Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-11254\14 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against deportation order, ruling it was not arbitrary despite procedural delays.

Case Number 1-07-11254\14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the deportation order, finding the decision was not arbitrary despite significant procedural delays. The appellant argued that the authorities failed to act within reasonable time limits and ignored his humanitarian circumstances. The court held that the substantive reasons for deportation remained valid and that the delay did not render the decision unlawful.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Section 10 of the Aliens Act; Section 11 of the Aliens Act: A deportation decision is not arbitrary merely because of procedural delays if the substantive grounds for removal are still valid and the delay does not fundamentally undermine the decision's legality.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation appeal arbitrary decision procedural delay Aliens Act humanitarian grounds reasonable time substantive review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Section 10 of the Aliens Act
Section 11 of the Aliens Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

    

         !"    

   ##$%&!'  

     ())**+   ,' ,' -   "-!! . /01 0'        2/     ,3.  

   .,",0.4 0"332"0"," 5678.3!/,,0.",  "      !0*##!00""          .,",0.4 07 0,/  0"7 ,. 9,.. 0"2  :,""; 0'     .,", 0.4 0   "2 )6*)6-  2 - ,"! 2", -0<<!0=%&!'-,.!0>>>>>> ???- ' -' ,/!0..0 "0 02 .-0&,2@ ' ! ..92 /, . 0,"##    ,.         ! "

#$%&&%'##(  )*+      ,&-. %  %/      +%0          

 %                         (               

  %                              !       1#     2            

%  

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

9 22/20,2-/"'&"2 " 0 /0,,! ' "0"0,0,0 /",# 9",, .",.0   0 .0 #.0 " 22 30."0, &", 7  90",""&", 0../", ,,"/8. 9, A  0"7  ' 7 ."  !0 "0. 82 0  ## #6# 3.,. /", '2," .',"0"0- /"  02 3.,. /", 90.. ." "# "0 7 2 , .2 .,", 0.4 0., "33" 9 2 ' 0, 0,2, 9, .087 0," 7  0, ' 2 7!0"0 .0 0,"0, "0, "& 2,"0#.,",0.4 09!0"32 /.23.,"0"0",2- 020,/ 9.0./  2' 2 7,".,0 -," .. 0,/ "330&,2"- 3"0,/ 3.,. /,, !0."0 0 '   ,  "332"0 0 '   , .,22 0"0 ,2,., 9!0"32 /.,., 30."0,.,# / . "7  / 0,7 .2, 0' "0 02 "7 .2,'8."0 -,0.,",0.4 0-..," "," .!.7A,"7  ,0,,2," ! .' "0 . "- !,0" /  /  ## 72, '2"",- 2 /00, /  ".",, !.2 /",,,"/8.- ."0 "",,2 . !0,0 /"0-/ .0"! .' "0 2,,2,"# 9",, .,##,!/"7 0""/ ,/  99# 0"7 9 .A !0"0.82 0 ###6#3.,. /",'2," .',"0"0- /" 023.,. /",90..." "03!"0 2  !0*##0""

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

9 22 9 .7 .0- ./   0",9 A,0 - 3/A"",-  ",,78,.  70 02 3/A 9, ., 0,' .0 70"' !,20 ' 70 2," 2/,2 2",0 "" !0 # C/A., 70 0  2" .8A3/A,2 "2",0.,-/0,"",..,0 ","0"&.A/ 0"#  ###6#7 $##3.,. /",90..2, .",.,,' 20,/ 30.",2' 2 "7 ."- ,0 $## /,0 " 0  /  / /,. ,2 . ",.7 " .2 ,0",",/,0," 93"2-",.., ..9 ",20""27 /  -  #6#30.,A-,0,"","/,"0,.30."0,. ",..,"-,00 .,.27 . "/00,9, ./",293"27 ",.., ..9 ",20""27 /  -' 2 <<"8 7  ",.., .. 9 ",2 ."93"2 7  /  # B&!,0",",/,- /..," 0.,A 92 2  9 ",2 ."93",- /  / /,. 7 . ".,/", !0  , .,   0  22 ' "08' 230."# ,/ 30."-,0,0","-/..,"  0 .8"/  / -.2<<"8-7  ",.., .. ."9,"-0 A ,/ # " .,2 ' "0."   0 30."",..,!0 -,0,"/,",.3.,. /",.'80"0  #0.4 0 9.0 /  "  0,/  / "", 099/"0- /2  0,,..0 , ., 0' "0 02#

/  ",20&00,.2  0 .'&/ ."8! -/.., .0,,/"0-0,/ 02"' 2 ' .",2 -/.., ",2 0,0 0-0 ,82#  ,, ",..",2' "0."2  0 30."0,"-/"0"20,/ 30."0,",..",,A &",- /"'8."0 "2#0.4 0"33-,,",# 

    0"7  '80,2 ",.., !0 - ,0 9!0"32 /. 3.,"0"0", 2" #0.4 0 9.0",0<<0 7 0, 9"3!!..",. /&70",.-  9 .7 "& .",2  , #0.4 0 ,  0,/   0"7  , " 2 !0"0./,0 2 -,"9.0",0<<0 7 0,"0/.., "332"0 0 ' 0/&70 "#   !0 0""  9" ' .0 /0',,02   !" , 9,  ' 7 ." .,' 0  0 &#0.4 0"3320 ' 20&,2,2#   !"780 A/ !00"",/0/ 0  9,.. 0"2 !.2 / 0 #  !"7!2A 52,"0)).9D)).D)D)#         ,' ,'    "  !! . /01 0'