Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-12550\17 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding detention of foreign national under asylum law.

Case Number 1-06-12550\17
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the administrative decision ordering the detention of a foreign national. The appellant argued that the detention violated their rights under the Asylum Act and the European Convention on Human Rights. The court found that the administrative body had correctly assessed the risk of absconding and the necessity of detention based on the specific circumstances of the case. Consequently, the court upheld the original decision as legally sound and proportionate.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2005; s. 10 of the Asylum Act 2005: The court established that administrative detention of a foreign national is permissible if there is a concrete risk of absconding and no less restrictive measures are available, provided the detention is not arbitrary or disproportionate.

Keywords

AI generated
administrative detention asylum seeker risk of absconding proportionality principle European Convention foreign national procedural review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 AsylG 2005
Art. 5 § 1 (e) ECHR
Art. 5 § 3 ECHR

Cited Case Law

AI generated
Case C-199/02, R. v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Adan
Case C-200/02, R. v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Brind

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                   

           

   ! "# $$% &'  

     ()$%)   !*   +,      - .'"    

  

 ! !*//*!*011+-*              2   *2 *  '*2 3 *"" !44'* 2, " '+''!'*'!*!!   

 ,!!'*,,   !"#$%&    

      '((    

 )* +  

,  .*! ! *!! * &44! !*!"* ' 2*  ! !*()'* ! ++' *&  !*" !!!'**! -+!*#056'-( !! !!''. *! *"*'' +!+ &'! "!, *"*''+ + ' ,',  '' !  - #'- "!! '!"* !  - .       .    . )* +,

'+".*!  ! !*'!-*!'  ""(7 '*!!,8*+



.*-#*'))7!!/8*+6$ !*   + .*-#*' !' # ! /   +' '!  !!  +.!"* !

"**! *"* , '  ($$$91$$$(5 3*&-2 ,! "#  $$$1:16 ! - '!"*!! !"* '#! !!*!*' !*!"*  !      !!  & '  ,.*# *! & ''!* #  ''*

*-!' !(6& ,+''!  & ,!2 *          

/ 

  0,,), ,       .   

 ! !*!//*!! 011+-*,'*;*! *!,*! !*" & "* 2"*  *   '' 2 ! ! "2 ''  **2    5$$$9 &' ! &'! *!!  0 11 ' ' "!.** +#  +!*"*  !2 +!* ! ''*+#  (9$6$$%  '' (9$ +' &' " <<< ' ,* <<< "+ +  **'* .*!!=  -"$$: 

  ! !* // ! "'  **"* *! *!  !*" & "*   &4* *-' !. !+-"*! !. *! -> ( $   

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

 5,0,6, ,    ! !* , " *!!  ! B!'%)5B       

  .  

 

 ! !* ! "'  *!!//*! //* *!*!2 *' ,!(9$6$$% ''*+#  '  !'* ' ''* !,*! ! ''  , !'! & '  + +."*!.*- & '!+.*&''*,+,@**&-*'*+."! * ''C/"*!"*!*!D2*&'*! *!44!+!!'*! " !2/**" ! + &*C&"D //*!!,!!' ''+-"* !*!+> , $   7   /!'!  '!-*!(9$6$$%.!'"! * !  ! !*!+!' "!  -7E,"*!*!8& '  .*!*

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

 '//*!   ! !*  ' *!)'" !* *! '* $2$ "*''*-""* ''* /  '!* ,'+*-!, . ?#  ** !,!"*  + +# !" 

 ""* *-+# !" ""* ! ,*'!"* 0(:'-9 '!  ''* *&'! - "*! "* +# - *& !. '* 2 ! ''* +,  *! *//' &'!*+ '!,*'2E! -, "&*"*!*+' +". !'!,!+'+!@**+-*!C-F*D   ! !*' !*,*!B!'%)5B"!.**''*+# +!*"*  !2! "! - ,.*- !*,'*;*! *!011+-*           ; 

 ! !*!*" & !" *! 2"*'' /*!'*.'!# !*  ! ! ! *' !. ' ,'+' **!//' **!'!&+& - !-*-*,*.*!*!44'!+2''   .*!""*!,.*! '+ ,  ' "' ''* ! *-' *  ! " // ! *!  ! !* *!   !!!  , +  - , +' //'  *!"*  &,  ! !*, "'-*'***"**!*" &2 *&   ,.*"'* !  *! !** !! !  - "2  '*  *! - /'' -  !!#  ! ".*! !,! ,-*! !  0 51 '-( ' ' !*-*"**,#!2  ! !*!44!#*-! "/''&*"* ''"'!     !*>   +,