Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
4-06-2062\2 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.06.2062.22658 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation order based on procedural errors.

Case Number 4-06-2062\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against the deportation order, ruling that the administrative body failed to properly consider the applicant's specific circumstances. The applicant argued that the decision ignored their family ties and potential hardship, while the opposing party maintained the procedural requirements were met. The court found that the administrative authority did not adequately address the applicant's claims, necessitating a new decision.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: The administrative body must thoroughly examine all relevant facts and arguments presented by the applicant before making a deportation decision.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order administrative procedure procedural errors family ties hardship assessment

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

             !"    

  #$%& %  '" ("          !)  * "       ) * +" , -./( !)-.)00 !)-1 /2"/  '" ( *

 )"/) ( )"/ &!) 3 ") 2/(.

 )"/) ( )"/ 4(/5

5 ""   4(/" /)/" %   6%7% )""/(/3)/ "& "78..67$.  ")"/ ) "5 "/ " " ) # ") & "(   %)  " ( "/() /  ( )"/ '/9/ )   '" (  ( )"/ & "    )"/) ( )"/ &!) 3 ") 2/(.  )"/) ( )"/ 4(/5

5 ""   4(/" /)/" %   6%7% )"") 3)/ "& "78..67$5 ):  ")"/) )5 "/ " "%   ;(+& $ ("/(5 )  ) * +" < (/5= ")/): ! ) !3 $) !3 4! )"% % #>     ) "5 / " ) % !") :   )  * +" ?  ) "5  5= ")/):  ! ) !3 #> 

      !    " 3 )/" ) )/5//)("/ (+ ) 5 "/") !)) )  ' () '/ (/

!) )""/ &=")5 "). "% 

  "#$$,4 ")! )3 "" : 1 % ! ) !3)(/2) ":  /  ( )"/ '/9/ )  ) (/  /")  @! "' + "  #$7#. 3 )/52/ 7867$7%  % !) )""'00 ) "/) )5 "/(/.  %* +" /  (/ ! ) !3 )/3  ) ": !) )""/ '/ (//: " /2 5 "/)!) & & "(%  % )  )""/  %* +" ? (/& / '" (*(/%          !) )""/ '/ (/ 3= 2 /: "  /3 )   + !)(/ 5//)(" ("/ "   :3 : ") )"& .

!)3( / 5//)(/&  3=  )/5  :3 : ") /" : & . )/ ) :/" & ( () "" )"   /" ) 5 "/ " 3 ") /  !)(/ 8 '/3  & "( ( )/" !) )""/  ))/" 5 "/")  + /" ) :/"

"" )"  $'/3 & "(. ( )/" !) )""/ ))/" 5 "/")%  &'&(

    /   "' ( *  )"/) ( )"/ &!) 3 ") 2/(.  )"/) ( )"/ 4(/5

5 ""   4(/" /)/"% 6%7% )""/+ 3)/ "& "78..67$) ") " ) * +" ?  "44:  "/((/". /) )/5  %% /(( #%$  3 (( ". / 5  " / (  '" ( )//$%

( 5//) ( &!) " 5 ) "= : ) ( ! ( & 2/". "  ) :/" 5 003 ) ) +: "  3 . 5 ((/+  

"  ("//" &  ; 8 ' # =:/ :.' /""/((/+ ) 5/3)/ . 5 (( / 

3 ( 9 )"// ) 3  (""/ :"/;8#6(+#&+ %  ")") " /: 3 : "& (:3)/  )""/ ! "/()':" :& 

 ")") /+/: 3 " "& (   ) ::. /) % * +"  !/)"/2 ) 5/' :: )/+% /( 5/) ): )""/&+   ") " !)3( /5//)(/& %* +" ?  (""/ :"/;8#6(+# ("/( ! ) !3 + $) !3 4! )"% #>   & ( "  ")"/  (""/ :"/;8#6(+ ("/(&!) 5 "= +"/ 3=)5 /7

"%  &)&'&& %7%7 " 2"   !)""/ % * +"  /2". 5 ((/" ' (2 3= 5 (: :  ) ( ) ":  5 ):  ! ) !3 " )  4!/ ")  & "(% /2"/" /  /" )  % * +"  '/)/" / ) ((/

