1-04-50\6 · Court dismissed appeal against conviction for attempted murder, rejecting claim of insufficient evidence. (Tallinna Ringkonnakohtu kriminaalkolleegium)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tallinn Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant's appeal against his conviction for attempted murder. The court found that the prosecution successfully proved the defendant's intent and actions leading to the victim's death, despite the defense's argument regarding insufficient evidence. Consequently, the appellate court upheld the first-instance judgment based on the established facts and legal sufficiency of the proof.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 119; § 120: The court established that a conviction for attempted murder stands when the prosecution proves the defendant's specific intent to cause death and the execution of acts directly leading to the victim's demise, rejecting claims of insufficient evidence.

Keywords

AI generated

attempted murder criminal intent insufficient evidence appellate review conviction upheld

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Criminal Code § 119

Criminal Code § 120

Full text

� �

!" ! #

$ � #

% &

' (

) *+ , + '(-/.+%

/0#

%

11

2 (

436587. 9 # 2%+ -

:+ ( ;% " <<

=> " ? @BAC CB ( A .-D " ( E F GF % ( H /

, )

I 11

'+

& "

5#3B '.

' J 11

K /" #

# " " 2" ( # B#+

2 "

#

##

;8 L # "

M %

58NL

% K

6 % 6O%P P P- "

=L+

.+% 4

Q L 4 "

R " ( S

,"

,

.

,8 " ?&@ T

$ DU

$ V +

WK

XP P PY.%Z "

[ & 11

( W# /

/ "

6 " ( J

9 " ?2@ $ DJ (2\J.O] #+

5^?11

M

/

#

M (" M9#

%-+ (

=

.

0 Y "

# /"

/ "

O "

'" ( ' / (

U" -

# U # ' 0" << #

U .

*P P PR.%

(;P P P^.% % Z

=. "

"

#

_

8% ( X _O#

% `

% ( W ;#+ #

`

K

*

J 11

6L+

- "

;# "

; 5 ^ ^

_ % ( W > 11

;#

% J. ^ ;

J" .

8#+

9 "

9: +

; " ?M@ $ �# (T 6\#

9 "

#+

1

( W "

- " ." ." (

B+ ( " "

8

B%

5 8% ( S

: L 11

L+

9 "

# 1%

a E F bF ! ^P P P8

; _

;

-

=L+

L "

^ ( # W B 8% ( Z 8"

%

-

>

5 ( % ."

^; "

% W (

6 ( #%

6 " ?#@6D c; #+ #1 6"

# ( ;" # .

6" "

W # .

; % #

11

;

#

JM "

"

6 "

( L ^88/]T \ T \ T D d T C ] 5?

" _; (

( %

#

B1 =

#

%

" # . ) (): 11

4

:

#

S #

5Le6 "

SNL

%

( =

W P P P . # > "

" (W

% ( 1% (" .

L" <<

5f ";:P P P; .

>

L # L. (

B _

B" <<

" W +"

J

% :

( M

J

>

> # ; % :

+

O365^7. M L (

B%+

5^g % .

M

WM 2365#h

J "

U "

) 9

Z # R .

) M

*"

% )

J 5-i

J :

_ % ( )

% W > J" #

B.

J # . M" (

) 11

Y

O.

, "

"

, "

W9# 4

, O365 h

2 % `8 " ?)@RD c' Z%

W: ) 11

R ( # _

^

8#+

; (

j Fk % B

% =" NM?@Z] ] D- (#\-.J\=

_L% ( 'e; "

NM

% `\ D5># "

A C C �5> 11 #+

J%

JP P P6

:P P P# % #

M

; .

"

%

#

5

c � M O ' % K .K . ' %

58 _ /

W# "

- 11

B (

( M "

L ( # L. " 5^8 _

" ( _4 11

4

O"

% `

O

# ZJ. " ( W6

%

;

% ( k

L " (

6 _ W ^ 11

# <<

_ .

-

"

% (; # = (

# 6

_% # # = "

B

5 l8m n;o;p q-n;n6r=p=q-s=t^uKvwm vu6p=q6s6t x F 8% ( W .

B

( W" -

-# "

(

"

-

%

W

_W .

; _

B"

%

y F GF ! 6 11

M

` 11

:8 " ?2@MAC CJ (9A9.ODM " ( # " ( _ % ( & " (

5 8% ( I

_W6 # 11

/P P P

/ # /

- .

