4-06-4495\5 · Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding the applicant's right to reside in Estonia. (Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu County Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative body's decision to deny residence rights. The applicant argued that the administrative body failed to properly assess the necessity of the residence permit under the relevant Act. The court ruled that the administrative body correctly applied the law and that the applicant's arguments did not justify overturning the original decision.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Act on Residence in Estonia; The administrative body is not required to grant a residence permit if the applicant fails to meet the statutory requirements for the specific type of permit sought.

Keywords

AI generated

residence permit administrative appeal residence rights Estonia law burden of proof

Cited Legislation

AI generated

s. 10 of the Act on Residence in Estonia

s. 11 of the Act on Residence in Estonia

Full text

!"#$

%&'()$(*+(,& & ($$ (

!"#)-./$( *(().(0 -)(" $0 ,1

(( '($)

-( $$

&&

! (+$

(

"./)$(/2(3(!)/

($$ (

2"./)$(/0 "$!" 0#)/-!"$) +(. ((./$ 4# '/ ,1&&,

")$$(.(

(().$ .( /$/! && *(().$ .$( /$/! .(2/5./(

! /)$0

. '

$6

!"#)-./$(

*(().(0

(

"./)$(/2(3(!)/ ($$ (2"./)$(/0 "$!" $!"#)"$$/

1 ($$ (

($/' 0 0#)/-!"$) +(.((./$4# '/

&'()$(*+(,& &

4)) ! (+$ #.' * ) &

! 4)) *)* ) ("./)$(/2(3(!)/ ($$ (2"./)$(/0 "$!" 0#)/-!"$) +(.((./$

4# '/ !""$) )' ,1&&,& & ")$$ !"#)-./$( *(().(0 -)(" $0 ,1

&&! /$) */$($.//!.$$( '$(71,,.5805/ #) #-/5 %) #-/9#/!)$"!""/0

.//!.$$( '$(71,,.505/./$ ! /$)$(5 0#)/*/$:/5$( -:)*/$(!$8!!$&

)$$( 2( .( -:/+ !"#)*(().$( 2"". - '( '-"! '/$) ($/' 0 - #('$(. ($/) '

! $$ )$/""! (+$( //5/!"#).( 8 2(- 0""!$. . )($ ")$$( !.) */$($) 0 ")$$( !"#)$

))-*/$(!$ !))($ */$( 2(- $)& $$ )$/"":/5$( $""-/$) ).(+ 1 2(- 0""!$. !/0 ./!.)

)( ) ' !"#) ($$ (!"#)* 0 .( . )($!"#)")$$(!.) */$($)&

,

"#)")$$ " !"#) ($$ ( !"#)* 0 ! )$(.(/$ $!"# 5 "$$/ , ($$ ($

))-*/$(!$!))($ ' - . )($%&'()$(*+/$),& &

($".(- $ $0 $ 2;; + !"#)")$$( )/)*/$(.( $ * $ -)(" $0 $ ($* !"'$(.) . #('/ )(/'

!"#)-./(*(().(0 &

"#"$

( "./)$(/2(3(!)/ ($$ ( 2"./)$(/0 "$!" 0#)/-!"$) +(. ((./$ 4# '/

!""$) )' ,1&&,& & ")$$(5 ! /$) )/ &&! .//!.$$( '$(

7 1,, .5 8 05/

# ) #-/5 % ) #-/9#/!) $" !""/ 0 7 1,, .5 05/ ./$ ! /$)$(5

0#)/*/$:/5$( -:)*/$(!$8!!$&

)$$($)#)+6()&&!! /$) )/-)("*(().$($$(..((($)6()) 0#)/$8&%&,& &

!(.. & /#). - .. $ ( * !" $ /$)//)$ /- $) ($$ ( )(( ,8&

!/."*(()/.

.//!'($

/$)/

$ $

*"")"$:/'!/)

!//$(5 6

*/$

9.() $

.//!.$!" .'$- #('/5 .+ )' !*<#

$:/'!//$)*/))(- #(*!/!*<#6$:/)($

!//$(5 =< !*<#6 */..(5 /!!$ .//!.$(($!/0 7 , 2 8 :'(/'6 2 ($ )"/*(

-)("6*/$"!- ./3/)$((/) -.//!.$$( '$(71,,.5805/&

,&&,& & ($/) $ && ((./*() )' ")$$( 2( .( ! (+$( * !"#).(6 ) ").('($

!"#)-./$(*(().(0 ")$$()9#/$) */$)./$ ! /$)$(* */$("$ $&

(+$($*5/) !$(6()-)(" $0 $($/) )'!/0 ./!$- $). $($$(.5/) $&&2:#0 ./!.)

