Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-08-3530\3 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation of foreign national based on public order grounds.

Case Number 1-08-3530\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the administrative decision ordering his deportation to Estonia. The appellant argued that the decision violated his right to family life and was disproportionate given his long-term residence and lack of criminal record. The court rejected these claims, ruling that the state's interest in maintaining public order and security outweighed the individual's personal circumstances in this specific case.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 127 § 1 of the Migration Act; Art. 127 § 2 of the Migration Act: The court established that deportation may be ordered based on public order grounds even when the foreign national has resided in the country for a significant period, provided the decision is not arbitrary and serves a legitimate state interest.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order public order grounds family life rights proportionality test foreign national status administrative appeal residence duration

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 127 § 1 of the Migration Act
Art. 127 § 2 of the Migration Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

          

   !"#$%&'"#$ #(  

     ) !)*+* , !-+ -.   ( /01       0  

   "22304&51  60#     3*7**-+8080 /13(8 03018 0%00 )  00 008 99/ 6)  &000&(8$0%%(%8#0(300 33   

(303$ ((      

  !" 7 ! "223((34&51&3001+ )3050$%55, 50$%55  7* (.  !-+  ,0  3 $2%%0(3. ( 1300 

5&%#"%0(030((3-++,$32%%0(3$. (&%%0&300010%0*,%2%%0(3.( 0( 1300 

(0   3   & 0 0 &#%0  (3%(00% $00  *:7;-  "(1$# *77!- -((1$0(%/0: -+ *+ ,%530%00105&(%/&(%0'000. 0(033&00&#%0 (3%(00%$00   *:! 7   "(1  $#  *77!- -  ((1 $0(%/0 ! :;!7: ,%530%00105&(%/&(%0'00%0(00.

,7.   03 (#303  0 50 0 5010 3' (0 (003  50%0(00 5/$%05050%0(000300(53        0(#10%0$0/030,"#$%&3. &0%050$&00%00 : ! 0(000,"#$%&3.&$002%(050$ &' 0 50$' % %0(00 0 ( $#%  $3 01  0 : ! %(%0(00302$%00$#/$330032%(050$ & 0 0  %0  0  : !   %550/0 0%0 00 00(30        "22304&51$<00$0%0(0%0'%0(0 00'00% !  !0 "#$(((*$300 (0 %000 3=%  00  "  0 <22 $51$3 & 0 (((0<22$>(((501#&203%993 0( 200' %# ((( # 0 $ 0( 0$3 30(13 00 #   " (((0201$#1"0%010$01")0 <22$&0%#&30(000?*@%((1$0  "0((0322302230((  #    $ #%    &(3&51%#0(303>  "(1(3203'%000% !  !#%01 "#$&0330/0((100$(0%220%'03 $3&/$31"50&30&5(0%0#03 "&%15(3'2(1020%'03/3(1 3&0(3"500&3020%'003(5$30 20"&99&0'03$300& 50%$30$ 0000 "  5  & 5 %(( "  $#  5$0 (( & $ 3=%0$30&$'3"#((0$#(3'%993 0(02(30199(3"%(00&33=% &51    &     00 00 $30 "    "     230 &30 &(55%'30000(%&0%533$00&%" %01&5%(0%50&0%'0350$3/(' 0""0%0  ((( " (1(3203'%000% !  !# 0&  "#$&3%5(13/0('%5200230 , 00 (% (  .  $ 03 23 $  /0( $5&  "  20 000 230'05(230300(3'"0523

