Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-623\2 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:1.06.623.1597 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for theft, upholding original verdict based on sufficient evidence.

Case Number 1-06-623\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the defendant's appeal against the first-instance conviction for theft, rejecting the argument that the evidence was insufficient. The prosecution presented witness testimony and physical evidence linking the defendant to the stolen goods, while the defense claimed the items were found elsewhere. The appellate court found the lower court's factual findings well-supported and correctly applied the law, thus affirming the guilty verdict.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 161; § 162: The court held that an appeal against a conviction for theft is dismissed when the evidence presented at trial sufficiently establishes the defendant's guilt and the lower court's findings are not arbitrary or unsupported by facts.

Keywords

AI generated
theft conviction insufficient evidence appellate review criminal procedure burden of proof

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Code § 161
Criminal Code § 162

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

  



  

  

    !"#$%&'"#$% #     ( !(!)* +!+ ,+)-  

  . .$/01   

  %0 $%0   0..223.0455$16,'784,7$14  $167'5' 91.$0660&00$0   0$%   

  !..3)7! 5+!+580$"#$%'"...(+78 0.3.80&00$00.00$'$1.3018::0.&8 %0&.&.$.3"#7 ! "#$% 6$4)5$16')$0$.1.&..%/30,3 01   $# 5 "#$%  6$  4 )5 $1 6')  4 5 $1 $0$ %/30 5 3 %#   "#$%6$4+$1(45$1 6' $0$ %/30 5 3 &#    "#$% 6$4)5$16')45$16$0$$#6$. . %1. 5 3  7 690% '# + ) "#$% 6$455$16,'7$0$%1. 3 /0 69 .0 3&.  5 , 8 #03( %.&.0 $0 ) 7 + 8  $% .. 6003 ) 7 +  

303%#. ( )* +  223.&#.0..455$16,'791..3*20-0%1.01 223.&#.0..4,7$191..3!*0-$.0%1.01 223.&#.0..4 $167'5' 91..3)*$&0-!*0- $.0%1.01 4!,$1$0$&#.0..$0$...2..00.&03&.0 00$0..$0&#.$...0,*0$.-!*-3%1.  4 !7 $1  $0$ 0. . 00$%1.0 %../.3 01 $0 ) 7 + . !  !  + 3  ) 690% % . $      

     

   &, -  $./ 

#

*+-  #03;%.&.0903.00...03&.0$1%$0 0$&.0$0. ! 

9$ &#. 0. .$ &00$$3 ( 3 +  *0.0  %..3-    .' #.1/.$  *0.02&&03-.060...$37),+*00. $&30$.2&&03%..-...1.$300 00$$3  3   $ %0 0 #&.0 3&..00.&. %0$0  ),7  0.<.61*%..0&/07 ,57,- 

9$&#.0..$.010.3300= )775. &0.*0$"#$$"#$%-8 + '+. 0."*"$$.7$$.-8 5,.< 600 0*"#$%-8 5)+.<.3*"#$%0)(-8

7 .<$0* #5"#$%-8 ,) ..&..*0$"...(+,"#$%-8 , .0.60..*"#$%/23'"."#$%-8 7,) '! .<&0("0* ."#$%-8 7,', . .$0.*"%$.>6$.))$$.8-8 ,, ')+. $..3*&6.000))$$.-' +)75'!+.<?%.*0+"#$%-8 +!'+.@  1 0*0$./("#$%-8 7 .@  .% ..&90*0$ 9.+"#$%-8  .@ .A#/..*0$$%3."#$%%$3"#$%&3-8 ) . 3*'#/,7-8 )+.60 /3<*"#$%-  .#03.3= +($$.0 B$ )7 60B.$ 0%$%0 ' &. .$ "#$% 6$.0. 0$%&.'C.00.34,7)$1,$0$ "3.0'&'.33'&0..%9%.$0'/31'&.3.$0"#$% 6$.0..#03.0.&.'9%.38  (  

  060$0%#./0.360$$..%.3$'.010&.$0660&00$0900 .&.01 60$$..#.10 &.0 %. $0/ 03   $0 "#$% & 3 .$.$0.&0690%$$00$&.0 60$$.0.0$0"#$%&.$.$%..00.2&0690%$' $0690%'&.$&00$06$0$%#.&$.%301 .&.$&00$0$302%.&.00%#./%.3$300$3.2&0690% $$00$&.0&990/00.&.000$00.3$0  

 

   223.00$$0'00&$$0+ )"#$%6$ 455$16,'7$0$.3%1.013'

)*+- (::$ %  , + %#. 0/03$. &&.0 00&91.$ 9 "#$% $. "... 9%& 006..&..$0$%$1B&&01 ,) .' (  + + 0$$ ,+  $ 1.   %3 %.    3 %## % 0/03$.&&.000&91.$"#$%$.90%0 066.0.0 5'6#1000$.%0$001&.0#'6..&0$0%1008 (  + +0$$ + $1.$.00&$3&.000$"#$%'0%0 @  .% ..&90$0$%06$0'$&$.%#.0/03$. &&.000&91.$9$7 (.8 ( + +0$$ ,+ $1.$.00&$3&.000$"#$%'0%0 @  .% ..&90$0$%06$0'%#.0/03$.&&.000&91.$ 9$$.$, (8&221.$.@$&0$$0$%060 (6.1$0. )7 ( 1010.,7 (.8 ( ) + + 6223. %## % 0/03$. &&.0 00&91.$ $. 6&.0 00$ .0 1.3 "#$% 0 / %0  30 63.'  6. .&0 $0%1008 (+ + +0$$ , $1.0$.$.1&.000$.0"#$%' %060 /3<6$0'%#.0/03$.&&.000&91.$ 9$.$5!+(.8 (  ! + 0$$   6. 6223. 0$. $.1&.0 00$ %## % 0/03$. &&.0 00&91.$ .0 1.3 "#$%'   %0 < 600 0.$0$%0600.'6..&0$0%1008 (  ! +  0$$ ,( + 6. 6223. 0$. 00&$3&.0 00$ %## % 0/03$. &&.0 00&91.$ .0 1.3 "#$%' 0  %0 @  .%

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

1010. 7+.8 ( +  + 0$$ ,  $ 1. $. $#&.0 00$   "#$%'    %0

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

1010.,55!+. 001   6..&0%##%$$9%#&.00$$00/03$.&&.0 00&91.$'$$0..'0%0&.&063%10'.01.&.0155 $16,'791.%$.C.00.%3.03 

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

+*+-

00$223.0    0$$0'00&)1.$ +0$$ ++$"#$% &"#$%%$$&&02$30&.'.000$.6&.000$  .$ $3 &&0 $0  ::%. $ :: 0 ". 0%$%.1 9%330$1+ (.'&.$ .$$3 0)'5 .%990'&.$.3 0".$0 001   6..&0%##%$$9%#&.00$$00/03$.&&.0 00&91.$0$%19%330'.01.&.019%&.01&.14  $167'5' 91.%$.C.00.%.0    //    223.% ' 0& .  6:. /. %0$ #$&.3 $0660 0$ #/ 6:./.223.%$00..$0.0= -455$16,'70093.0130.&060&.000%1.8 -4,7$10093.0.&060&.000!3%1.8 )-  4   $1 6 7' 5'    0093 .0 .&060&.0 00 )  ! 3 %1.  %$  4 !, $1 ') $.. .03 2..0 0.& 03&.000$$#6$..0&#.,!3%1. %$4 !7$100$%1.0%../.301$0) 7 +.!  !+3)690% %.$$#6$..0&#.,690%%1.    

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