4-08-9800\2 · Court dismissed execution of a decision ordering the removal of a foreign national from Estonia. (Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the execution of a decision ordering the removal of a foreign national from Estonia. The applicant argued that the removal would violate their right to family life and that the decision was procedurally flawed. The court found that the domestic authorities had properly assessed the risk of re-entry and the best interests of the child, rendering the removal lawful.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 12 ust. 1 k.r.s.: The court must balance the state's interest in enforcing removal orders against the individual's right to family life, and removal is permissible if the domestic authorities have duly considered the best interests of the child and the risk of re-entry.

Keywords

AI generated

removal order execution family life rights best interests of child re-entry risk assessment foreign national status

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.

Art. 12 ust. 1 k.r.s.

Full text

!"

#$%$

&'(()$$'*+,--./"*0

&'($'1''2""$""

"'%$""!($"%$$

#!('%$"&'( !" "$$(3$ -

4"$$"'5,1%4$!$'$$6$!'$/

%$1,77,+/%$$4$!

%%!"4$$'1"/$!'1"1%$$"

%%("!$$'%%

!"1"(%

1""""'$

!

8"'"%$8$"$"%$$,77,+/$""

"' %$" #! "$$(3$ - 4 !$'

$6$$!'$

&'(("%$""!($%$$4$!

"

)0

%$$""%%'%1)",/+0$'

#! "$$(3 "$ )" 0/ "' " 1% "' #!

"$$(3 ' "' $' '4 %' %1

1" %$$" $!' 9"' "" ( "' 5 ,

%$'

#"

2%%" '$ )2

0 5 "4 %/ %" (:$

4"$ :$' $4 ' %"$ "1 "'$ !$ "'$

%$$"$"'"'1"4'"'"'$$'!$%"$

"1 !$ "'$ !$ "'$ %$$" (;;' %"$ "1 !$

$ %%4 ""$$ $1"$

"

%$"'$)

05"4%/$%$$4$!

%$" "!($ " %$$ !$ !"4$ "' "'$"

'%$$$%%

%"" 1" 4$ $ %$$ 4$ "'4 1 ""

"'$'$"'%("4"$'/$$'!$"$"''

$1"$""2

5"4"

4 $ " %$$ " $4$ ($'$ (!1'' 4 "

"'$"

5 "4 " $ %$ %$$ "' ""

%% $ '$ $4 " $'$ 5" ,/ $

::'" $ " $ $ %%' %1 ' !$' $

$%4$1%4$/$%$$%4$"($''1::'""$

"/$"""$!(;;

8' 1"/ %$ $ " $' " "' !"4$" !$'

$ '$ $/ $$ $ " " !$"$ %" "

"''("$$("$''$"'$"$4"1%

"'

$4$$ %"1! )" 0 " & '(( $' #!

"$$(3$ (" - "$$"' 5 , 1%4$ $4

$1$'1!'.-

$$"$($$$$($'$$)"+0"&'("'

%$")%$$,77,+0

4 %$1 ,77,+ %$ "' %$" '

%'%11"

2%%"'$)2

05+"4.%/"'$$(;;%$$"

4 %$'/ $ ;;'' 5 "4 ( + %' %4 1 %"$

"1!$%$$"(;;$$"'$":'

+)0

%$" '$ )

0 5 "4 " "!( %$" %%

1 ' %"$ "1 !$ "" %%' $

$!'%$$4$!/$$$"$!'$'$5

%'%11"

5"4(+)$,.$''$0%/$

%$/$%%1!$;;'':$5"4(+

"$%$/$%%'1!$;;''

$'

::'"$$,./$$"%%%$$4$

"'' $ ,. 5 "4 (+ %' %4" 5 .

"!$"

"$2

5+"4.15"4(+"/"'$$%$'/$

;;''5"4(+%'%4/%"1'$$'5

"!$%$$4$($$4$'1"'8"4$"$$

%"1''$$4$"'$+.

8' 1"/ #! "$$(3$ - 1!$

;;''5"4(+%'%4$4(''5"!$

%' %$$ 4$ ($ $4$' 1"'/ $$ "$ /

"2

5+"!$".'%$$4'

5 "4 " $' "'$ $' "1" !$4 %%4

$ %$$" (;;$ '$ ": " '"" $ " %"$

"1%%4$%$$"(;;$'$":'

$

!"$'$

$

$'

:

$

$$/$'"""""!$::'"$$4/$!$

%$$" %$" '$ %' $' ' %$ %"$

"1

%""1"$"!"4$$""44$$'$$!'$4!"

$'' $ $ 8"' )" 0 1 """ "$' )" -0

%/ !" 4%%$.&'("$($$'

!$4 $$" 1/ $$$' #!9$ $4" $"'

, 6 / "'' 6 + $4 2!$$

"''.%$$-$$

4($'$"!"4$1(::$"$$'%$$"$""'

$+.$'%$"'$5+"4(%$$

(%$"!"4$!$"$%$"'$5

- "4 ( . " ( %$ %$" !"4$ ($$" !$"$

$"$""1%%$$

<$'%4$1%"'/!"4$""'!#!

"$$(3$ - %$$ 4$ ('/ (' !$

$"%$"

)0

2"5"4("+$'""%$$4$($

%%$'$$/$%"$"1"$'%%$$""''$

%$$"(;;$'$":$!$$%$$%1($'$

#! "$$(3"$%%$'$"/$$$"%$$

4$('

%"1;;'':"$'%%1!$8'

1"/ %$$ ;;'' 5"4 (+ %'%4$4

(''5"4('//+1%'1"'/!""%$"'

%$$"'%$""!('%$$4$!

#$%$

$

Court dismissed execution of a decision ordering the removal of a foreign national from Estonia.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text