # / 0 #

# /# 0 # #( # # ! +3 + ' # 3/ # # . $ . # + # ! 3 # # $ ! #+ $ !.$3 + /'0

+ ' # # $ #

#. #$ # / 0 # # 3#, ' ( #( ++#$+#(# # ('! #

+ # # / 3 # 0 # # '# + # # (

#( ++91 # + # ! / # ! #(# 0# &

# # # / # # (

+ $ # + '## #$3 # / # #( ++## #### # ' #+ # ! 3

# # #+ / #$ !0# ! # =##+#+ #( ++ 7! 6 ##$ , ' / # +(# # #

# # . # # 6 #3 + # (## #+ # # #+ .$ +! #(# (0 ## .# #/ ! , ' * ' +# /. !# + +

/ 0+ 3+ # +*/## / $ # 3+ , '

#+ # / #0 , ' /.+#3# $ #+(# ! ##+ ( ##0#+ 3# #

/- 6 #+ $ ! + # 3 + # # # / ( # ! # # # # # + 03 # # #$ ! + #$# # ( # # '! / # + #/ $ # # ( # # #

/ '! / + + , > # # #+ ( ( #0 # ! 3#/ #### # #.$ + '$ #$ # / #/. ! ! ## / $ # / + !# .# + 3# $ 63 , ' # + ( 3# +/ # +3#, )) 0

3+ .0 / ! # +## < + #! .03#, ' /' # / /'$ +/ # +! '+# .03#/ # # / # # #, $ $ (0 ## # +! , + / # ! #$+# #( # # +# .# # # + 03 # , ' / # # ($# (+0 (#$ '$ # # # '! / ! + # # # ## 3 #+ '$ # # # # # # /' # # # #+ ( */# + # =# ! +# # 0 3#, ' #

#. #$ # / 0 # # + # # #('!# + + .. ##$# # ! + 86 $ 38 $ 387 38 6 " # $? ? ( '$# -

Court dismissed execution request against a foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text