!)3( "/5//)(/& ' ()5 ): ! ) !3  " "%%* +" )/ ) " 5  /2"/" !)(/./)/  " 3  !) ")+ ") " 3=)) %  *+,'&*&)& !" " ) " /2"/ !)3( "/(/ 5//)(/& (/. /" 5  3 ")"/" )/ ) 2. /) )""/ )/+/5 "/(  3/") ): =  5//)("/  +" +): )=/:/ :%  5 "  3/") ):. /) ( ("

5 ")/. "/ (!(+ " //( = +/ & 2/"/ ": " &!) 5 "/  (  )/+/5 ")  +  ' ()  +/()  ") ) 3  = +"

5 "/+   + &!) :/" "= : ) ( ! ( & 2/ "/ ": " '   5//)(" (/ "  ) 5/ 4! "  !)( )/ . !") :/""/((/+   "( (/& )/.    "//: /(& )/3 ")%3/") ): 

)/5 3  "/5 :

5 " .5 ((///")5 ):  ")"/:/  (/" 3) : 5 //"5 .   " ' /2&) 3 ()) 5/" = +"

5 " % !)3( /5//)(/& (/ 2./) )""3)/ "& " 78..67$)(//2"/ :"/")& 3 ") 2

5 "/ " "/(/ + = +( /." 5 "/  (/3 ") 5 ): ! ) !3  " ) 5 "5 "/"%@!)( "  !)3( /5//)(/& )/ ) 2./)/ " 3 ) ") & )/

)"5 ") !) ")+ (/ +/ " 3  " (/:  /2"/(2 3 ) 5 "/( !) ")+ (%  **  ") 3 ();#(+#3= 2 !)  !) ")+ )  (: 5 ) ( !/: :  /2"/ & ( " 5//)("/" &  )/!  ( !/:   ; #$ "))/ : &+ :/".   !"  " ): /2"/ ' 

!)5//)("/)/ "/(/' (/(/ +"/(+ ) :)/5 "/ " !  /2"/"!)/" + !)5//)("/ ' (/:  /2"/"3= "/((/3 ")"/")/ ) :./) :/ " 3  !) ")+ ") " 3=)) % !"(/ : ". /) "& " 2( !/: :  & ( "5//)("/"% !"(/ 2./)3)/ "& "(/ :3 )/ & ( /)=/: )/+ ' ) (( +  ( ! ( & 2/)3 ") 5 "/

!)  : ) 3 !/:  3=  5==)/ ")  ") 5 "/( ,3)/ ) 5   78..67$ ,/: "' :  1 )( 1. 5//)(" ("/ "  4(/ ( 5 "/ ' ) (( , )( $1  )=/: 5 ") (/ ::. /) % * +"  &!) " %% /(( #%$  3 (( ". / 5  " / (  '" ( )// $%

( 5//) ( 5 ) "= : ) ( ! ( & 2/"%  //+  % * +"  

"  ("//" &  ; 8 ' # =:/ :.' /""/((/+ ) 5/3)/ .5 (( / 

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

    (/"/ :  " )5 & :"( () " /""/ ( : .5 : %* +"  (/5 ):5 " 55  ")"/

 + ) "5 /'=!&") : 3= 2% ;(+$5 2./) " ) ) ") 3   ")"/) )5 "/)!) /+/ ) ! 4(/) : 4!)/ ") ).5 (( ") )!) /+ %* +"  5  /2"/" ) )(/"& 5 (( "/) )("/ !" !(: 2% !):/"//() :")& &! ::/";:/")#(+#.#$'.#$$.#$.#$7(/ 2 !"./) /   '" (  ( )"/ & "    )"/) ( )"/ &!) 3 ") 2/(.  )"/) ( )"/ 4(/5

5 ""  4(/" /)/"% 6%7% )""3)/ "& "78..67$)(/2 " ( "/() 5) 5 ):  ")"/) )5 "/ " "& )/! "/((/" " "" )"".5 "/  " /: %* +" ?  ( : 3 ") 3 ();#$'&+ %  B ((  B  * "  !)        = +/