Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-08-2176\4 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against agreement termination due to lack of valid grounds for revocation.

Case Number 1-08-2176\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal regarding the termination of a settlement agreement. The appellant argued that the agreement was voidable due to the other party's failure to perform obligations, but the court found no evidence of a legal ground for revocation. Consequently, the court upheld the finality of the agreement and rejected the request to terminate it.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Civil Code § 161; Civil Code § 162: A settlement agreement remains binding unless a specific statutory ground for revocation is proven; mere breach of performance does not automatically invalidate the contract.

Keywords

AI generated
settlement agreement termination contract revocation grounds breach of performance civil code provisions appeal dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Civil Code § 161
Civil Code § 162

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

         

   !!"#$%&'(#$% $)   

     *!"* +,-!+ ,!!..,,/   )0 0%1      0  

   000'22304*3 ,,%1 5(66%1 5(("' "%1 5'710%55&)%  2%%080&&          003 .9.!9!! , : 0%& 0)3% %: 0 0010 3)0: %1031: &% 0 %: ;; 0 &:  & 0&0)% 03< / +!66"5%49%1 *.6%1 5. '710 , 3 3: /!"66" =$1  5%4 !+%1( '%1 5(.((*'710"' 3: ) 0 )3&0  ! !!,: 0))0 53 % !!6 !!+( $)3 0&0) % !6 !!+    

)33#=7  !"  000'2230&$04 ,,%1 5'710'03)101-2/', -/3 000'2230&$0466%1 5('"'710'03)101!-2&&/ 3 000'2230&$04"%1 5'710'03)101"-/3  4 , %1  %% 200 0& )3&0 %  #             $% &

  '%&  ( 000'$)30&0)'7)30'0)3&0'%1%& 0))0503&0% !!6 !!+ 

7%'&$0 000'%0103'<  !!!-/)0 : .!!-2%&3/)0 =:

 -9/ . !-%&32&&/)0 # 

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

.-9/ * '&0% 6!+ !!,* !+ !!,( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%()%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %(5)33)(&7101%;;03 %0'003 *'&0% !+ !!,%%.!)0 .!+ !!,%%.!!*)0()103%0%( %3'  %( )%003 &%3&0 ' )%0 $&0 %( # &&''(&7101%;;0300%0' !*)0 * '&0% !+ !!,*.!!+ !!,( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%()%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %(&''(&7101%;;0300%0',9*)0 * !!, 5&0( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%( %3'  %( ) %$&0 %(   &&''( &7101 % ;;03 %0 ' 0 03 * !!,5&0()103%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0 ' )%0 $&0 %( # &&''( &7101 % ;;03 %0 ' 0 03 * '&0% ,!6 !!, %% 9.!* )0 +!6 !!, %% !6!!*)0( )10 3%0%( %3'  %(  %% %$&0 %(  &&''( &7101%;;0300%0'9!*)0 * '&0% ,!6 !!, %% "!!* )0 +!6 !!, %% .!!*)0 )10 3%0%(%3'%()%003&%3&0%(5)3 3)(&7101%;;03 %0'003 * '&0% .!6 !!,*"!6 !!,( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %(&''&7101%;;0300%0' !!*)0 * )10 '&0% +!6 )0 !6 !!,( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( %0%003 &%3&0 ' )%0 $&0 %

@0 &'' &7101 % ;;0303%0'9!!*)0 * '&0% !!6 !!,* 9!6 !!,( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%( %3'  %( )  %)3 %33 %$&0 %(  &''(&7101%;;03 %0'003 *! !!,*+ !!,)00)3%1&57%()103%0%(%3'  %( %0%003 &%3&0 ' )%0 $&0 ' 0&0 )%0 %$&0 % ## 0%( &7101 % ;;03  00 %0 ' ,!!* )0 * '&0% 9!+ !!+* +!+ !!+( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %(3)(&7101%;;03'003 *10%$5 !!+)103%0%%3'%()%0%$&0%( &&''(&7101%;;03 )315$'0*%%0)'6!!* )0 *  '&0% ! !6 !!+ )0 !"!6 !!+( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%( %3'  %( )%0% %003 &%3&0 ' %0 $&0 %  3 %&'' ' % %$&0 % $%)( &7101%;;0300%0)',,*)0 * !!+  5&0 %1 )10 3%0% %3'  %( %0%003 ' )%0$&0%()3*?3%&''00%0) ',!!*)0 * !!+  5&0 %1( '71&0% ;;% 5% %&0 0)10( )10 3%0% %3'  %( %0%003 ' )%0 $&0 %( ) 3?  3%&''00%0)'.!!*)0

-9/ * '&0% !6 !!+*6!6 !!+ )10 3%0% %3'  %( )%0&%3&0%#&3%&'' %0'003 * '&0% !6 !!+*6!6 !!+( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %(&''(&7101%;;0300%0)' *)0 *  '&0% "!6 )0 6!6 !!+( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %=@0&''(&7101%;;0300%0)'.9)0 * '&0% ,!6 !!+ )0 6!6 !!+( )0 0)3% 1& 57%( )10 3%0%(%3'%(%0%003&%3&0')%0$&0 %5)33;;0')%0%$&0%&''(&7101% ;;0300%0)'99*)0 1 0 00' 5)0 3% 0& %3'  % $$ ) 3%0)10&0(4 ,,%1 5'710%0A000 

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

% 2230 0 00' %%(  &( &3 0 %0% 3%0 70%&0 ( %% !!, 5&0 %$5 $0 0 %1( )0 0)3%1& 57%(

= &'503&0 )3 100& & 3 7%031 0)%331 0%3 '0520 %00 , ) ."",( 0& )0&3 '0520  % ' 500 %3 %% )0)1 030 %33 '0520 3%0%&'503&0%3%%)0 !!+10%$5>*%&22 000'5%00%.!. !! 0 %346%1 )$303(&0%% '710 5003 000%701 %0 $0 3 7% 3 4*.  73 %&0%-35030&0%/%%'71)100&01%&)0 $0*%3')0&%(4. %1 )$303(&0%%'71&0%))%%&'%$01 %% &7103 %%0010 % % % &0( %% '71) 03&0 ' 300&&0 )0 % 100&0)0 ' %3 4 . %1  703( &0%%

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

7%'&$0 !!!)0( =.!!)0( #. !)0