Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-08-1158\4 AI generated

Court dismissed settlement agreement as it violated the principle of good faith and lacked mutual consent.

Case Number 1-08-1158\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court rejected the settlement agreement because the plaintiff failed to provide evidence of mutual consent, arguing the defendant acted in bad faith. The defendant contended that the agreement was valid despite the plaintiff's objections, but the court found the procedural requirements for a binding settlement were not met. Consequently, the agreement was declared void due to the absence of genuine agreement between the parties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Civil Procedure Code; s. 10 of the Civil Procedure Code: A settlement agreement is only valid if concluded by mutual consent, and a court cannot enforce an agreement that violates the principle of good faith or lacks the necessary mutual agreement.

Keywords

AI generated
settlement agreement mutual consent good faith principle civil procedure void agreement

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Civil Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

          !"#    

  $%&'(($% !"#  

     )$*    !"+' ,!-+#.& #. .+ /'..0.1+2( !!,'!3  '.'#    /3! +(. #/ #+!3 /3! +/#.&  

   4.3,.'53!! !3#--/'#+#.# 6(,$&1,'% /'0  ' #--/'#+#.#  6  (, $ & 7$ 1,' ! (.&&.0..+(#.#%            ( !"+8 #'  !!/8**9*

!/ !/##8   '/#8 0 ..(8 :&&.#+#8 .0 '0'( !# '#+0+%

'+#18/#.&

2 ./;.( !"#+(" 0'#. ..(/ !"(/+/%%$)     

    ( !"+8 #'  !!/8*)$$

!/ !/##8 '/#8 0 ..(8   :&&.#+#8

'#++#8 '0'( !# '#+0+%

'+#18(. #/ #+!3

 $ 

2 ./;.( !"#+(" 0'#. ..(/ !"(/+/9%%$)   !"#  4"'//.# 6$76$ !"#!+##+# !         $%&' ()%*    +     ,

   % 

6)(,7*(#.(1++3,'#+#+'.(' (++','0#(' (++'+0'#.(.&<<0+ '4.3,.' =3!! !3.'&.*#+#. '+0'# !+!((', +#.11!! #(+!'0.++"+('  '+.,1 +'/> 6)#+.#++/ !+!((2/.'/1 !"#+#'% 

6?(,(#.((,./ + #..(3,'#+#.#3''>'+/.,%9%$)%% '%%$)%% #%!%$&.3%  

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

    % 

 6 ) (, 7 *(#.( 1++ 3,'#+#+'.(' (++','0#(' (++'+0'#.(.&<<0+ '/'0  '.'&.*#+#. '+0'# !+!((', +#.11!! #(+!'0.++"+('  '+.,1+'/>

6)#+.#++/ !+!((2/.'/1 !"#+#'% 

6?(,(#.((,./ + #..(3,'#+#.#3''>'+/.,%9%$)%% '9%%$)%% #%!%*&.3%  

2 ./ . .( !"#+ (" 0'#. ..(/ +-"'#+/ /'0  'C' #"+.# !"+!+##. 12#+0'#.(%

'#+#. /0'#.1(,#+3+(+.#$%%$ 

 6 ) (#.( 3(1 02'#+ 0..+(# ( /'0  '@(+ 1 4.3,.' =3!! !3C'(+ #!('/#.(+ !!+'('#.'.. #&.+''#+.!#+0'#...#+. #&.+''#' +))D ;$ !!'7E. #&.+''#'+.!#+0'#...#+. #&.+''#' +$$)D*$ ;)$ !!'%  (102'#+/'0 '@(++#'','2',#>'..#+#.'+#.#/.(' -00./ !(0)*  !!'1  #.+' ',  6 )9 (,  & $ (#.( #/"  )  -00. +"+ ". ##/ #.'+#. -00./3''#  !!''','+(/.##.%

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

  -                   

-   

      

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

   0 +.,.3#., ' # /'0  ' I !!+'('#+. 1 &#-""!+!!&#.+. '.+. ', ./. ("+.'.+.#./#.I6*(,16*(,*#++.'/%  

  -                   

-   

      

-        )  )  )     )         )     

     - )       $ %&'   ( ) %- ( *    1       2     ) )+  

  4.3,.' 53!! !3 1 /'0  '   +'#+#'/ .#+ #--/' +'.# 0"#% ! < 1 #--/'#++3/ '+#1+. 1.#!(. ( ! #2(0'/ ! (.&&.7 0'((. !"#.(+ &! < 2/'# !"+#8 --/'+'#+/4.3,.'53!! !3 6(,$&1,'',02'#+ '#+#. #*#++ 3,'#+#+70'(('.1++ 6)(,7*(#.(+'.(' (++','0#(' (++'+0'#.(.&<<0+ ' 4.3,.' =3!! !3 .' &. * #+#.  '+0'# !+!((', +#.1 1!! #( +!'0. + +"+('  '+.,1+'/> 6)#+.#++/ !+!((2/.'/1 !"#+#'%

6?(,(#.((,./ + #..(3,'#+#.#3''>'+/.,%9%$)%% '%%$)%% #%!%$&.3%--/'+'#+//'0 ' 6(,$&7$1,'',02'#+ '#+#. #* #++3,'#+#+70'(('.1++ 6)(,7*(#.(+'.(' (++','0#(' (++'+0'#.(.&<<0+ ' /'0  ' .' &. * #+#.  '+0'# !+!((', +#.1 1!! #( +!'0. + +"+('  '+.,1+'/> 6)#+.#++/ !+!((2/.'/1 !"#+#'%

6?(,(#.((,./ + #..(3,'#+#.#3''>'+/.,%9%$)%% '9%%$)%% #%!%*&.3% 

2 ./;.( !"#+(" 0'#. ..(/+-"'#+/#--/'#++3+.#"+.# !"+!+##.12#+0'#.(%

'+#1/1'/#2(0'+/ ! (.&&.1/.1&(#'/#.((. ''+/% 

 

!"+(' +0'#.&2"1(+.,' !"#1.(/#./7.+#--/'#++3+.#--/'+'#+0'.1 ! (.&&. #2(0'0'.!!(/#--/'#++3+.+2.('.+"+.3(/#1 '0'(#10..+(.0'#.(!1,'+/ ! (.&&.0..+(#.#++.'/%--/'#++34.3,.'53!! !3+(.>#--/'+'#+/ 6(, $&1,'',02'#+ '#+#3#+3(+ ! (.&&.(.%--/'#++3/'0 '+(.>#--/' +'#+/ 6(,$&7$1,'',02'#+ '#+#3#+3(+ ! (.&&.(.%--/'#++3+.( 3#++#+ # ./3'/ #1!(#'/ .' !(. !"# +3#+/% .,./3 # #1!( # (,.# !"# &"+#-/0('  ".+##+% / +    ;  . #&.+''#' #/.+/  !!+'('#./ './ ; .& 1 E ; 1++ (('

!"+. #&.+''#'1 '0'('#+'  .# ##.(#8#'#.0''#+'0#7$%%$%%  (3+' 7 -!! '(0 '(. !+'/7 (>'&'#+3/ '(. !+'/ 1 0'','& '(. !+'/ ; "3'+/ !"+!+##.12#+0'#.(%

#'3''(",'.#'++/.'!(.%   ,!-+#.&

!"+'