Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-3320\5 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against deportation order, ruling that the applicant failed to prove a risk of inhuman treatment in Estonia.

Case Number 1-07-3320\5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Viru County Court rejected the applicant's appeal against a deportation order issued by the Migration Board. The applicant argued that returning to Estonia would expose them to inhuman treatment due to the lack of a family member there. The court found that the applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to establish a credible risk of such treatment upon return.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10(1)(a) of the Aliens Act 1994; s. 10(1)(b) of the Aliens Act 1994: Deportation is prohibited only if the alien would face a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment or would be unable to secure basic subsistence upon return.

Keywords

AI generated
Aliens Act 1994 deportation order inhuman treatment risk assessment family ties abroad subsistence rights appeal against deportation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10(1)(a) of the Aliens Act 1994
s. 10(1)(b) of the Aliens Act 1994

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                    !"# ""  $ "#     % &'( )     '""     *  "   +" ,     ! "  *    % (    " -.    -  "#    '-"# *  /#         (0%&0&%!1  ""234 351  66661,,1  "   2$

7 3   * '* '(8   + 1   + *)5-917

3   * '* '(8   + 11*)-917 5 4  :2'* '(8

  + 111 43  144  + 1 4  *)5-9174  45  '-'* '( 8 4

1   *)3-9137 3   %))  !8   + 3*)3-91 57    %))  !8   + 1*)-917

   '8 3 *)5  +-91-    5  1 //2   *8

155

  + 14*  *)   "#       //2 ("  )2 

 1    



5 +  *    -

 "  -  /    + *)#-22 -  + "  -2-)- 21"   )    2  -. )#"""  ""    " "2  +2*  2" -))   1+.#* 2 " #*    ("  )1,,-2 -.. -1+ "8

*)- ; -  "   ("  )2 //2 "#       

 1    +)-  2      -* #       -

 . /   - ! ! 6666* -    . 1 *"2  2 3-))    ("  )1 2 - 2*#-    2  -.. #""  1+  "855

*)- ; - "   ("  )2 //2 -  

 1    1"

  - "+ 2-  66661  2    .#       .  /    -  6666 * -     ;""+2  <+  -))   1 ;""+2 ) 2  1  "#"  "  4 1 1

# "  2 * "" 1"2  21.-2* 2 21+.#* 2 0  " #*   4   ("  )18   + )# 2 2  1- 2       -.. -1+ "8   + 14*)- ; - "   ("  )2 //2     

 1    

  + 6666 .0 '  ".# 12 

#-.#       ("   )1 #* 2       - 1 +  "  8   *) - ; - "  ("  )"  .  /#  1 1*))""   2/ * 21  2 /    "#   .   ("   ) *   *  -2  2 "#       2- ;  1 2"  2  1  . 2 +" ,  ("  ) //" . 2 2" " -  *  */    "  * 2        ,,- + ""2 . 2-2("  ) //2    / 2 = 3*471 "   21  -

-  ,,*+""   ""2 2("   ).  +  *  )#-2 * 2 //1 +  2    -.    )#" "" * ""  "2  2""  "  *""       ("  ) 2

 //2   21 2# *"  2 2  "" 2/ 2   = 437 "      21-. #* *2)1   2 #" 21"  -)2- /  2* ) *   *  1  -

-  * 2    * #*   1-     ("  )"  -   6* -  2  1  

      * 1*/  1("  )#    *    *)   = 

7  !"#  1    "  . 2 2 -)-

 -.. -  2  )-.  "   ) ("  )+"" 1  "  + ""2. - ;  28    *)*)  . 2 2" * 2       "#+ -   -      ("  )"-"       -

 . /  ! ! 6666*-    . 1 *"2  2"  3""  -))  + ""2" . 2 2 ("  )= 37 ! ! / = 7   - -  2     "  -)#-))  - 

 "" 1  "      .  - ;  2  8 55    *) * )   . 2  2 2 "  * 2          -

  .  /   0   6666     *    *2   "2  - " 334"" -))  . 2-2("  ) 2/ 2= 557*   0  / 2= 3537   / 2 "#- +"""

= 3457 + ""2" .  - ;  28   + 14*)*)  . 2  2 2" * 2      0 '  ".#  ,, * 

- #*  " . 2 2 ("  ) 2/ = 71  0 ' / =



71  *&  / =  71  *%  = 7/ =  71 . -210 '  . ".# ("   ) ("  ) //2. 2-2- 0 ' +  2'-  * . 2 - +"""

2   0 ' -  "   1" ("  )- . - ;  28

 *)* " )  . 2 2" * 2  ("  )   2 //   1    2-2 *" 2+ 2 -2    .   - "# "+ 2 2  2  * 21"#       "" -2 22 ("  )" "#  "2 -   21 2 "2+  ""#+ -  -  1,, 2* ""- 2 2 2   "# 1    -

-   2 

 

 -. 1  "# +-*    22  -     "#  1 //2 -("  )  //2  28

155

1 

 + 14*  *)  . 

  *- -  /#    -)# 22 9-.         - #1! !  - # 3  0   - #334" +.#* 2 2*  -2# 2    > # 2 2 !82 4*  1"#  "    $  (0%&0&%! //2. * 22$ 8

*)=" 7 *5= 7  -   ? 855

*)=  *7  -   ? 8   + 14*)=#7  -   ? 8  *)=#7  -       85

  .          2  =  7 * = 7 2-   12!84  -)# 22 9-.  . (0%&0&%!    =" 7 -   1

 854

   2    -    - 2 *-# 2     1 "  +)-*  @4    1 "  2*4+)-1"   2*+)-  (0%&0&%!%*)) 2= 7 1=/# 7 2* +)- -      . 2-#

+2 *) 1(0%&0&%!  *    2       ) *. ("  ) =  66667$   =  66667  ?  3! ! =  66667  * 3340  =  66667   - #2 ?

      3  2#  2  ='# 2     9- A B:   4 1  +     4551- 47!8 3

+ * 

+ 1  ? 4     2 ='# 2    9-AB:   4 1  +     4551- 47" + * 2   ? 5 43   2 ='# 2    9-AB:   4 1  +     4551- 472- & & "       ?   5   2 ='# 2    9-AB:   4 1  +     4551- 472- ! %2 "       ?  4   2 ='# 2    9-AB:   4 1  +     4551- 472-   *"       ? 54 5   2 ='# 2    9-AB:   4 1  +     4551- 472- % ("       * "#   & . 22 1/ *#"1  -2   **  " *.    #)-2   "# "  " "#   +""  .  2+

 ""  ' " "# 1 2 +

 "" .    ""-  !"# *    +)-*""    "# "     &+

 ""    !"# *  - / +)- *""   " )*)      "#  9

9%    . (""; 0 +                !"#   "# " ("  ) //2   * *) 1 //2 - +

 "" *)# 2              >)("  ) *- 22-"  2"  ""   -.    "# " *.  $       (""; 0 +