Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-08-4434\1 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against minor's detention, ruling the measure was lawful and proportionate under the Juvenile Justice Act.

Case Number 1-08-4434\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu County Court rejected the minor's appeal against his detention order, upholding the lower court's decision. The appellant argued that the measure was excessive and violated his rights, while the state contended it was necessary for public safety. The court found the detention justified by the minor's age, the nature of the offense, and the lack of alternative measures, thus ruling the measure lawful and proportionate.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 10 of the Juvenile Justice Act; The court held that pre-trial detention of a minor is permissible only when strictly necessary to ensure the safety of society or the proper conduct of proceedings, and must be proportionate to the circumstances.

Keywords

AI generated
Juvenile Justice Act pre-trial detention proportionality principle minor's rights public safety alternative measures appeal dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
§ 10 of the Juvenile Justice Act
§ 10 of the Criminal Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                

                             

              !" " " 

 #  $  % &&&& &&&& &&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&  % "%"'"! "(%)" %

" !"  *    %   !" "    )"  "% !     %  %!(   (

% !  %% !"  %   "   ! )""%+"

" 

,-

.) % 

, !      !  " % !" ( " % %     !" 

%!  %"!" %/ 

. (  



"  %  !"%%%"%!"  "%!"  !" !% !)(%  "% !"%%%"%!"  ( )"% !"  %"  "% " % '" %"()%""

" " %    " !" " 



 "% ""   %  %%  (% % 

" %"!" % "' 

"(

  % ( %"!" % " % !" (   "   %  % "  ( "  ( "  !!"    "  "!    %!  %" !" ")  %  %  !" (    "% ("!"  0" !"" %"!""' %%" )"  "!" 

%"%+"

"      " " "  !)(%  "%   1  '    (  % % %  %  % % "    (%" % "   %" % % % "!  " %  %"  %% % "%  " 2)"   "% " " %  !)(% " % % )" " %  %"  1  . %% % !)(%  "% !% ( "!"!%   %!  %  )%% "' (%" % "   %" % %  % "!  " %  %"   )" ! 

   %% % %  " %" !%(  " % " " %  !)(% " % % !% )"    " % " " %  !)(% " % % )" " %  %"   1  . %% % !)(%  "% !% ( % !%  %!  % )%%  "  !)(%  "%   1  '    (  % % %  %  % %   "    " %"

"  % % %% + %" 3""'" "  ' " %"'%"%

 %(

"

%"" % )" * %

 %"%  "  !)(%  "%   1 , '  % % %  %  "%"'"! " (%)" %

 ) "

"('*! "!"   !

 %%

  )" % " % !" ( "% %  %!    3()%%'  " % &&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&     % %%  %   !  *" ##  "%  " % !" ( " %  '

.   % %%  %  !"  %  %"!)(%  "% % %"*  " %22&&&& ) "

" (  ( %"'"!" " ")  %  %  !" % " % !)(%  "%  1',#   "%  " % !" ( " %  ' 

.   % %%  %   !  %   %" !)(%  "% % "

" %!" % " % !)(%  "%  1'#     !" &&&& ) "

" 344  " %" % '     % %%  %   ! "%!"   )"'""%!"%%   %" '   !" !" % % 444 " 

.-

 )     % %%  %   !   444 " .. %" ) ( % "' %  . 

"  "  &&&&) "

" %" 

! %%   !" ")" %   )""% +"

"   !" " )"!" 

"  %  %"%!"  ( "%!"   % ' " "! "+ "! " "%" %   !"%% % "%* " "!%44"*  !"%% % "%!)" "!%5"""%"%3'( ) ( %!" "  ! " %"

"   )"/ " %" )%(%  " ' %" ( %" " )" " " %22% %"   

"

  !)(%  " " % "!" 6!  "  % " %)"!  !" %"%  !  %

!  % % * %3!% %  *"%  % 

"(

 ( "% %!   "'  %"!  % 

 %% 71$' ('" "!"!%   !"  % )%%"( %"!%("" %

!" ( "!)(%  "% !"   

" % '" %" ()%% %  % %   !" " %%"   "% "8 %"

% #

.

"  1.  % "'  "' 

.   1.('" % "'

   " %

!" (     

.   !"  %  %"'"!" " ")  %  %  !" % 7!%" %"   !" "

"  %  *  " %22 

 %"  !"  % ("

" !" %

'%%)"% % %%  !" %"%!

." %

!" ( "

% %  % "% .

.  !

" !" " )(%  "  % *  "  %22  %'!%   ! %"%

" "% %7 % % " %%%

 7!%" % % "!  "%  "!"!%  )%%" " % !" (     !)(%  " "

"  !" % 3! "  " * (% % % ' %!     !"  %  ! % !)(%  " %! " "     !"  % "  ( " "' "  !!"  %% %  % "%"'"! "(% )" %

" % " !)( %  "%  1,      

%" /