Court dismissed appeal against criminal conviction for theft, upholding the lower court's decision on facts and law.
Estonia (EE)
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the final criminal conviction for theft, rejecting the claim that the evidence was insufficient. The appellant argued that the prosecution failed to prove the specific intent required for the crime, while the prosecution maintained that the circumstantial evidence clearly established guilt. The court found that the lower court correctly applied the law and that the evidence presented at trial was adequate to support the conviction.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedCriminal Code § 160; Criminal Procedure Code § 259: The court may convict based on circumstantial evidence if the facts are clear and the conclusion of guilt is the only reasonable inference.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedFull text
! "# ! $% % & ' ( !))
* +,$% -") . /* - 0 &0$ 1 * -00$% 1 2 # ( 3 4 5 " () 6# * ( 3 7 . !6# *"5
*
* +,$% -") ! ! /
. ! /
6 .
*6 ' ! * / " "
'* ! * -$,& 8 9 3 ! -,,: 3 ! $ 0-0.) *
) " " # ! 6
)"
3 - . * / * 6 * / " ! "
'* ! * -$:,8 9 3 ! :$&:,$.) *
) " "
# 6 + :- 7 * * ; 0: 0< : 0
.$6 ! !
53 ! ! " * " *,3) !"
3 * 3 ' ! " * 0 3) ! " 3) ! # 3 ! ) *! " ! ! " ! ! *!)) 3 58 ,-:. $6 # 0 $0 " ! * 3 3 " * ' 7 = ) >?:- # * ! *! @@*) *! *!
* ; 0< : 0 A * * !) " 3 ) ! * *# & : )
* +% & ! 3 * ! * " !) ) 3 !* . 0 0 ! B %6 ") * # //* " *") * * *C % 0 * / ! 0 * 3 3 " * * ; 0< : 0# *
/ * * * @@ #! *!" % "' ' */ *# * 3 / ! ) ! * ! * ! * * " * /" * ' ' " 3 # */ % ) ! % %04-4 0 . ,6# ) ! 0 "! % $0 * ! ' 7 = ) >?:- ) ! " * ! *; 0:0<: 0 % : :6) ! ')3 3 " "! * ' 7 = ) >?:- * ! *! @@*) *! *! * ; 0<: 0! %
3 * ! . :%&6
3 * * ; 0:
0< : 0 .
3 ) * D'-056 @@ !" * " / *!" " %; 0:"; ,- " * ) ! * * !" * " # *" * * * . 0 / *# " ' ' / *#
3 * ! #! ) ! "! # " *6 * # 0 $0" ! *3 3 " * ' 7 = ) >?:- # * ! * ! @@* ) * ! *! * ; 0:
0< : 0 /
!
! * * *# !)) 3 ) *"" " * "
* *# ! ) ! ) ! 5 " ! * # * @@ *# * */" " "
-.$6 * !) * # * * @@ # / / *
3 * ! !
3 * !
* (
* +% ,$% - ) * ! * " # * ! * ! @@* ) * ! *! * (
" + $ ! * * * ! *! @@*) *! !
* * @@ !) !
* +% ,$% - ) * !))
#
" + $
/ *
!
"+ $
* +,$% - ) * ** # * " ! * " * * *
))
" ! * 5 " ! * # * * " * * * @@ " ! * ! * ! ) * * * 5 "# 3 * "! ) ! * * /" " # !" * / * # !) ! " 3 !"3 * ! !) * !
3* A !) " *"# * )*!" * 3 **)*!"
3 * * **
! " //* !) !* "*3*!* ! 7 3 3*
* + ,$% -")
# !
*!)) 3* !)) 3 " #3 !" ) * ") )) *
*! # ! * +%* " $ ! ) * + "# !* #
E !) * # !)) 3 " / " 3** " ) * * * ! !) " *
* )) 3 3* *" * * !*! #
* 3 /" !)" ** ! !
) ! * 3 " 3 *
/ 9 * " * # ** 3 "# ! / * * "
* !
* !)) " )
" !** !)
* + 0 // " ! * *! * " *! * " *# ! " * //* *
3 * *
// * 3
" ! * 5 * !)) " * ! * . * *
6 //*
*!* " *!* "* 3*!* 3 ! * !
* + ,$% - )) ) *
)) 5! * "# !) #
$.$6 * * ) " " *!# 3 !" * !
+% $- * ) " 3 ) " + :- ! ** // 3 ! * "
// **!7 # *!* " 3 "
) // * 3 3 + :- !" 7 * * ; 0: 0<: 0. !)) "" 6
+ -: * ! ") *
) * + : //* ! /! *
//* A *3 ! *!))
!)" //* 5 * " 3 )) * 7
3 # ! !
3 " * . 6 -
3 - !)"