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

:,7. ((&(1(3200(&%000&3'%0 0(0%#13(00003&%0003"&  (101/00%0(331$3(0$&(0(5(3' 3(30$00$3"& (&%0003(33  !&((00030(3  "0(33,+.(5$( !  !0+:&/0993(3" 0/01'00*!&&3=%"#020"((3 030%#(1&0010(0?*@%&00(0//$  ((0 1% 3 #0(303 , 223$' (((' ((( 0(3& & ((&0203((10(3.0/#0(3'0 !  !0  &:+$00&"#$(((*$300&%0003=% "00"0<22$51$3'030(((0<22$ B22(0$51$30(000'0""501#&203%993 0(20'%051"#0$0(0$330(13 00#"" 201$#1"0%010$01"<22$&0% #&30(00?*@%000  "  0 0 0(3 03' 0   !  ! #  300 &  "  %000 3=% $  03 ( (((3  ((&3   ((1 "  ( "  & " $/%3=%0#$03010((0&%&#0%(((3((&  (((("20(5/'0&$/0)$0&((&  20 (5/ %' 0 &%   %/0 :+ & #0%' &503/ 00' 0 2230 %513 2(3% $# 0 03 !  ! # 0   &  :+ $00&(((&223$$503($5$300'%(1<220 $51$%""03=%$/%0&003$#%0 "(<220$51$%0(3"(0&03(3'3"03 %%0#((3020#'$0(2'%3"0320 1##"20300'0"03#((3020 #(#((& 201'0033=%0(03020 0(51((("&((& 200$030100&(5 "/0'0(33(5$(0+:&"#00(3 030%#(1&0?*@%(0010(0"(&5100 (513%#((& ((1(((030(3& " $0&'0"203#((3%0&20#%0(# ((&   201' "  201'  % 0(33 <001'  00/ ((( 203 3$550%   223$ "  203   $0 0(33 <003 03 "  0 $/ &0' 0 0  %(1 $ <220%#&3 &3'0&$0%&%(&"/0993%0 $0((355%0$50'&& "#$1$350'(($3 3 00' 0 ((( "   0 (3 (0  0(3 & $51$ %&'%0%(1%$&% $002((& 2032%/0"& 2((&  20000(5(3%(1"&"$0<22(%(5/  2000'00%&#33=%$%0('03&/00"'"&

  1    ( (((3' 0 &#3 3=% $0 00  ' ( 00 2%/0 2300#0(301((& 20000'0%3=%' 003000%0(3'"&"0(3223$0((((3'0 "3=%00(%(001$#/300'0 0

+,7. (3#03=%%$(5'(&#33=%"&"%#(301 &0% ((&   ( (((3' 0 "   "  0 '  0% 3=% 0(0001<22(0("&"$0#00#0(3&'%  3=%0(0 

03(#0(3300'%%0""003=% 53  ( 223$ (((3' 0 5%  ( 20  ((( "  & ((& ((((3'05%0&((($50%#0% %  $51$ %(0  ((&    ( (((3' 0 (51 "  & " 3=%%(0(20((&"((((3'0"5 3=%20$0#0(3$3(((&((& 203'0" 5"3=%0((& 2000%#0& %$5000((3'(0100&%01"&"3=%%(0(51  '    0 &% #0% & /0( $5&  ((& "  ( (((3'00%3=%#$(1"3=%5((( "((((3'0"(1'55%500'00 $0&503/(((&((&"20&'0"3=% #$0(10%%0503'"&/20"3=%5 5(3  ((("((0$'"03#((3020#&0 $ 30(1 5 # "0(33 (5$ ( "  $  0$(3   /0 99330$000#&03((($50'0"010$0%0 <22 $ #&  5/$0 51 ( (3 03  0% # (1&0?*@%(0010(001(0(&55(3%1(5$&51' $#/ 0033' 0 00 &5&0 0%(0 #&  <22 $ (  $' 0 0 599%(0 $ 30(1 #& ($ $  &0' 0  (((  " 010$0 1&5&0 %0 10' $/  $0  00' 0 "    (% (((((((3'0$5(%((& ((((3'0(51 "(%((&3"& ((((3'0(0%3"(%0(5(3 %(223$"(((3'0"#0020(%"( 0(3((((%0%&1'0$%(03"30& 5%(0%(((1(0%$&'0(((0(% 003<220((05   $0 0 $50(3 ((( 20 3$55 &' 0 0(33 ( <0030%0/0(2(0020#%(0&%01#99% ((( 03 0(3& ( (((3' 0 01 $0 00  & & &#3% 55&(%%300"550%0(0#%0 1 99%0   0 599%0 $ 30(1 "  ((0  0% " &0%&(0#%099%0199%"0'(( " ((00%00#%$0&'0"%#$000 &(3$3'0"0#%00031#'$/000' 0010%00(((&0%$5&%#03322301'$301000 #003(32(3%01   $0  0 0  ((( "  & ((&   20  #10  03 00#'0"& 0($0%&%%0((3  (( ((&  ' 0 ( "       (  $0% 33 & 000&%000003&303((30"&

-,7.

