Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-08-3521\3 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against enforcement of administrative penalty for illegal construction of a building.

Case Number 4-08-3521\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the enforcement of an administrative penalty imposed for unauthorized construction. The appellant argued that the building was necessary for family life and that the enforcement procedure violated their rights. The court rejected these claims, ruling that the administrative body had correctly determined the violation and that the enforcement measures were lawful and proportionate.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Administrative Procedure Act; Building Act: The court established that an administrative penalty for illegal construction may be enforced if the violation is established and the enforcement measures are lawful and proportionate to the infringement.

Keywords

AI generated
illegal construction administrative penalty enforcement procedure proportionality principle family life rights building permit appeal dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Administrative Procedure Act
Building Act
buildingact

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 

      



    

         !          "#$% &      

# $# '() *+,,*- #) !(#  &#$#.##  #$#  &%!$.#

  " #( &#$#.#

#

$# #  ! ##/#  

#0 '( 0#$#  . 1 ( 0#$# #( ' 21 3  0  4&0 $ #( !  , . 5 #. ($#-  &#4 . *66*+*- ## # &$# #0$#     $&& ! 0.#- #. (4# 4 &#

     &&# ## ! % #( $&&#%#    ! $4#  &#! 4 # ## #($#       7!(# # . & 7!#  $#.## &# . *66*+*- $# . ( &#$#.#  ! ##/#   #0 .  $ #( !  , .  &$#

# $ . % &#$#.##  #$  ! ##/# # .  .(&$# ## #0$#    !#    # 4 # .( ./$. &#$#.## $# 

     ! 

& 7!#  #%- # ##$&0( # &$.# # # #0.(- . # .(&$ . ( #(# &#( &4 4-  #..#  $88($ !&# $#.##4 # 4 $- ..0 ! 0.# . !&4( &##(



'1 ,+ - +  4 +   3  &#( #0$&4 4 #% 9.# ( .(&$ # .(&$ . ( &## $#0 ' *1

#. (4 5 " . ##/# #%- #  $# !( # 4& ($ 4 ($ # #.(#. #- .  . 0##0# (#( &$## 4 & . .( ## &$ ## ## # !#(- # ! 0. . $# .( $ #( ! &$# #(- #  . &.( *  0 !(- $ . # $ #(  4   ' +- 1  "!  

:&&#$#.## #( ': 1 3  0  &#%- # &##! #9 #0##$ 9$#( ..0 $( !&# $#.##4 #.( !  #.( &$# $.#!( #( 4 #%#0#( #.(% #.( #.(  !  !&.# $#.##4 !  #.( !  #.( &$## 88.( !&.# $#.##4 ! $ . $ $&&#0 $#.# # $ 4 $#.##

&#$#.## #( ' 1 3  0  &#%- # ! &$# #0$#   &#$#.##  #$# # . & !  ! 0. !(# #.($# #( &$. $&&

. &##! 4 . #0#$  3  0  &#( !(#0-  . ## #.($.# ! $ 4 $#.## :  3  0  &#( 

(! ## ' 1 4 # ' 1 .&%- # & 7  $#.## . &# . *66*+*- $# $%  ! ##/#   #0 '( 0#$# 4 . 1 # $## 2 3  0  4&0 $ #( !  , .  .(&$.# & . .( +  ## .$#( # .(&$#   $# # 5 #- &.. 

& !# ' *1 # .  ! ##/#   # .(&$# 0( &#$#.# *  ..0 & .  $## !&4.( &##( , 4 + 

( 0#$# # #0#$# 4 #.( 2 3  # # .( ( &$##-  #( # .( &$## 88(   4 ## #0#$# &#! !#

. .$#( #  . &#$#.## 0.(  !  &#!.( *  ## :   &#.. #. (4 !(# $ ' 1 ..0  (!( &#( .($#(- $ #  # &$# :   &#..#-  %  !( #(- # # . 88.( .( # &$## 0##0#-  ## #0#$#   4

+  4 ( :  4  :  3  0  &#%- # #.( # 88 &$## #0 &(#-  . $88(.(

 3  0    &#( &#0 4 !&# $#.##4 # !  #



'1 &$## 88$ # # #( 9(

&#$#.## #( '#(( 1 3  0  #  ## &#$#.# !&&# 4 #( !&# $#.##4 # !  # # $&&( ! #. (# &$# #0$#  -  ! # # # . ( #( 3  &#( &4 4

