Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-6444\1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.6444.18716 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against ruling on criminal procedure regarding evidence admissibility in a case involving a specific procedural violation.

Case Number 1-06-6444\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the lower court's ruling concerning the admissibility of evidence in a criminal proceeding. The appellant argued that certain evidence was obtained through procedural violations, while the opposing party contended the evidence was legally gathered. The court rejected the appeal because the alleged procedural defects did not meet the threshold required to exclude the evidence under the relevant criminal procedure code.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Kriminaalprotseduurikoode § 107; § 108: Evidence obtained through procedural violations is admissible unless the violation seriously undermines the fairness of the proceedings or the evidence is irrelevant.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal procedure evidence admissibility procedural violation exclusion of evidence fair trial rights appellate review lower court ruling

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Kriminaalprotseduurikoode § 107
Kriminaalprotseduurikoode § 108

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









        













 







 

 

 







 !

 

"#$ %&

'



 



 



(

#

$



 

 

  

  





          )* %+ $$$ $$"

$$+ $"'" &"((%$"+ '

$ ! 

 " "



""%

 

*%$%'")'$,%







  

      !













 

 $$' 

$ $$ '-.   $' & $$" "$%

$"$"%

$.$ /"$



"  

#$







0 $

"$

$1$"







"$&

"



""%



&%



 ! & 

  

 2 33 / 4 ""$ $$+ $"  &'$

!  ! '

"" ,

 '" ,

$" $$  & "

$&" )'$

&/

"$/!

&$$!&"

$&"



$"$'"$



5/ $/  

 !   """' $$

&$%"%



"$/%$$$"% /

%

+$$$$%%6"%"

%  &   

 /

 %

 '""+  '.%$ '.%$ '-. """' & ""







"$/%$"$$"&%-

'$$$

$"/""/"""'$

$$%% 6" %"+  "$% "-$%$%+ $% "'% /

 %

 ""

,

$ "$ %% '

/"$/ """'  '

$ '$ 

""

""% /

 $$' &  " "$$/ *$ & '-. "$"% /

 %

 ' ""%

$$

$" & "" -

'$ %

" '-. /

 %

 '.%$ & "" 

"$/%$

"$$"



   $+ $" /

 %

 '"$ %. 6%$  /

 %



".+$"$$"$%'

/+$"$%"""$

"%. $$'&

//$

'$+$" /

%

.$$

$"-

'$%+$""$$

""'."""



 

 

$.+$"



(

""-&$%"%/ /

%

"$.'"%$$'"





 2  / '-. """' '"%+   " 

'$+ $" " '-. '.%$

& "'""$

"$/%-".



(

$/+$" /

%



$$ 

'$ 6%$  /

 %

  '""  

$$ '$ 



"" 

""% ,

$ "$%% '

/"$ "  66% $".+  ""%$+ $"

'..$&

"$& .

""$$$%$6"%

&+""

"$/" $"%.









"7#$ %&

'