Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-08-412\6 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision to deny residence permit due to lack of sufficient social ties in Estonia.

Case Number 4-08-412\6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court rejected the applicant's appeal against the administrative authority's refusal to grant a residence permit. The applicant argued that their family ties and employment history constituted sufficient social connections in Estonia. However, the court found that the evidence presented did not meet the statutory threshold for establishing these ties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2004; s. 10 AsylG 2004: The court held that an administrative decision denying a residence permit is valid if the applicant fails to prove sufficient social ties in the host country, as such ties are a prerequisite for the permit under the relevant immigration legislation.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit social ties administrative appeal immigration law burden of proof Estonia AsylG 2004

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 AsylG 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









          

 

  









 

 





 !!"

#

 



  

$!"$ 

 

%&&

'%

 

 

(&&)*+!+,-.+(/00000000

000000 000 000$0( 

 

     

!"#!$#%!!&#

# 

 ' 



%&(!)!*)!!+,&$

&1/&'%/



-./-



0 11 '    

1 231 $%!

$)")$"%%



4

5 

 

      $"#$%#%!!*#

#  ' 



  %&(!)!*)!!+,&$



  #

-551  

1  

 

1 2*+$

$





    







'

$!65  7

' 5  

##(!!6

7 #









'   

1

      $, 6'  5  7  '

  #%

2/&&34& / ! !!*.! "!"   & 5&3%6 7) !8 /& %

'9&)&&%'! !!".-,+".



1

 



 1



3/#&&)&%&

&&6&/

#'1)

/':'%391//9'&(&&%&#&6'&

&    

# '1/  &1/&/ , 39 1/ 

9'&

&%& &'& #&6 % '%// && ))& &1/( 9/&/ '%/1/

#&'))&&%)1/





-0.08/.-9

7*8



#%2/&&34&&%%1&%/&!*! !!"6991

% "-!(!,(!!."&& %)&%%((')3&&)1&'&#&61&   !!,

// !;.! 1/

# '%% #'3/ // #'3/ /& 26& 9%/

'#&)&( &) ' #/ 3) 1&'& ''%)&/ 9'/  

1&'&<&6/3%'('&//6&&&/&1= /6* (&&/)= */6 

%#)&)(3%%&'&&/)=,/6196&/&4&&99(*!&:&

"!!%&&6



9/& '%/1  3/ &  %) &%%    %9/ 

&%%&'3%))6>'??///3&/#'#'&16#&''&%'&(

&) % % #3&/% 1 1/&   '99) & '& 3)( 3/ &''

9%))1'99/('%'&



9/&% '%/1( ///   3/  )&   /&)6( % %#

/%)'&6&1/&'%/(/&)(6'&/%9/&%'%/1

%)'%//&&&%)&(6%#3&/6(///3)&&&/



 /&(  %) &%%  3/ &&/)  = ,   /6  196& /&4&& 99

&'3%'&%9/&'%/1'96&)1/1%#%))'%//

&& &%%'9/&:/6993//&799&'&/83/%6&///(1&

#&)&3&&)1&'&#&661&/)6(#&26&9%/(%96&3/&&('&

993//& &/) 6 // (  %) &%% ' 3&&) 1&'&#&66

1&/00000000



= /6* /3&&)1&'&#&6//'#&&&#&61&)'#&)&

=$ *%&')1)/1= */6$ 9(3&&)1&'&#&6#& 

6&  1&'& %) -$, / &&/ &%6&'/(  '#&)& % '

#/ /3%' 7)/& 18 #& /3%' 7 )/& 18 3/ //

/&)&&



6  & /%) ,!+ ++ :%)&%) (  99 &'3%'& 1/  -$% ( 3&&)

1&'&#&6 '  %) &%% 3/  '#&)& 1&'&% /(  ' #/

3/%)= */6$ %&')&&(#&639%



 = .- /6  / &'& / % && :: & '#&'&/  3/ #&

'99'&/ 9/& '%/1 3/  6%)&) 1 %)&) 1/&)(

#&'/'#1)::)/)3&)&&)'::6)&'3%'&1#&6&'&

&&)

&&/)=,/6196&/&4&&99%&%%9)

%&!!&:&#& %)&%%%&)*!&:&&6

() %)&%%('3/&'3%))99&/&)(1/(

6'&%000000000000000000000000000000000#33&//&6(&/'/

#&6&'&&&'3%%)799&'&//*81&'&&&/(/&(

 &%%  % #&'/& '#1)   )3&)&  #&6// 9&'  '/  9/&

'%/13/'99)&6%))



*7*8

 %)&%%)/(/99&'3%'&1/'11

&'&1//&1%&%6//'99('%''/'99)&

( /6& (   991 &)  /%)'&/ /9 

 = ",

9( '&// / 991  &%/ '%// &&  1

993//& 9) /   =   / && % ::#&'/&%( &  % 

&'3%'&1/::)&19'/%/1&% %)&%%/&99&'3%'&

1/-%1&#&6&'3%'&)&'%//&&(

'&:'%'/6&(2%%)=.!/6'#/%

#&61/)'#/'/%'/







&

'%

%&