Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-08-3301\4 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement of fines for unpaid fines, ruling that the debt was extinguished by the statute of limitations. The court held that the debt was extinguished by the statute of limitations. The court dismissed the enforcement action because the debt had been extinguished by the statute of limitations. The court dismissed the enforcement action because the debt had been extinguished by the statute of limitations.

Case Number 4-08-3301\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement proceedings initiated by the tax authority against the taxpayer for unpaid fines. The taxpayer argued that the debt was time-barred, while the authority contended the fines remained enforceable. The court ruled that the statute of limitations had expired, thereby extinguishing the debt and preventing its enforcement.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: The statute of limitations extinguishes the creditor's right to enforce the debt, rendering the enforcement action inadmissible.

Keywords

AI generated
statute of limitations tax enforcement extinguishment of debt time bar enforcement proceedings

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

              !     "##$$     %& '   ( ! &  ) * &&!&  & +& &  &

* & &'& 

   , )  - ( ! & .)- $/012121 & -3    4!   &+ &5&   .  + & !!      ! 3   *  ,& .3        !  ( !&  ) * &&!&  &+& & & * & &'& 

 ) )   &  4+& )  & * & &'& 

 * &&!&   *  ,&  * &  !  /66$"     &+ &5&     &'   !  $$/ ( ! &&  )  2 !!)& (*

 )  ( !&  ) * &&!& &+& & & * & &'&



    *   ,&   * &   !  /66/1 .   &+ &5&   01 &' ! 2$/1( !&& )  2 !!)&3

* &  ! /6$61.  &+ &5&  "2$  &'  &   ! 12$$$( !&& )     20 !!)&3 

* &  ! /66$2.  &+ &5&  2"  &' ! /$( ! && )  1 !!)&3  '&&!&   &&*

& & )         & +& & %  +*&   & +*&      &%& &    )

     &  & )     +) & )     & )    &%&    &     )

  .23 "#$ %$    ( ! &   !  "    & & !)  )& & + % +& ) 

* &&!& &) & * & &'& 

 * &  )&/66$"/66$2 /66/1/6$617& &!  )2 !1 !20  ! 12 !          *  ,& !& !)  & . 2#/3&& %& ( ! &  ) * &&!& &+& & &'& 

!+&!)   * &  ! /66$2! * &&!& & ' & &  &+ &5&   2"  ! /$ &!)   &+ &5&    )  1  ! !)& '! ! !)   1  ! "      &    *    0"  ! &&'  &   ! ) * &    ) )    &!)&& &'& *

&) !      ! !& *)& )   !)  &!&  &  ( &  & &!& & & & & & * &  )& ! &!)&   *& &!& & +  )  )# * &  /66$"  &+ &5&     &'   !  $$/  )    2  ! !&8 * &   /66/1    &+ &5&   01  &'   !  2$/1  )  20 !!)&  * &  /6$6  &+ &5&  "2$   &' ! 12$$$ )  !&& '!! !)+& &

* &&!& &   1 ! &' 1" !     20 ! 

   9  '  +&

& * &&!&    &'& 

   &&&! )  & ) 9#* &

) *    '+$ & .!$2 & !) &)  !3&     *  ! ::)!);   &  & ) & &  & * & &'!& +&%  ) )   & &'& *)&&  &'    & & * & !'

&'&&' &! * & & !&'!&   *   & % &   * &&!& &)  (&    * &   &  +& &&&& &'&' !   *  ! !) &) *  &!!&;&   ::) !&!)& &   4!  &+ &5&   + & !!   & . "3& &&  ( ! &  ) * &&!& & +& & &% *

 )   4!   &+ &5&  !( !&  )&* ' ) &)& )&' &

&!* ) *    !)  *  &&!)&<& )  &!& +& ( !& &  )   9/*

&)   %  #     %$     9'* & %& *&& +& ; &'&&  ;&)!!')  *&&!& &  &!)  &!) * &!& )  &) &% &'&)  &!) %  &!) &!)    *!& &!& &    &!)     &!) 

  $.23

* && +:: !)  *!& &!& &       !    &'  &!&   &    &!& &  9'* & %&    * & &'& 

 * &&!& &+& & & !   *    '!  )&  &!) & & ) *  !     !! !' ! (&  )& + &'&    9#  '  * &

)  )&'  &  &!) !& !      &!& &   9#  '  * &

)    ! +)

) ) =    *      * &   &!) 

&  !)&

)  )& !!' !)!)!&& & &   ) &  * &  & &  )& . #)#3!* %& - 3 * &   /661    &+ &5&   "2$   & !  12$$$   &!)  2$   )& & (&    /  !     12  ! !)& ! * &&!&   '

) /$    *   ,&   +  $  ! (&& * 

) * & & )    *     &2$  * !)&,& )& ) !)&)!02"   ) ) * & & ( ! & &   *   ,&     %; & 2"    *   !  !) && (&&  "  * & &  & ! !)& 

& &   % !) & )      &  )&   &!) & & '  3* &   /66$"    &+ &5&      & !  $$/   &!)     )& & (&    2  ! !)& !

* &&!&  '

) $"    *   ,&   +  02  ! (&&* 

) * & &)   *     &/2  $3* &  /66/1  &+ &5&  01  &! 2$/1  &!)     )& & (&    20  ! !)& !