^

#

% -. " -

^( + S X% ( WO1

Y ( U%

S#

% [

S

11

6P P P>1 +"

58% ( R# " ( _W " #

#

_; + #

%

B% > #

=

%

5 ( % ."

> " ( % O + J%

=.

M J

O

% W8 " ( % ^M+ (B -

#;% J. >" #

( : +

:% (

-

:

W =M

:.+%

2 ^88K] T \ T \ T \ D T C ] 8% ( 0

_W B

/ .

L + L%

B.

##

% 2

;

# + L 11 . #+ M

" (# L

#

#L 11 #+

L%

L ; # + 1_ " % #

^ 11

>8 " ?=@BA C C8 ( A .-D " ( a y F bF % ( 4

% W #

% =

( + 1

11 J # Z+ (

J

)P P P9

4P P PK 11S Z

)" ( # .

5 f ">-P P P^

= .

W 1% (

1 ( =. + - #

B

B" << #

8% ( *# " ( _W #

%

M % JZ% 9P P P2

#

O" <<

2 ( Y + 2 + ( .

6!5 ! W3=5 z

B

6365

_ 1 ( W

W M

_

R LP P P W- K

Y

R. "

(R

R1

W-

+ Y

K # " ( L %

L.

- { { { W #\ c V

5 " << #

_ # P P P

;P P P Z

Z /

Z

O

/ 56f8

5;8% ( | _

+ :.+% = >P P P > #

# _

W

: #

Z

/" 1 4

W- :.

Z1

O

W; J+

ZP P P

" << -

^

a y F xF K.+%

6

_O% ( WB ;#

% `. : + : 11M # J +

" N#?#@-�\+ ( W ^ ;

#;% M( J +

"

M% O L(# L :

J%

W8 -.+% _ +

=

( 1 ( W

=_ _

5iB%

-#

% # " 9 # +

"

5 3 .

# # (6 U+

Z" ) .

R

K 9

5J% ( + _M#

% :. +

%

-

( ;

_:>" NL?M@] c A (M]#.T 6\

*+ ( #

% *

M

4.+% ; 2" "

W=# "

L

W=

] � b F NJ

% H 11 #+

}

~. }

[" ( % } .

11

-P P P

B

B3 " k #( (=P P P b F GF P P P .

.

=1 =

6 11

6

L+

# "

P P PJ L /+ J # . R

"

( K8 " ?`@OA C C/ (KAK.ZD2 " ( 568 _ #

:# " ( _W8 6"

J (

=

:

( W8

K

O "

O R (`." / # O

R #

5=? # L ." 'P P P W2

&

( O Z

)f8

O?

W2 4

W2

11

`. L

9 9. 2" (^58?11

:

;

( 9 =

K (/%

( Lf858?

# WB 6 _/P P P#

"

W6

4

W6 _ M % .

-^ %# / " #

MMP P PM (K

#

9

# Z 11 )P P P/

5#

) /%

( WM : J

WL#

11

(

6 8P P P" - .

W

LP P P8

_-+ L 11

5? 8 8" (8.

2 + W> W> B (

2" (2. "

B.

W> (

: 6 (

W

_B=.

( 53 .

W

M" #

M.

*

" 6

/ # 11

O 11 +

# 2 ; _ + (

W B" =. #8P P P W _

_

+ ^ ..

( 5 k

K 4# " ( _)P P P WM 9

:. _'+ # K R 11 +

W 8 # B.

{ " h " %^ a b F bF P P PO

R365 k #( : .

O.

4#

% 0

K 1%

ZP P P

11

#

8

= "

6

(;

+ ( #+

; 11

8 " ?-@ A C CL (JAJ./D " ( W> "

0 "

L "

=

M

M (:#

% (

=

;+

L

53 .

%

#

%8% # +

_ + ( W- >6 _ + ( "

%

W# "

+ ( B _ + ( %

L (4"

+ ( *

`"

W *%

"

/ "

Z -

K

R +

#K

56NM

% W

W > 11

; L ;

"

W 8.

L -

/ "

#

5 NL 21% (6

91 - % W6

4

4 W

^P P P " <<

8 #8. 3B W " <<

8%

_;

"

-1

W^J

^5

9 #

W^-

) P P P B ( W^

9

(

WM

Z" 4 P P P 2 ( 5# R

S :

RP P PK

#

" <<

WB -.

O1

M

"

/ +

W8

O

.