)(* 2"".) )"/*(2 '' :/5$/!!*/$( $0 ".$/'& && (. + & - .. $ & !9. $ 0 );;) +

($$ ($ $- $ & $) - .) ! (+$(.( ./$ )' );; '0 ):('/.( ((.' - ' &&

/5 2(- $(' );;9.($ '(' *"")"$:/'!/ 0#)/*/$)& 4#)/*/$:/5$( -:)*/$( !" . "

);; '0 $/)' ! .* );;) 0 5 );;.(2/5 .:2() */$)& *)/ ((.' + $0 ".6 ()

*(().$ .( /$/! (. + -.0 $2"". ($$ ()6 /5 2(- $(.) (.!"'./!( - 0 '$)(

#.' */$(!$*"")"$:/'!/! $) */$)&

)$$($ " *5/)'6 () && ! /$)$) !(5(' - $0 ". )(* 2#)$9' *./!!

! #()$$)& ($".(- !$ 0 !$ " 2:#/! /$)$( * )' # ) #- && 2"".) ) $)'&

(.)""' .$(.0 -($) '($ 7.5*5/)'! /$) */$( .$(/'"*(().$ .(

/$/! $(/$!"# .6 () )(* .( ./$ ! /$)$( * */( (/ ".( 2:#0(' )'& /$)$( *:/$)*/$(

(($*5/!$ (/ )"#/ ".. ! /$) ) - .( .//5$()( 0 2:#0(' * ))( */()$)( 0 !/)$('$)(

)(!/) */(& && $(/$!"# .6 () ")$$($ *5/)' 9.'$: ./( 2:#0('$ ./$ ! /$)$(

!"# .' */$( !"#) (/ ".( !"!(()$( -)(" $0 2#. $0 !"# $('& :#0$( *5/)'

:/5$!" ! /)$*/$(9.'#-/""* $/$.)'(!. )//-(&

"#)/$)5/.0/&&! (+$(0'(&

%&'#"%

"#)-./(*(().(0 .(/ +6()! (+$(/!. #.' */$(.(<)&.&,<&

&&2#.(/".')(5(*/$)*//* .$(!//$(9.() */$(5 &(5(*/$)"./*/))(-#(*6!/

!*<#-: .+ )'!//$(9.() */$(5 >!*<#

& ($".(- . 0 ."! *(('/ ! '

( *$(.( )( ' 6 () !//$( 9.() */( " 2:#0$) ' */)*(/' 3 ) .$( ) 5 00(5

.//!.$:()$/& 5('($ -)("2")"!"../.) && 9).$/ -)(" )"/*(2 (*/$( $0 ".'(

!"#) ).(+*!/' 6($/)(!$6()&&")/$) '"* $99'/52:#0('$(!$")""'?

@&&&) #)$/ !// 299' & 2( )$($ .///+$$/6 */..(5 */ )9) $:/)/$ ../ $$(& /*(.)

)9) $) $*"+//.)(.(3"/*/ )"$$(@& /'. $)/(/$ /*() )'2:#0('$)!(5(' -

$0 ". -($) ' /5)(5(*/$)(/".'! 0#' $(/$'/5 ! /$)$$( '$)/!*:))($&

A/5$!" ! /)$*/$( #-/'( -($) */$(. (/ ".( !"#)-./( *(().(0 ) #)' &&

! /$) */$(5 )(/$)(.(/$/!)(.(#/*) - ))"/*() - .' ' 6!/'!"#)-./(*(().(0 "$//

8

2/' '(($*!/ - .' ' :/5. $(! /$)$(5 *:06*/$$(' !$//*($)(

$!"*/!(#)/-$$(0 $ .'$):/5$!" - $)&

(().(0 "! $) '"* ! .).$:/5$)6*/$#)+//2:#/! /$)$(6!/! ./$ ! /$)$(

* $)6 */$ (/ ".( * !$/* .( - /' !($!*/$( * .#(' (& (().$ .( /$/! "./

- .' '! #()$$)0 !(5(' - $0 ". $(' ! -($) )/&( '$ '0 " ''$(.5('

2///'! /$)$)(!"# .' */$(!$0 (/$2//($2( +! *(().(0 "* ")$$(/')(5(* &

"#)-./$( *(().(0 .(/ +6 () &&.( * )' ! /$)$ " 2"2")$/" .( 0

:/5$2 (/5./$ ! /$)$(!"# .' */(2:#0(' )'&

%%

"#$"..($))-'-)(" $0 * )(0 ./'(5 /5 !. '*(().$"$ ./$)($(.()$('

.(/ +6 () ! (+$ !"#)-./$( *(().(0 ")$$( )9#/$) */$(!$ ./$ ! /$)$( * */$( "$ $

! (+$($)""''2:#0('$)(.(/!. #.' */$(.(&

&& (/ ".( - /'.$) )' $99)(" )"/*(2 (*/$) - /' ")$$(5 * )' ./$ ! /$)$( $"