 3  0    '. *  #.( #(.1 &#- #  #  &$-  !&&## 4 $# . $88(.( 9  #!  3  0    # #   &$-  !&&#  #( # 4 $# . $88(.( ## (

 #% :  3  0  4  3  0    &#  0#.((#- #  & +  . #(.(4 #.( # &$## 88$ 4 ## &$- ( .99( . #0# &#( ##(- # #.( # &(#-  . $88(.(  3  0    &#( &#0- !&4 !(  #.#!(  3   #  # &$# #0$# #$ .0!( 4(

. 99(  #..# * -  #% !&&## &$# #0$#  (( . *   3  0    &#( &#0 !!  3   ## 

7!#(# 4- #  ! ##/#   # ##(!

4 $# . $88(.(  3  0    &#( &#0 ..0 (!(  

3    # &#( # &$# #0$# #$ .0!( 4(-  #% - # !! :  3   ##  . .( # &$.# #0.(

:  3 + 0  # . !( #.( #.( $#.##4 0 $ $&&#0 ! &$## 88$.# #( 9 # #(#! # # !&.# $#.##4 $ $&&#0 ! &$## 88$ #( 9.(

! $#  !#($.# #  #.#( 9.# !$$ $#$#- !( ##  #% $  99(# !# #0#!- $ ##% ! $ & &#$#.## #( &#( $##$#( (# & !&# $#.##4 

&##! 4 # # ! 0. $#00 .( ! #. ($ #0  !# (.( ! $#

#% !#(  #(- # ! 0. # # .( #( #$ # ( &#$#.## ..0 #( # ..  !(# $.# *  0- $ ( # $ #( #   4    ' 1

& . &##( , 4 +  ' - 1 .(  $## !# (# 5  !- &# +- . !#0 .($##  !$.# 4%   # 4( (# #  #- &..  ' ,1

&##! 4 . $88(.( 9# #  .$#( !&&## ##(!

4 $# . 99(.# # # $#00 .( ! #. ($ #0  !# (.( ! $# ..0 # &$## 88$ # # #( 9( #0 # &$# &#0 #.(( ##  #% - # .(



'1 !&&## &$.# . #.( 9# $  4

 3  0    &#( # &$# #0$&4 ##$&0 .- # !&&##0 $ #( # '  !1 # 4 #/#!.# &(#!$.# !( 99(## $ 4 #((# ($# 99#0(# $#.#$ ..0 # ##0 0 !#

## ## &#%  3  0 - #   !  !&.# $#.##4 # # $&&.( ! $ - # ! #!. & ..% ! 0.# ! #!. $# &4- $ # # 9#$   &#! #0 #$   &#!

 3  0  #-  ! #!. $&&( &&#! #  !   ( ! $# &#0 # 4&0 4 ! &$# &#0 # # #.(( ..0 ! 0. # # !- $## #. # 88- (% & #. (4 # !(# ! #.($# #0 !! #( 3 * &## # &$## 88.( $# !   # . #.( !&.# $#.##4-  & 4&0## $# $0.#  $ # . &#( :  3   #

 . 0 ,  # '4 . 1 #(.(- # # &$# #0. ##.% ##$&- # # &$.# # $ #%$   4 & 4  # ( -  &  ! ! $ #.(4 # ( #(# &#( &4 4 ((  !  !&# $#.##4 # &$  &##! 4 % .$#( 0 # .0  !#(

 #%- #  # #.#  3  0  (# - -  4  &#( !&&## &$# #0$# #$ .0.( 4(-  #% !&&# &  3  0    $&0( &4 4

;   0#.(( :  3  0  4  3  0    &# ##- #  3  &#( #0$&4 4 #% 9.# ( .(&$ ' ! 0.# #$.# &##1-   00# $ #  3 * 4 :  3  &#( #.(# ($# .. $ $ 4 .( #0 $ #( ! &$# #0 #%$&&# 4  ! ## 0# & ! $# 4 $#  #  ## 4 #.$ &&( # '!1 9( 4 ##!#.!# ##$&0 ##0 .  0#.(- #  3  &#( #0$&4 4 #% 9.# ( .(&$- #% 0# ..0 ! 0# 9(..(  $ ## 4  <# :%0  #(# 3(#  4  &#0

. # &$# . $88(.(  3  0    &#( $  &#0 ..0 (!(  3  0  (# - -  4  &#( 4(- ##  #% ##&#( # &$# ( &$#.#  #( &$# #0$#   "#$% &

.