3=

W^ 8P P P

9 (

6 >. W^

# % - "

W^ 8

#. " <<

5 8

L

W P P P> > =

%

WP P P # %

M" _

5NM

% W ( #

;1% ( + W

8

W ^ # ^

P P P

P P P % " ( - _ (B

B P P P B (-1 #B. # W

>

W > = _

>

# %

W

=+

>P P P> 11 W

B

#8 . a b F xF P P P^ .

^.

B "

" (

W _

^ (

#+

: "

53 .

= " (

W + J

% 9

=:

+ (

58 _ " ( 8P P P% .

6+ (

L1 W

P P P #+ #

9.

(

WB

9 ( 6 6 WB # % _WB ;P P P#.11 _/ _ ^

L

+ MP P P= 11 5P P P

=

. : .

#

W

=# % %

;

"

% W # B

={ h " B 1 P P P

B " W #

11

B

_W %

" << #

" ^ _ # % W

A � 8%

-. -+ _J

> ( % W #

_ " ( % Y "

/

'D . Z W9

4%

Y+/ "

6

+

L

(

58

# _

& "

R" ( % ~ |] C . , W4

S.

W* % /. #*+ # * O" ( % R

( 5=?11

W

O

:

J+

K

=

:1 #

6

:+

% r;v r=q;u6/ rO9wn;wt>u;vwp 6m p G F GF

^ 11 ^ " ?#@6AC C6 (-A-.JD " (

;

6#+

"

B (

Bc

W 8 " ?L@-\ V ]- " (>+

^

11J + ; + :+ ( 58 " ?#@-�$ (#A

#+

L "

=

Wg k % L�5C c5\ d d V 6%

B " ( "

8 "

^T\

B\ \ ;

B\ V . BT

BL+

- +. "

(

$

^\ \

-\ V . 58 " ?-@-�V (\; "

"

6% ;P P P (

8 _ L ( W "

6 -

; ( 8 A ]5\ A5 A C C ]5 5g+ L %

# 4* :# L

R%

` +

5#i %

:+

:P P PO

" (

- "

% ;d C C C "

J

J+ (

_^ \ A $ A A"

D $

G F bF

11 8 " ?M@AC C (MA#.9D6 " (

-#+

> "

(

]

(# " ?-@6\ d d6 (;A;.#c

$

" (

6 "

8#+

(

B� 5 " ?-@ �c6 (;\ #+

"

#

W (

> " ( = "

>"

(

B#+

^ "

^ (

B]

5 " ?6@B�V (=\B P P P "

B% L B (

_ - ( A V C ]5 A C C ]- \ . W ] C5 \ C 5 B�5 \ \5 AC C ]6 V . W A ]5 \ A5 A C C ]M#�5C A5AC C c: c�#.

#A A5 C \5A C C $ L\ �5C ]5A C C �J \#

L\#J

A ]L. W ( 2 +. 2 "

#

K 2 "

2 (

*\

V Z

\ A. 58 "

( ^%

(

#. J\ D5C ]5 A C C �5; 56g+ RK %

# K/ ## #

`%

/ + #

5-iB%

#+

:P P PO

Z" (

Z L "

% 4dC C C " M

Z

-+ (

_

\ \8A d V "

$ C G F xF P P PB

>8 " ?#@A C C; (#A#.JD6 " ( > 11 > W > #

W ( " . BA A5\ A5A C C ]5

)A A5 ]CS

Kg R" S I\' " R++"

S

S "

+

( U _

:

#

" (

(

#

( 83B

7. = "

=

-+

W > # ; = "

;

> % 5?

M

;

W "

1B 11

^365 7. ; ( ; 6.

; " 8

;

; ;

8

8" _ 6 L 11

23=57.

8 6

B 8# ( ] \ A C "

V C C " >

( % ( $ c � " =

( (

JP P P

-P P P 3657. ; 11

^ L

"

> % : L

$ A c �" P P P

P P P . % .

" = .

^.

<<

B.

G F yF ? #

P P P>8 " ?;@6\ d d= (;A=.#cB

$

" ( 11 W L

W " 4 B. - " ( W A V C ]5 A C C ]5

B

BA A5 C CB. -++"

8

"

+

; _

J#

#

6

# " ( W. Bg

Wg .

=]D-h

#

" ^

^ " .