* &&!&   '

)     *   ,&   +  $0  ! (&&* 

) * & &)   *     &0  <   *  &+& & * & & &   &!)!& * & !' * &  &  &!*      &+ &5&   01        &  &'&&   & !)  )'&  & & )  .> 3 9 $$"  &  & !)  )  

* &&&) && * &&+:: )&&& &'&&+*&  

& 0"  ) &&!& && )    & )   9$'2 * & %&  &!) &+::  * &&&'  *)& !::)!) 9'+#$ * &

) * &'  *&&!& &  &  & * &&+::  & &&) ; )  !$2 & !) 9$' &  * &&!&  '

&&!)   )&!!'&&& ) * &)&!) & !! !'* &)%&!)   ) &   * &&!& &   &+*& )&  * &  )&/661.   &+ &5&    "2$   &'   )       12  ! !)&3   /66/1 .    &+ &5&   01   &'   )

20 !!)&3& !&&) *&&!& &  &)) * &&+:: )

  ".23 '& &'&  * & & &   &'  &&+!&

) * &  )&  &   +& &

* &&!& &           *     &    & &'&

*)&  &&  & !) 90' &  * & & !&'!& & &  *   !'+& & * &&!& & '  * & &)! )& ) (&& ) &   & ;     ) && ! (& &  *&&   !

&&' !   & (&   * & &)*

&   )& &&&(& * !)& +& * &&!&  &  &  & ) !) !* %  *     & & (&!;& .  &+ &5&  2"  &'   ) 1 !3" *  !)    &+ &5&   "2$   &'   )   +& & * &&!& &    *  !) '! +  )&  !& * !&  %     & &  (& 

* &&!&  &  &  & ) !)    9  '   &  +&

& * &&!&   &   & )  *& &!& &  &  & & )  &!)& * & &'&



  &&&! )  & ) 9#* &

) *    !&!   ! !&!$2 & !) 9#' #"  9'+$.!/2 & !) &)  !3* & &   &  

*   & & & !::)!);  &   9'+$  & &     *   &  & ) & & !::)!)  & &  ) , & )& (&   & &'  &%  & & * & &'&    ) )  ! /2    9 ' +$ * &

) ;&   

* &' ' *&&!& &   &+) ) !)&)!&!)& &  %&&) ) & !&&) )&)  &%  > 9#10'  9#"'" * &

)  *   ::)&  <   &)   +&  !) +& &&' &!&   & * !)   & % &    9  '  + $ &% '&!) )  &&  &   &  * &

) *   . ! );   & & & 3 &%  )  &  

& ) & *   & &'& *)& ! 

) 9#'+$ * &

) *   & * !&&!  &') &    &  +)& +    .&  &   &'& &  & & !& 

& * &&!& &  !&  )   &'& +&!&3 !   &&  &  )  )  &% '&

!! !) & &  &  & )& * &

)  & * & &' *   

&% ;!&  )  !) *    !  )  !) !   !'!!    !!  !'!! .  !!  !'!!  $/   &   ! "#/#8 !!  !'!!  1/   &  "#/#08  !'!!  $1/     &  ! "#/#"08   !'!!   $/     !    !  #/#$28   !'!!   $     &   "#/#11/3   &&  &   & +    .  ) )  !!  !'!!    &!))3  &  !  &  )&  )    '   )&&'21  &  ! $#$###1! & &!)& &'& ;&  ) ) &  &  &  &' *    &% ;!&  ) !) *    ! (& &  )&  &+ &5&  01   * &&

  2.23 +:: )&  & !)> 9#$$"* &

) *   !01   "2$   & *   

) 9#'+$* &

) *      & & !&!)&   &  * !& &'!) !!' * &&!& & +& & +)%   *  &%&

&& +    & * &. *  +& &    &!) ; &' * & !' 3 ) && &     &  & * & &'& 

 * &&!& &+& &&  , )  

 

* &   /66$"

 

* &&!& &      &+ &5&      &'  !  $$/  )  2  ! !)& +& &  & * & &'& 

 !   & +&!) )   % ) &&  7&

) * &   ! !) !&    & * && +:: & *&&!& & !;  *  & & !)  )& !) * &&!& &  & ) 5  &   ! *   &)  &!) &  ) &  $"    & !& * & & ! '!&  )& ) & 02    *  !! &. 23  !' )  * & &5 *%& & *' !&

) !& !  & '&  ;& &&&   *  & & '  & & &  !)      & &     & & + !) + &'!&   *   ,  &% )  & & &      &+ &5&      &

* &&+:: !&&& !)&  & !)> 9#9$$"* &

)& & *    & * !& &'!)% &!!& 9#* &

)

* &' )& &       && 

 ! +&!) ) * &&!&  * &   /66$" & * & &'& 

+& )   (&  ) * &&!& & +& &  & * & &'& 

 * &   /66$2      &+ &5&   2"   &'   !  /$   )  1 !!)& &%*

 )  !   *  !! &!&&  "   ) *&&   !) * &&!&  && !)&&

 9'*

&) % &!) )  * &&!& & &*&&    !*  

&& *&&!& & &!)  & ' & (& & & ) )   9/*

&)  &!) )  ) & ' * '%* ' *&&   +!

&'&    9#  '  * &

)  )&'  & &&    &!   ) )   &!) !& %   9#  * &

)   & &   & 

% &&     *     *    )& &   9  '   &  & %   *  &&  )& &&!)   &