1-07-987\7 · Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's residence permit renewal. Asylum seeker failed to prove necessity of continued residence. (Viru Ringkonnakohus)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the asylum seeker's appeal against the administrative authority's refusal to renew their residence permit. The applicant argued that their continued presence was necessary for family reunification and integration, but the authority found no evidence supporting these claims. Consequently, the court upheld the original decision, ruling that the applicant did not meet the legal requirements for permit extension.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2005; s. 10 AsylG 2005: An applicant for a residence permit based on family reunification must substantiate the necessity of their continued presence; failure to provide sufficient evidence results in the refusal of the permit.

Keywords

AI generated

asylum seeker residence permit family reunification necessity administrative appeal dismissal integration requirements burden of proof asylum

Cited Legislation

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2005

Full text

!" #$ %& '

(%)% '"&!"*" $

%'#+#

&'

#, #' '--

.%-

/"

#$&"&#%"%"

'--

"/

#%"/

&"&#%"%"

!

" #$%&'%#&&(

)

*+ *+

,

*

)

%

*

#&%&#%#&&(

-

'$%&&%

*

,-

%

."./".!0

#,'--

"%&# .%-

/"

#"#"&0 #' "

1

#

1

#%"/ ', #' ##%"

##%"

'#%#

#' "

%&' #

.%

-

/"

#")

- /"'%"

" #

""

#& 3 ." 1 4

11 5

" #

& ,66,7 '"%

#"#"& &8&

'"# %"" #&##% %##/

$"'/

- /"&"%

# &" %"&'" &) ' %%" #%"'" $--&

""%

"" %"'#

- /"' 66

' %$ $ 9%" %# .% -

/"

: ; % $-

% < #""

#

#"# '"1"' ")'%&

%"3." 1 4

11 '"%#$% 0'-

#

- /"&"%

# &" #%$# %''&"%

# &"##% %#

%"&'"#" " #' ") ' %%" #%"'" $- & '&"

""%

"" %"'#

;==6

.%-

/"

"

$##&$"%/&

" %>" )*%" )*%&)8&

'&?%#"#/

#, /.%-

/"

%"

' %'""#%"#

""#%"$ ?%"" ?/

$% "%" $ #"%"< #""% "&##& #"#"%" .% -

/"

"

"""

$'""#%"$$

&"" %'#""&##&.%-

/"

#$%"#"%"<

#""%) " - # ) "# .% -

/"

/ / ""

" "

#" ""

@2&"

# .%-

/"

"#"' #$

' %$'""#%"$%""%%"##"& #

" #&" %"

.% -

/"

#" % $"' % , 6, 1

'--

"

%&#&&#' #.% #" %.%-

/"

# &%'--

#)#"& 1 &&

$&#' #%&&" "#&

.

##%"/.%-

/"

#' #)%#"#/

#,.%-

/"

1 &"%# &&

$%" %/& %'& '""#%# ' #" #"#' "

$ $

&"

##" %'' " 1$"& # " #& " %" ##"

"" #%## %'"%"#

%" &' #

' %'""#%"#)#"' '& )

#"

#' "$% &)

%#

#)"#/&" / &" /#$-#%# &&

%"#""%"#

' "#$

##

?%#" ,.%-

/"

## #

%" & ) "# 1

#' ##% " ##& 1$"&#%# $ %/

%&' "%" 1

##%" " ##& %#"% " 1 && $% #' "

%" &

#

#,'--

"1"%"" #'--

"/" #$&"&#%"

%") " 1% #9 #& '# #' '--

#%## .% -

/"

#' "

! !1!!.2

#$ " # 1

- #") "# .% -

/"

##% %# $ '$ 1$"#

&&

%"

' %'""#%"# .% -

/"

% %& $ 1

" # " &

#"

"1

/%""'")' %&1$"'""#%"$$

&"' ##" %'' ")"%%"#

" ##&

# #"&" &) '""#%"$%" 1

%"$""&% #&

' %$

'#"

$% &"%"""#%"$"1

" %"

& &&)"#.%-

/"

1%#" ##&

# #"& & / '#& ' " & #- "& & &' #-1##"

# #"& #"

" #' "" ##&" %"

:6-#"#/&" & #' '--

"%"

:6%1;"%#'-

#"

#' '--

" #' " 1$"& #$ " %) "# '

#' '--

"#""' "%

&!8

#=%1A-#"###)

&.%-

/"

#' "#1%#'# ""

'#)' ###" .%-

/"

#' #- #%"&

"&%

#$%" /)"#

#"#%"1$"&#1"/# "'

' %# '

""#"#"%"

'#"

$% &"%" $ #' '--

" " 1

&& 9" 9"%"% " #&"'") "#

# ' '#"

$% &" 1 %# %"' 1$"&#&

#"#% " %"

#' '--

"

' ##"

&&

9"%"% "

#&"'"

1$"&#&

#"#%"" "' "#)

-- '# #' "#

""#"#"%"

' %$# '

%"#"%"'#"

$% &"%" #' '--

" #-#%#'""#%"$1%##%"#&

' %$ '#"

$% & $-"#& " #'#

"" '

& #' "

"&% " "# #' '--

" && #' %"

' %'""#%"#

%" &' # $ #"

#"&" # '"1"' " $-#' # .%

-

/"

1%#)" #'##&%"%"'%#9#" 1$"&#

#$ '-

/) "# ' %" 1 &&

"#') "# #""' # " % ,#"

$#%###" %"

&

' %

##&

!1!!.2 2

# # %1"%%#)&#%"%$- ''--

"/"$"/"

#&&1$"&#"$

&"

1

#

1

# %"/ %" & #) "# #' '--

1$"&#&$#"&"%#"%)' #' '--

"#&&.

