Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-15873\4 AI generated

Court dismissed psychiatric compulsory treatment appeal, ruling the patient lacked capacity to consent to the measure.

Case Number 1-07-15873\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against the application for compulsory psychiatric treatment, finding the patient lacked the mental capacity to consent. The applicant argued the measure was necessary for public safety, while the defense contended the patient could understand the proceedings. The court ruled that without the requisite capacity to consent, the legal basis for the compulsory measure was invalid.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Section 10 of the Mental Health Act 2003; Section 11 of the Mental Health Act 2003: A compulsory treatment measure cannot be lawfully applied if the patient lacks the mental capacity to consent to it.

Keywords

AI generated
compulsory psychiatric treatment mental capacity to consent Mental Health Act 2003 legal capacity assessment court appeal dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Section 10 of the Mental Health Act 2003
Section 11 of the Mental Health Act 2003

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

                         ! "#! !$% "%&"$''!&'           !"( "')"&&       *+''$,," -)%#"         +''$     ./'/0!."! 1&0   +'"#)!")2" (" "/&'$'     30"4&/5$"/!      "$"&$''!&'&6)'!$"'%),"!"&"'/0" &/$"'  !" 7"//' - )*-8*-)* - * -99&#)*-&#*-9*- *-   #

$%&&'%'%       ((   $%%) '%'   

    (    ' +''$!'!6'/"!&/!/'"&' ""#"6"#("!$$  "0!$''!&&/''%%!!3'!".(""#"/   *     !$'&'06"('"!/!&'$'(',$')'0%&*&!' )'0!*$"&"""0"/&!!0!!$'!!'/06")"/"!'/$  +           +' '$ !'  &!!/ "$"&$''!&  -  ) %#" +' "#)!"/0"&/$"'"$"&%!'!$"'$''&! &6"+''$ '&& %&#0""'&&7*)6%!/'0""$'&'0"" &6"'!'0 0& )& "/''&  "/'''&$' 0"#!'#* 0 6&&""#''

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

&//),"!"&"!/0"  !%!"!%!'%=",!&!'!%'&/(*'!!!,/ '&&   %& # +' '$  :'/' ,!&!'#  &#"&"' ''  ,/$ 0!&)!&&"!%"!6'/"0!&)!&&"!%'&/0!'0' !&'"$'!!/,/'# !'"!!/ '0"#!'/  ;"''"!/ = ' "#& !'!"'# ! !' % "" !!&" ')'!""" !"# ! !' .""$' '&! !0!!" !& &6"' !'0/    0& )& "/''&  "'&$' 0"#!'#* 0 6&&""#'' '')"&%06&0',&'$"')""%0(&)""*$"&&'!#%%'&!'" &!&" 0)&' 0'"6"/ :"$'!!/ 0"#!'/  0&";"!''"!0/ '&!&"' 0"#!!'* $"&&'! !&''0&! !&'( &#'/* '! +' '$ !'"! '/ !'#'0'# 7  ' !'0"'%!'

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

 9

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



  6/$''&'06""!&!'"/$'),,""'*$!""!&''&"$"'06" ! % !$"' %& !0!!/ "$'!!/ '"/"/* $" '" 06"$&/ "/& !' !'$ 0"$'!'"/"!6"#0!'!'!"$')'$"'%&"#!$!'%0"$''"/"!6!! !&"'/&'%,"&'"#0%(0"*$(!&&'),"!"&"'/0"  +' '$ !' ),"!"&"' /0" &/$"'  "/!!/ !!"' !),"!"&"'')'!"""!"

 9

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