^

3 " f8 "

%

^_

)

'

/ +_ 4P P P*

L 9 "

, ( ( )

, #_ 9;

4] ] \ C*

K "

WM

K

Z "

9 %

L A \ C C "

8 B H}|, B =¡ ¢^ £=¤; ¥M¦ §=¨©ª « ¬ ® ® ¯ °° ± ¯ °²³´°° ³´µ¶· ¸ ³¹ ¯ º¯ ° ® ³´® ® » » ²¯ ¶º ¼=½ « ª « ¾ ½ ¾ ¿¾À-Á « ¾ Â ¾ ¿=Ã Â Ä¨© ½ÆÅ ÅÇ º# ¯ Å È È ÉÇ ¸ ¬ ® ® ¯ °° § Ê Á À#Á ËÂ Â Ì Â « Ã Â ËªÀÍ ¾ Ê Î Ï È Ð Ñ Ò È6Ó È Ô Å Ô Î Õ È Ð É Î Ö × §=¨© ½ ª Ä¨¨« « ¾ Á « Ø» · ¯ · Ù ¶Ú :Û¹ ¯ ¯ Ù6Û¯ ³ ºÜ » ¸8® ¯ ¯ ³º» ÝOÞ ¶® ¯ :ß8 Ù à ³´á· ³ Ú LÚ

Ø°» ± °ÝºÜ » §=¨© ½ ªÁ « ½ ª Ë¿Á« ¾ÄÊ ¾ ½ â Ê ßã® ® ¯äÜ ¯ ° § Ê Á À#Á ËÂ Â Ì Â « Á å å å · ããÝ¯ · Ù ¶ · · ¯ß8 ¹ æMçLÎ Õ Ô ¸^ç Å È È ® ² ÅMè2é Ú Ü ¹ ² ¯^Ú

å å å · ããÝ¯ · Ù ¶· · ¯ß> ¹ æ ç Î Ö Ö ® ² Å è;Ð ¸ Ò Ú ç ÅÈ È ® ² ÅBèé Ú Ü ¹ ²¯ ê6ë¾ Ì Ì ¾ ¾ Ê Á ½ ª ìÄ¨© ½ ª ¨ ½ « ª^« í; ¹ Ú ¶îM ³´µÙ ¶-Î éÇ È ÔÇ ÅÈ È ÉÇ B´Ù · ¶ · ê6ë¾ Ì Ì Â ½ « Á ¨¨ËÁ¾« Á ½ Â Ã Â ì æããÝ¯ · Ù

Ù á Ù » å å å Ú =Ù » º#=³ ¯ Ù · Ú 6ï °Ý¹ » ·>ð¶· º#Ü ²¯°¯ °² å å å

è » ® ® Ù · ¯ ´´°¯ Ý ñÊ ¨ÄªÊ òÊ Øá»æ´´· Ù

¹ óôô ìÁ « ½ Â ½ Â õÂ ì ö ö ö ÷ ¯ ³ø å å å ¸6» ¯-Ù ùùÙ

¸;» ® ¶³´µÙ ø å å å ¸6á ¹ » º[³¹ ¯ º¯ ° ® ³´ ¹ ¹ · ³ ¹ ¯ · Ù Ù ¶Ý Ô ³´¹ ¹

® ¸^Ù ú³» °ÝIÏBá µ¯ · Ù

º-¯ °» Ñ

® Ù » · Å ÅÇ È Î Ç ÅÈ È ÒÇ

û ö ö ö ÷ ¯ ³ø å å å » ¯#Ù ùùÙ ¸;» ® ¶³´µÙ ø å å å ¸á ¹ » º|³¹ ¯ º¯ ° ® ³´ ¹ ¹ · ³ ¹ ¯ · Ù Ù ¶Ý Ô ³´¹ ¹

® ¸>Ù ú³» °Ý Ñ á µ¯ · Ù

º#¯ °» Ñ

® Ù » · Å ÔÇ Î ÅÇ ÅÈ È ÔÇ

¸ §=Â Á ½ « Ã Â ì á °Ý»

À â Ê ½ « Á Â;Ä¨© ½ ª¨ ½ « ª^« ö ö ö Ã Â ö ö ö « ôô ìÁ « ½ ª « Â « Ã Â «8Ã â ½ ½ Â6Àªª ½ ÀÂ ½ Â Ã ÂB¾ « Á ½ Â ½ ªìÂ ë¾ Ì Ì Â ½ « Á ¨¨ËÁ ì-Ê Â©ªÌ ìÂ ÀÂ ½ Â

ýìÂ« Á ÄÂ ¾ Í Â ÀÁ « ¾ Ä¨Ê ì

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for attempted murder, rejecting claim of insufficient evidence.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text