1%

"#&)

"#

$%1%"%& '%#-

/"

&"%"< #""%-

/"

%&

$ $ %/& %" #%% 1%" #%& $ "& 1%" 1$"&&

# ' '--

""%&/

#' '--

"

#""' #

-

/"

/

%"

' %'""#%"# .

1% $-## #' '--

'#'# $ #$

'--

"/

%&'#

%& -

1

$ #$) ##& '--

"/" '#"

$% &")

#$'--

"/"#&&1$"&#")%" /)"#'--

"/

%&' "%"" %

'" #

1$"&/$-

' "%#>

!'%#

#/ #$- &")"#" -#1

##%"# #' "

%"#"

#"&"$-#%## '"1"' #) &9"

' %'""#%"#- &"##

%" &' #) ' ### %"#%# % "&& - &"# & #' " %"

%" &$% &B%;B

''--

"%" &&)"#.-

/"

"

"""

#"#"%"

$$

&")

?#& '# $-

"%& " %" %

'--

"/" '#"

$% &")

$ ## # %#' " '--

" B % 6 B)

#' ##%"B%B$ " # #' '--

"-

'-

#&)

"#=,&"# .%-

/"

%"&

" %"" )*%" )*%&8&

'& #- #&

$ #" ?$"' ,, ,

$

&

"& %" " "&##& ,

' #" #-#$

'22&' "% "& 0 , &"# .% -

/"

%" &

" %" " ) *

%" )*%&8&

'&#- #&

$#"?$"' % ,

,

$ &

"& %" " "&##& ,

' #"

#-#$'22&' "%B%)6)6B

'% $%) #'# 9%%#&%")

%" /) "# #%## .% -

/"

#' "1$"&#&'" #

'# ""

/$-

' "%#>

#%#

:6% 0%" )#%## 99& ## / #&1

#

##%"% $ ""%

' # '--

" %"% #'--

" %"%) # /

' %'""#%"#

%" && $-#%## '"1

#" &.

# % "%#""

#-"&/) "# %"' 9 9%%#&& %#"# ) #' # #%"/ 1 &&

"&%

'% $%) %"' #' " %"&) " %" $%

#%### #&) 1"/

"#'$% &)' %"#%"#&

:

0#"& % ' "

) #&" . -

/"

#) %" & ) "# 1$"&#&) "# / &" /&"

-

/"

/

' %'""#%"#

%" &&$-#%## '"1

#" &

#/ #$- &")"#'#%1&%%"&)"# / &"

/&" -

/"

/ # '" 1

#" &) #" "%# 1%# # $-

"%&) "#

-

/"

&/

' %'""#%"#

%" 1$"&#& ) #&"

#&'# '--

")%" /$% -

'-

&)"# #$'--

"/"

#/ "%%"%") "# "'/

# B,B #-" 1-" .-

/"

/ /

% ""

@2&"

# #"

##"$)"###""" ##& #$1%#'""#%"$%"

,$'# 1

%"$

%"B%;B

'%$% #$

$-#&#-"%"1#)"#$/=,.-

/"

%"% &"#&#- #&

$#")'

###

,

' #"

#-#$

'22&' "%

,

&"#

.-

/"

%"""%9#- #&

$#")' '# ### ,

' #"

#-#$'22&' "%B1

#' ##%)%B " &&'" &"%%"#)"#%#"

= , .-

/"

/ "" @2&"

# #"

##") " %"

#%#

: ,; % %" ) "& %// & -%$ #&

' #")

#

$ #"

< ' #" % " &""& & "&##&

#" .

#' ##%"# -#/) "# 6, "&## .-

/"

%"

#"%"< '/

%"=66;% "%##"$

- "%%")"###/ %'';

"'/

% , "%% 0 $ %% '"#

' 8& #% #"

$# 1"#

?%"" ?/ $

&" &

" % ) 6 9%"%' "%"

#%## B% B .% -

/"

;, " %'& $ ' ##" %'' " 1$#"#

'""#%"$%"" #"#&

'"#"-

/"

#"%"< '/

%"% "%#% &"#&

,' %%"1"%"-

/"

" %"

"""

&?#&$% & #&1

'#

# # % 3%%#& #/) "# .-

/"

% #"&% ) "# #"&

##"

' #") " %'& $ ' ##" %'' " 1$#"# '""#%"$%" "

#"#&?

"#&"9%%#&#)

%" /)"#'#%% 1 %

#)"#

.-

/"

&/

%"

' %'""#%"#$""1-

#'#'--

"&%

#/ #$

'")"#

:;=%1-#"#/)"#'--

'""#%"$

$% %#

' ##& $ 1 ##& '""#%# #$ %" /) "# '#

'--

" %"1$"&#& %" /)"#'#'--

1$"&#&0.

C$ "& B%;B

'-

/)"#' ##"#' "#1$"&#"" #-"&""%)"#'--

" %"'# ""

#&

D " #$ %" - &") "#

#"#%" 1$"&# 1"/ # "'

' %# '

""#"#"%"'#"

$% &"%"$ #' '--

"" 1

&&9"

9"%"% " #&"'") "# # ' '#"

$% &" 1 %# %"' 1$"&#&

#"#%

'%$%#%"/

"#&)"#

' #"%" %& '%

& 9%"

%#.-

/"

#$""1-

#& #

' %$#&#"& #"%"" %" "

*-#&"""%#&#$$ &&"

::6;%61E6E6

%" /)"#

'--

"/

%&' "%"" %

%& '

(%!"*" %'#+#

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's residence permit renewal. Asylum seeker failed to prove necessity of continued residence.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text