0(((&$3(3013%05%00&0( 0&$&%051&300'0"& 0100$3 $51$3&%0/%3$0$300010%01'%3"& 0  0 0(3 3  (((1   "  &   $0%3 %03' % 3$  53 5$(0 0 13% $# 03$  $5501 $300 $%%(0 0 50(3 00(00 03' 0 (3 !  ! # & &(  $03 1  00 $' ( "  &   203  %$000 %%00#%30#0(301C00#100(3331'% " 201 &'0((("(50010%55%0(01$01'0 ((   0% 0% "#$ 612%(%'  0%0 " 3$   (((1 223$ "#((("0<22$51$3 00 01 & #& (((0 $ $50% 30 01  $0 1(%0010%015$(/'05010((3000 (%00##%(0$#199%(0$#/$%00$03  B220$51$%01"0 !  !#"#$300& %000 3=% ( "#  %0 "   00 $550%0  (((1 "#  223 & 0 #1$ $5$3 &3 3$3  $<00/ "#%0(34&51  &$3051$30'0"#00%0((3#1$ 01'(0$(0%(0%(((5$3$0000 001 %51/  &51%  (((1   0/ & "#   %0(3 #1$$5$&(%0%4)!150'%00 0100#1$(0'#&/$0$#$0000$#1$2((0 0(3$#00#12$0300'&302(3&#12$03'20%00&0 5300((&"20(5/'00%"& %$00 &&%0  00 ' 0 (0 "  0 (3 &  3 55    "#00033'0"0&&%0#10'$#/0010$, 5$3 000 0 0 (3. #00  33 #1$0 2(30 "# 20"00/$03'0203&0(3"#%(0% 0  "   0 %  3  $0  00' % "#  & "  3 3=%&030$3$51$%(0'031103 "#  5300(3 0$ 5300(3 0/ $0 0%0$ $# $0000$#1$02(30#0033'0((("/0(0 31 "  $51$1 5$3' 0 (3 "#  & "  3=% &#30 00 5$30 (5 0(%  010% 0 $0 01 $0 000$ 2(301 "  5 5$30"#055%5"#"&30'%#0%333/0( $5& 0% & 53 00&50 3=% D$30  00 & %0 &/ % %( %993(3   E1$(0 2((0    $530$ "   5$3%(0 $51$ %01'005$30010%01&"0$%01&//0( #0$33"3/11(0$'0"$"5$3%&5' (0000$20%0$#0(300'%"$51$%0 5$30 & 5 03 0 20%' 0 (3 010%  0(% %(1 % #1$0 2(301'%3("#$0#&30(0$"(32"&  %5(1511$03'3"13%&"%"&

00"#0%30$000%"20(5$0(%0&5(3 

7,7. 0 %#%0  0/  4 +- 0   $03   223$ 223'  010(3$3 & 0(3$3 &3' % $#% %#&3 223$ 033 3%220130%0(0%0&#1%0$3 0 /1 00030  4) *  1  ( #3' 0 /% ( 0 $55%(0' %%(0 $# %(0 $' % $%/ 0 (' 0/ 0 0 & $# / 31 0 0% $%0 $# 0 0$  % 0304) (5030030/(%00113$ 5% , 1 . & % #10 %0 0   &3 00 0 01 5$(0 030 $0 & #1 , 1 .   $0/ "#  22 0 (3%0&'0"#010$%0&0(33"00(0$13% 5%0"#20"#0(30,0/%"#$530' 0 "   0%  5$(1  030 000 00  0//$3 $5&0(303. ((( 0(3 (%$55(0 5%(0  $0 $50(3/  "# 223%0300'0"#220$51$50 &00$3 00'0"#03'0((((0(00$51$%(000 0 ( ($ & 03 0(% 5$(  00 0  "#   0(3/ 220 %0(0%(0 03$ (0%  000  0 010(3$3&33$3  4  ((( 00 (53((0$(101 00&"#$"0&((#0(3,)3'*.(5$("#$0%( %(   $550%0(00% 99(3&6 0%/ "#$51$0,!. $030&3'0"#($0%% &030%0$515'0/'0"#$#/3010%10 0  0 01 & 03 0% 22  $030  (( %%5505030%55 $000223$0%050$00& 00%0("#0%050$007*(,* .  0(0$  4)  !  1  2$/ %0(03 223%#0 500$ %(&(%0(030223%#$01(0$(3'+1 %%550%%-++(&&0%(%%0& 010%0*' (,*:.'%0/223$1300$5&%#