Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-08-5820\6 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation order based on family ties in Estonia.

Case Number 1-08-5820\6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Narva Court of First Instance dismissed the appellant's appeal against the deportation order issued by the Estonian Ministry of Interior. The appellant argued that deportation would violate his right to family life due to his wife and child residing in Estonia, while the Ministry maintained that the threat to public safety justified the removal. The court found that the family ties were not sufficient to outweigh the public safety concerns and the risk of reoffending, thus upholding the original decision.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Section 10 of the Aliens Act 2004; Section 10 of the Aliens Act 2004: Deportation may be ordered even if family life is at risk if the alien poses a threat to public safety or order, and the family ties do not constitute a compelling reason to stay.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order public safety exception family life rights Aliens Act 2004 reoffending risk proportionality test administrative appeal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Section 10 of the Aliens Act 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



  

         

   !"#$%&'!(#)  

     *++,   -( .(!       .#   

   %""(% //0(" 12%3)43' %"55"#" "(%"   "%64(            %( 777' 0 8289+' : 0 ' ""0'"#""%;!" """%'"(<<(& "#((=50$ >" 0;"%(%#"""%0%("&&&&     0"0!(%  ?"% !  !"#   !          $%&' (   )       *+ ,   -  .            $ /0   (         

    (&-&%-%&&0-    ((-&%-%&&0- 1 - % + , 2     )        )2       %+ ,%02    -        $ 34   (     2              1            2                       $ 35   (         2 ) 1 6 (, 



  7778 %,     

             

        8 *,    

              

                    8 4, 

  

                       2  8 5, 

 

       919) )22      

      $35 %2(  6       .-:             4''&      )2-        (0+    ,-     ;(&-((-%&&0- -              )  ;        1       )  -  )            .777:777+-7771    1777,    

     4''&+          , -  )                  

    6    /5%5 +           ,  1    <    !=   2  

        )     (/05 +           , &4  1    

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

 2                   

     

       )         1 --   $ %&'   (     >       -  >%%""(% '("#()%  ?"% !) 3 5(!  5<$ "%64(!"%&+&&>%#(0%"55"3 >$5< $(%""(% %"(" $2%3"((" 4(0("(#"5 "#"""(8 *%#,0! 3((&%00%""(% (" 19+)194(("0  3)4(( #>("(0 ! 3( (4(#"%" 5<<#( ( 3#"%' "( //0#>("( " 5 " "% (")% (#" ( ((% ("3 ) (40$ ("#%"   1 9 %3  4("((0 4(# (%%)5 00 (%% >0"0)(= , "%#(#44(0%%""%D , %## # %%0) #44(0 )!"#" )4"% # %%0 0 "3(""#"%"D

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