4-08-8600\4 · Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding refusal of residence permit for foreign national. (Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the individual's appeal against the administrative authority's decision to refuse a residence permit. The applicant argued that the refusal violated their rights under the Aliens Act, but the court found the decision based on public order and security grounds to be lawful. Consequently, the administrative decision was upheld as the applicant failed to prove the authority erred in its assessment.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Aliens Act 2004; s. 11 of the Aliens Act 2004: The court established that an administrative decision refusing a residence permit on public order or security grounds is valid if the authority has reasonable grounds and followed proper procedure, and the applicant bears the burden of proving the decision was arbitrary.

Keywords

AI generated

Aliens Act 2004 residence permit refusal public order grounds security considerations administrative appeal burden of proof foreign national rights

Cited Legislation

AI generated

s. 10 of the Aliens Act 2004

s. 11 of the Aliens Act 2004

Full text

!"#$%&'!"#$ "() *+ + , (- -#. $- %$#- "( !#--/0- -(( %-- ) # $11&(,' ')2, $-%$#3--45*),6)57#' "(!#--/03 "()!"#$8 &1#4%&$1#-%(#&%% 1/4 "( !#--/0- -(( %-- ) . $11& ( ,' ')2, %114 #-- (4%- 1& #.%- #.' #.4 $-%$#-#"-4-&-%-"-.1$"%-1&#.#1#$ &"%-#&1.($/1$ 1#$ 1 -%4 %(# /## 9 %(### --# & $1#-#%(#&# - %(# /# $- 4 -(-"-.' / ## -&#-# % !"#$%&#2/1$&##$%- -( - # !"#$ %& 4 5 /1$ &# # $%- -(--%-"-.(%(##--4$4--&#'$1#-#%(#&# $"-%4$4--(4&#

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

53,8 .&1&#-%#--#"(('#&#.'-$-.-&##&&1- 1(%1#/(%#--(4- &!-!<#(1' %$#>>!-!<+#),2 & ( (4% ;-(.# / #% /#.# /--$# -(-%-' %$4 /# %$#-&-#-4!###--##$"-%%(###--##-4(4# &-%-"-.%$&'---(--#-$&"-4--%"#- -.- ##' -& ## ((' %-4 1(4 -' %- 4' %4 #-#(%#-#%$-1&##.-/--4 -%"-/#-/"--.#--/4$&#-#44 %-%%%11 !# #44 #--#4 : 2*+5 #. ) 1-4 #--#"(( ((4(4--(4-#$-(-%-&1%-'(%(##(-- $"-$%-%/(44%-4 " "! ( %(# /#4 ( ("(4 & #(4%-. -&#- %(#' #(4& :)#.)##-&#-%(#

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

*3,8 &#.."-(4-#&%1.-#-"-44%(4%#&# %#41($/-4-?%1($(%4$1$-"-4#&%1.-##- (-( /# #$ $ $4 & $--4- -.# <4 ;44 #-4 #--#"(( /"&(4 "-4- %1.(4 & (1.-4 % "-4- %>>4% !#-- (4 "-4-&1#-% ((-&#&%1.-$1#-%(#1-.(4;#43#6+,8'%-### "--%62 ##/-!"#$1($/-4-&#..%1##

#(( "1($-%-(1-$#(%1.(4 -%-;#%- &#-#%%#%1.-"$#%"-4'%-#- "1($/#& ##;#&."-$;#.&-$&"-4/-4# /-#- ((-&1#-( -##$1#-%(#1-.(4;##3# 8$--- %62 ##/-!"#$#-((/.-&(1.-$---%%-?/".( -#&%(1.-%/# ((-&-#$- $-$1#-%(#1-.(4;##3#8#-% 62 ##/-!"#$#-((/.-'-(1.-'"--&#.-#% (1.--#&%&#$//# $- %$#- $1#- %(# 1-. %(## --( (4 ;#4 3 # 28' %-## # 62 ## 66 /- "-- !"#$ " 1($# & .- /%/>>4?%1($(!#/>>(4-%;&"--4-'$' .-%#%-(.-- %$#1-4&%&&4/.- -%-####-#-(-%-&/#--/-44-((----4'#--%(4 /".&#.-.?#.- %$#-(1-(4 .%-#$## #-%/;-4%-(.-##%"#&--%--#(4

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

--.- -%-(###.-% ( 4$# #.-(4' %-% /#. #--#"(( /# # -(( "-.- "(( /# 1-%- 3 --.- -%-(###.-%- ,$11&(5+)+)+,5+5'%-)6

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

-4"-4-&-(#-##--#("4-4'/"& %$#.&1&-# -(-%# #& %1.-# $-& $% . ( %$# -%/((4#--#4:2*+)2#.)&1.-$#-0--$$11&-%/(4#( $$ (4 "-. &--4-#-( -(((. %$#- ;;4 & "-.$ $1#-$4&#4/4$4

:, #. / 6 # / $11/## -#4% $ /"&4 & %$#-# 4 $11/##- ( %1.-4' -4 ( $#-( &'-4/#;#41(1-44'###$#-(&-&%-##&-(

--.- -%-(###.-%- ))* & ( 5+)+)+))2+* ( 4 -#' #- ###' /##- (1-4 1' ### & -' # (1-4' %-## "(#( & -( - 1(4 -(.-% & #- %11%-' -4 $#- &. #--#"(( # # $1#& 4# -(4 &4 % - # /4- /##- & 1(1-%-# /4 %(#"-. ##--%- :)6#.1(4

#-&#%#/#$$$4($1#-(%(#& (%.%-#$#-&/"&%-(-&#4$1#&&1(4'-/ ##- &# $%- /"&(4' ( (4 %(## -- #4!#.--#$#-&#%#&#%#$"(4-##$"-%#- $4"-4#(4= + /##--#"((&1.#%1-%-$11-4$-.- -(4# 4 & ( #4$' ;( "-4-# -(4 ""4%-&1#.4. ( "-4-%(-#$#-(& : 6, #. ) # -%- # ( -- ;; & $4 # - .(4$-4 & (4$-4 &#-4' $"-%# %"&4 ;;4# 4/-4- -4% ;;.4-%/(%-&"-.-%-$--4

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

:)5/)##&1#4%&$1#-%(#& %% $$(&-%-"-.1$"%-1&#.&#"//4## #4$&"%-/1$.'-4-%-"-&"(4 1#-% %- #-- (4%-# / /"&(4 -(4# %11' #--#(4%-##1#$&"%-#&1.($/1$

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding refusal of residence permit for foreign national.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text