Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-05-1896\1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.05.1896.13637 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for theft, rejecting argument that victim consented to the taking of property.

Case Number 1-05-1896\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant's appeal against his conviction for theft, upholding the first-instance judgment. The defendant argued that the victim consented to the taking of the property, claiming it was a gift or loan rather than a theft. The court rejected this defense, finding that the victim's words and actions did not constitute a valid, ongoing consent to the permanent deprivation of property. Consequently, the court ruled that the defendant's actions met the legal definition of theft.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Krim. 1. § 10; Krim. 1. § 11: Consent must be clear, specific, and revocable; mere words or ambiguous gestures do not negate the intent to permanently deprive property, thus constituting theft.

Keywords

AI generated
theft conviction victim consent defense property deprivation criminal appeal intent to steal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Krim. 1. § 10
Krim. 1. § 11

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



  



 

             

  !"#$$!"%&  

     '()*    $+, +-  

   ./ .-& 00. 1 2  3!$4%!3($4-54% 5 /2+21$ 2           2/ 11 6 """ 1$,5&2++1#$1  3$4!3( $4!#%(-54&7. 21 24 11+4/ 1 2-4!  11" !"#$   #              % &'   ()& * % +,(   ( -                  

./   0-  --   )1+'//2     3 1      %.+-     044   5    -  -    )    0  

          1  6        %7+ ()%+,( 8     9&//2   31

6 



  :";* <)8//2    316 



  =""$>!?  :)@// 2  3 1 6 

 

   =$ # # :) 8&/ 2       3 1 6 

 

   = !* :) @// 2  3 1 6 

 

   =A$* : ?

  - 

)     # 0   $  )B    (1  5             -   *      

 

     0       &, 2     3   @/   ) --            C   0 5        8&8 2          3  7/      8'//2      3 1  11  2&711$151/ 2$&87       1 .- $11  2



 !  -8 1/ 2212 1+. /+ 122/&2$. +1$2+!!(9)2 1: #+4 &8 &2$. +1$2+!!!()) + #+4 %&12+/7299%/5.2 1 / 2./2+.$2% 211242/ 1+$ 2 1 24% /1/+$ -+/7-2 &82$$222 1+$+2 1  1 1." 5$-/8 121.       +. +. /+ 122/ &2$. +1$2 + !!(9)2 1: #+4 &8&2$. +1$2+!!!()) + #+4 %&12+/72 !9" 1$. - +. &87 &711$ 151/ 2 $ 1 .   - $ 11  2 -8 1/ 2 212 1%/5.2 1 / 2./2+.$2%211242/ 1+ 1$.2&8 +.1 / 24% /1 /+$ -+/7-2 &82$$222 1+1$.&8 +.1 +."

5               

$        " 11   .21 21151$2151/ 2 (#52&/;;./ 2$11  2-8 1/ 2 1% 00.$+22 $24+8.2.&711$151/ 2-- $1 +."  !       00./8 121$+84 11  25112 / 2$2-54+2& 1#52& 1#52&- $11$2.%21   1  /+$ - 0$. "  +/211. 151- - $ 1$2 2$$ 1 11$ 1 2

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

0             9             0  !0 D       0   0       -       )   )  

     --   )   - 50             05 )11 %&' ()&*%+,( (-   6       1  !("!"!""  11. 00. 1 1  2$1 124  +4++#1 &  ++ #;7$&2112#+2$.../ .-& 12  1 2+$ 1 1 1 )/+//#52&/55$1 2 '$51&$1/+/$ 2 1#52&  21$2 1$7$./ 2$2 /+//#52&/55  +*% " (  '$/ 11 & .* +" $..  3 )( 5112. ++4 /112 #;;1 /8 121.  1 1 152$$1 151/ 2$2%  1 2 #+2 $/2 1 2 1 2-- $11$$11/21124"



 (   % 

+.1$22 11.182+.2.%$27 %21./ .-& 00 3!$4%!3($4 -54+182+.1.%1$ 11&" .-&01$ 124%1++ 1-"8 2+01$ 124% /1 /+$ - 41.-$2182+.124"00. 11&124&$@1 221842 1 3!$4%! E($4-54"   1 2/8 1/ 2$&817 &2 2 0012 2$/- 1 1242+.&.- 2+.&.  -$ .% /1#;&/ 1 1 2  "   122711  214+2.2 22$1.$2--+..2  3.2 1!$4%!($4-!9"    $+, +- 1+