0#)/*/$:/5$( -:)*/$(8!!$&(().$ .(/$/!-/' +6()./$ ! /$)$(!"# .' */$(

(($*5/!$ (/ )"#/ ".. ! /$) ) - .( .//5$()( 0 2:#0(' * ))( */()$)( 0 !/)$('$)(

)(!/) */(/5:/5$!" ! /)$*/$(#-/'(.(-//) */(")$$($"- /''(!. )//-$($/$5 &

(().$ .$(/$/!-/)(."0#)/*/$:/5$)(* .(- 0 ./!$("$($)(* );;/$(.""*5 /5

(. 0 );;!"# '/$) )$/ ):))& B &&, ):('/$) #)- .) );;) + && $(..($

())(-:))($ ! /5 *"")"$:/'!/ 0#)/*/( )(* /5 2(- $($ );;$ " - 0 ./! 0 -.)/* )&

4#)/*/$:/5$( -:)*/$( !" .6 " );; '0 (' -/)(. $/)' ! .* &&5

);;.(2/5.:2() */$)<)&.&<&

"#$(/:$)*(().$ .$(/$/!5 $(..($6())(* .(./$ ! /$)$(* */(!"#)-./$(

*(().(0 2"".)(/".'2:#0(' )'&

//!.$$( '$( 7 1 .5 8 !"# $(.) *"")"$:/'!/ 0#/ 2"".) .+ )' $/* $:/'!//$(

9.() */$((($)9.(!/."*(()/)/$C! /$) ) !$( # ) #-/5 !/,) #-/9#/!)-:/

($)/5 & $) - .) $ * 2 5 #-/ & .:/!(.( -:/+ !"#$ -:/ !"#)-./( *(().(0

!"# .' ' !($".(- 2 5 #-/ .:/!($ 8 $)($) )' $99)(" (($) ./$ ! /$)$( $:/'!/

0#)/*/$(:/5$( -:)*/$)9#($)!$)!/!(!/&

/$) */$( .$(' $)($) + ! /$)$$( '$)/! 7 & /*() )' $))( &.:/!( !"# $(.) "

! /$) */$( .$ /$/! $99& /$)$( *:/$)*/$(. !"#) 2"".) -:/ * */$(. !"#)-./$(

*(().(0 2"".) -($) ) !$( !(5(' - /' 0 $!(' - /' $0 ".$/'6 -:/* .$) *:0) '

$99'. $)(' $2/'/#"/'* $99)(5'()"/*(2 (*/$($)0 :/5$!" ! /)$*/$(#-/$/'&

$0 * )(0 ./'($)#)+6()- $(* .)"&&!.+ )'$/* $:/'!//$(9.() */$(

(($)! /$) )'! #(.!" .C,0 , $) . # ) #-/5 & /$) )$"!9..!$)'6

!/')(5(*/$)"/$/!)/$(.""*$) - )( '*()(5 6*/' ).(+ 7.:/!(!"# $(.)

! /$)$(*:/$)*/$(. -($$(-:)) 6#/' * !$-:/* .$)*:0) ' $99'. $)(' $2/'/#"/'*

$99)(5'()"/*(2 (*/$($)&

/$)$!0) +(' $):/5$(/!!*/$(0 $(..()"/*(2 '/$/!//!./!!#!! *:/$)6

*/$ - .'+/$/!:/5$)(0 - + '$)(!/)$(' */$($& /$)$( $!$(* - '$99. )$

/5 (/ 0 9.'2(-()//-$(' - 0 '$('& (/$/$: 2( + ! /$)$ - $) * )"/*(2 '' )("

(+ :/5$(.(6*:0) * /$/!)(' $2/'//!!*/$)($)#"/'* /5! /)$* :/5$!"' 6!/'

! /$)$(/)"#/".. 9. ./*() )'(($*!/'($ -) */$(!$/.*$(.5(.)9.(* (&

4#)/*/$:/5$( 2( ) */$( (($*5/!$ " * #.5 $ ! /)$) )(/$)( /$/!)( (.6 )(-/$) 0

"* '/)& ((5 " /*() )' .//!*/$- + '$( 2// 5 !(#)($) )' )(/$)( /$/!)( :/5$)( 0

- + '$)(! /)$(!$&

"")"$:/'!/0#)/*/$(!((. */("! $ 0 ..(-/'! /$)$.//!6*/$!0) +!"#) - )($

(' $) (3(!)//-$() ! /$)$) .//!.$ . $)( :/5$(/!!*/$)( (($)& *)/ (/ ".( )(5(*/$)

/.*$(.5(.)(+ 2"2")$/" .$(! /$)$(5 6 -($) '($&&:/5$(/!!*/$(/$(.""*&

&'($)

!"#)/!

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding the applicant's right to reside in Estonia.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text