Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-05-1898\2 ECLI:EE:HMK:2006:1.05.1898.3748 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against probation conditions, ruling they are lawful and necessary for public safety.

Case Number 1-05-1898\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the defendant's appeal against the conditions of their probation order. The defendant argued that the requirements to report to the probation officer and obtain permission for travel were overly restrictive. The court rejected these claims, stating that the conditions are standard legal measures designed to ensure the defendant's compliance and protect society.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Kriminaalhooldusestiku § 10; Kriminaalhooldusestiku § 11: The court established that probation conditions requiring regular reporting and prior permission for travel are lawful and necessary to ensure the offender's compliance and public safety.

Keywords

AI generated
probation conditions reporting requirements travel permission criminal supervision appeal dismissal public safety probation officer

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Kriminaalhooldusestiku § 10
Kriminaalhooldusestiku § 11

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

K O H T U O T S U S

EESTI VABARIIGI NIMEL

 

                !  "   #  $%      & &  '  %   (    )   ' * 

       &   &        

    ( &    &     

          & ( & &      ))          &  +  *           &  , &  -$*  ( ((    &         $'            ./      & & &&012     /     / 

   &  034 52 6+3 * 7 )  6. 7  &&0    &              &        8         %     *3- *    

9       -  *     ' ))       )&&   &   $'        &    (   &      &     (             #    % 5   ((    (      &       &     5:++ *  ;      

9      -  *    &   + %   +      &   '   ))             Kriminaalasi nr. 1-05-1898

Kriminaalasi nr. 1-05-1898

      &        ))      &   

 & &  &         &             3* +   

9      -  *    &   / %   +    5     ))               &      ))   &     &&  &       &         +    

9      -  *    &    %   +    5     ))               &      ))   &     &&  &       &        

3.     #    % 5       &&       &  &  (           5:+    ;       5))& % 5  ))&    (     &())&  &&        &    &&           &   5))&    &    &                  &       &     &    (   % 5 &  ()     &  (     &  &        ))& % 5657)) ( &&   &  ))   (               $'     & )      6 $-*$/3$-$-7&     )         6  /$.7 ( &    ( &&  6 *$7  (   )6 .7       &      % 5         &    &  (& &))&     &   ( &        &( &&   &        % 5  ))&   5  : ++    *    ;             % 5    &    (( 

  (      &        ( &        &( &&   &        % 5  ))&   5  : +        ;         % 5        

Kriminaalasi nr. 1-05-1898

&         &   &  (               & &( &  ( &     &    % 5 ))& &             &             (      5:/     & ))&      &&(  & &&  & 9            & &   & & & ))&    

(   (& ))& & &  &    )) &        5         (     (

  &     (   5 : /          (   (            (  &            &    (      (   (  &))&   ))&        &        & ))&        &       && ( &&   & )    &&  % 5             )) &        ))&   &&     ))&  )) (             ) ))&     5))&   ( &&   &  5))&       & & &    &&   &       (       (     (     &   &          ))&   ( &&  (   &   &   )   

                ))&    ;           &  (

  &          )&    (         (        )                 )      (                ( &   (         )     &    ))&       &:.*$./        ))& (    

(  % 5       

 &

  ))& (     &         &        &   & (& &    &     ))& (   (          &         % 5 657          ))& (          )             &  < (  &      

Kriminaalasi nr. 1-05-1898

 5 : ./ : .+ : 3     ))& (    ( &   ( &   &     &   5:-/-3:./:-/:-:-$--:-/          

   !           !        ! "!  #$  ! ##!  ! #!!#!!!% ! !# !# !!!   &  '( "!! "!#$

#$ !$ ! !!#!! "!      )  ! # % ! !   !! "! #$!    !! #  "#% #  "!*% ! !   !! "! #$! $   ! ++   !  #!!%#$!!!"# !#!"  !   * !  #     $!  " ! !! #  !        ! ,  & " #"  ! - %     "  #   #"  !!!   #  $! !!"!#! !  !" #" !!! # #   ) !! # $!.

1) elama oma alalises elukohas, ilmuma kriminaalhooldaja määratud ajavahemike järel kriminaalhooldusosakonda registreerimisele,

Kriminaalasi nr. 1-05-1898

2) alluma kriminaalhooldaja kontrollile oma elukohas ning esitama talle andmeid oma kohustuste täitmise ja elatusvahendite kohta, 3) saama kriminaalhooldusametnikult eelneva loa elukohast lahkumiseks kauemaks kui viieteistkümneks päevaks, 4) saama kriminaalhooldusametnikult eelneva loa elu-, töö-või õppimiskoha vahetamiseks.     )      !  ! "  #!   " #! ,$!% !" "#! !!%   "! "  "! $#! /$!  ##!   #$    !! ! !! 0"#!! # !  '( 121!3"%!#*! (  "## ! "  )    $* ##  " # "!##!  '(  %   " "! "!##! )((  "! # $! #!

!  !* ! 4  & "5"# #!!! "! !! $* &   ' (  '  ! )  !  ! !% #! #!  !! ! ! "!   !#! !!"!#! /! !! ! ! "!   )  !  !  !% #  "#!!!!$#""!