Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
4-08-11647\2 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement of administrative decision regarding illegal residence permit revocation based on procedural defects.

Case Number 4-08-11647\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement of the administrative decision to revoke the applicant's residence permit. The applicant argued that the revocation violated the principle of proportionality and lacked sufficient factual basis, while the authority maintained the decision was legally sound. The court ruled that the administrative body failed to provide adequate reasoning and failed to consider the applicant's specific circumstances, rendering the enforcement order invalid.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Residence Act; s. 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act: An administrative decision is void if the decision-making body fails to provide adequate reasoning or fails to consider relevant circumstances, thereby violating the principle of proportionality.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit revocation proportionality principle administrative procedure defects enforcement dismissal adequate reasoning requirement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Residence Act
s. 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 

     

                

     !"!#$%&'("#)        *%!!+((        *,", -     '(""."*, ! !&*"/0,&'(        1111111111&111&",-%            

      !" "  #$%&'$(%%)  *  )                   ( +   ,    )                 -.!/. !!0 1           22!!0!!/-23     

  "/ 4!! 5     6             .  #      ..!%! (2$ !"  3#,! 4.!( )% %"! 4.!("& #%   ( %""(" "#..!""! (2%!4 , "! #&#..!$!,-,,"%! "'("#)     

5  /%"!4!6!" '( 4%"!,, "!"%"! )"(,"$!% % %(3% #!,!"%!"!(.."!),

&& ",,""% # !4%7( 33  +%! ! 8  !""!,."  (.."! "#!4,!#! ) "" "(- 9 "(3 %"!&  9 ,& +%! ! 8  %-  !""!,."  (.."! "#!4,!#! ) "" "(-  "(3 %"!&  ##  ,) 8!""!,." (.."!"#!4,!#!"""(-9"(3 %"!&## ,5 /%"!4!6!"'(4%"!,, "(.."!)

&& )2"9 





$"'("#))'(""."*, ! !(%  % #!4%7("!"(!, #!!"-  *(% !).-""."*, ! !$3,"."#!%5 /%"!4!6!" "(.."!),

&& &#%%!-(2%-,%!,#.." "(##9 , ."!#!,!"% % %""   !,2 ) 5  /%"!4!6!" (% ! %!% #% 4.!(% (2%-,%! %  !"  "."#"! ! (2%-, (.."!#!,!"%! "! #.-"  !%  !% ."#"! ! % (2%-,%!  "#!""  .""! ""." , #!"!% ($""% "."#! ".") )% ! %! (2%-, "( ",  :"!-" ) ,,"#"  , #!"!% (2%-, ,#!%! ( ! %! !-"!!"  *"!-"!!, #!"!%(2%-,%!%$2 "!;! !<!,=111!""> 2  " ! %! ""."%! "!  ,,- !%%!%! ! %! (2#% !,2!" 4??" #!" , #!"!% !- 9 (2%-, ! "??" 2%-, (!% (!  %  !"" & !%!%!,  

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





#4-(%-%!%,,4!!"((!%%!("!"## !").!"!94"!," "(%,2!"! "."#!& 4"!," ""! ($,!#"!"!, ) 3%!)..,  ##  ).!"! ,,4!!"(%! (,-%!! "#! (,-% !!!) ! ."!""    !!-!4!""$!!!,  "(!"-,,-)."$'(""." *, ! !(% % #!4%7("!5 /%"!4!6!"'(4%"!,,  3% #!,!"%! "! (.."!)

&&  ).- "( !, #! !"-% #"  ..,"!" !!%" %!%)),  !8%-      *%!!+(( ",