Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-6163\3 AI generated

Court dismissed complaint against administrative body for failing to issue a residence permit within the statutory deadline.

Case Number 4-07-6163\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the individual's complaint regarding the administrative body's failure to issue a residence permit. The applicant argued that the authorities exceeded the legal time limit for processing the application, while the administration contended that the delay was due to the complexity of the case and the need for additional verification. The court ruled that the statutory deadline for decision-making had been strictly observed, thereby rejecting the claim of procedural violation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Residence Act 2004; The administrative body is not liable for damages if it acts within the statutory time limits, even if the decision is ultimately unfavorable to the applicant.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit administrative deadline procedural violation residence act complaint dismissal statutory time limit administrative liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Residence Act 2004
s. 11 of the Residence Act 2004
s. 12 of the Residence Act 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









   

 









 







 

 !"#



  







 

$% &%





' '  (%%) + ") +

,





 

 

''#"&%-""!.%/#

%#%"&%#%-



 



 $!.&%-"''&%%0%!""/&0-#)

• !"# "%%.1% 22334   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 2334   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 44334   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6! "%%.1% 44334   0 !% #%  2

-%5%-!%+

• 6! "%%.1% 334   0 !% #%  3

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0 "%%.1%3340!%#%5

-%+-%/4-%5%-!%+

• $&&-6% "%%.1%23340!%#%

4-%5%-!%+

• 6! "%%.1% 334   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0  2333   0 - 24 !% #%  2

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0  2333   0 - 23 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+





(3,

• 6"03330!%#%-%5

%-!%+

• 6"03330!%#%-%5

%-!%+

•  "%%.1% 333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0 "%%.1% 22333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0 "%%.1% 22333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6"0 "%%.1% 333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 43333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 2333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1%33330!%#%

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1%3330!%#%

-%5%-!%+

•  "0!%#%-%5

%-!%+

• ""%-- "%%.1%20!%#%

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1%40-3!%#%

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 4   0 - 33!% #% 

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1%    0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• !"# "%%.1% 4   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• "%%%    0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

•  "%%.1%  0!% #%  

-%5%-!%+

• 6! "%%.1% 2   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

•  "%%.1%    0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%



 7&"&%#''#"#%#%

 &&&%%"+#!"0-%"/%-!/"









 





(3,



&&."#!%%&&  !"#/".&#

/""""%



!





'#" / """ "% -%%/ (" + , " - &% '   ."

"""/&0-#&%-"'')



 !"# "%%.1%223340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%23340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%443340!%#%-%5

%-!%+

 6! "%%.1%443340!%#%2-%

5%-!%+

2 6! "%%.1%3340!%#%3-%5

%-!%+

 6"0 "%%.1%3340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 $&&-6% "%%.1%23340!%#%4

-%5%-!%+

4 6! "%%.1%3340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

3 6"0  2333   0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

6"0  333   0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

6"0  333   0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

  "%%.1%3330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0 "%%.1%223330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0 "%%.1%223330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

26"0 "%%.1%3330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0  24333   0 !% #%  2 -% 5

%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%433330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

4 !"# "%%.1%23330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

3 !"# "%%.1% 3333   0  !% #%  





(3,

-%5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%3330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

  "    0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%20!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40!%#%-%

5%-!%+

2 !"# "%%.1%0!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%0!%#%-%

5%-!%+

4  "%%.1%0!%#%-%

5%-!%+

36! "%%.1%20!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6%"/-% "%%.1%    0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%



''"8""&0%&%-""!.%&%%0%!+-

 &%% - 99- %% ( , : 4 "0  .  &

&0 -%-0  % " 80% &%% % " #"/  % #

(.-0#/%--%/,%"#%



    

"







&% '   "%+  "&0%  &%%- % " 0-+ - 

-&%%-"&&//"+--99%

#&"%-"//!%

&%%0%-"!.%0"%

&%#%%%"%0/&%%%-00%0 """-''

 &%% 0%- .-  : 4 "0  .  ""+  #%%" "% "

%"+%"""-##%"



$!- "%%.1 "%+  % #" " /& "+ 

  %%-"  (% - 4++, % &%%"

-&%%-%-0333(%-$$3,"%

&%-"3333(",



$!- "%%.1% 6! ."%%/- "%+  % #" " /&

"(",







2(3,

$!- "%%.1%6"0."%%/-%"-!&%-""!.%0

(",



$!- "%%.1% !"# ."%%/- "%+  % #" " /&

"+ -  - !%00"  &%%" / &%% ." &%%"

.99+%!.''" :&%(",



; "%%.1"%+%#""/&"+&%-"

- "  & &/ /" -%-0 .# &%-" /&%

#&"%#/"(",



$!- "%%.1% 6%"/-% ."%%/- "%+  % #" " /&

"+-3&%%"&%%("

,



.%%-%"+ :4"0.&&/

/" " 8- " -&%% -%-0 % &% - #!"0-% 

"-%-#%0"%-!%+%"""#%%-%"0%-+%%

-#!"0-%%-!#""%%





 #"







6&&-" % (6 , :  "0  &+  &"# .8%

0"% 8% -%-0  #&"% -"/ "-% #!% "-%

&%%"%"-#"/"0"-"-%%-#!%#&"%-

-"/ #!% "-% #!% "-% &%%" .99- #&"%- -"/ #!%

 -%  &&0 -""%%   %/"%

-"

&%-"%( ,:"0&+#%&%%0%!

&%-" "!.% " - &%% #!% #!"0-% #" "-%"

&%%-%&&



&%% # / #" "%  -&+  &% - "-

&%-"''/&0%/)

 !"# "%%.1%223340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%23340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%443340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 6! "%%.1%443340!%#%2-%

5%-!%+

2 6! "%%.1%3340!%#%3-%5

%-!%+

 6"0 "%%.1% 334   0 !% #%5

-%+-%/4-%5%-!%+





(3,

 $&&-6% "%%.1%23340!%#%4

-%5%-!%+

4 6! "%%.1%3340!%#%-%

5%-!%+

3 6"023330-24!%#%2-%

5%-!%+

6"023330-23!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0  333   0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

6"0  333   0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

  "%%.1%3330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0 "%%.1%223330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

26"0 "%%.1%223330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

6"0 "%%.1%3330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%433330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

4 !"# "%%.1%23330!%#%-%

5%-!%+

3 !"# "%%.1% 3333   0  !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1% 333   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

  "    0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

 ""%-- "%%.1% 2   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40-3!%#%

-%5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40-33!%#%

-%5%-!%+

2 !"# "%%.1%0!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 !"# "%%.1%40!%#%-%

5%-!%+

 "%%%    0 !% #%   -% 5

%-!%+

4  "%%.1%    0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+

36! "%%.1% 2   0 !% #%  

-%5%-!%+





(3,

  "%%.1%0!%#%-%

5%-!%



&%%

%--%

"

-



&%%"

.99

+



"!%0%% % :  /  : 4 "0  .  & &/

/"

0-&%-""0%-&%%%-"%"



3/!%6 / 

6 :"02&+"-%%.99&%%"0&%+%-99-

 :4 "0  .  & &0 / #&"% -"/  #!% 

&%%".99%%"%"8

&%-" % (.%% ,: "0" "!. &%-"

#&& /  #&"% -"/  #!%  "" &&

#% %-! &%% 0% !+ % #% % " % -!

%%:4&&//"

:4"0.(-%2%-%-,&+%

&%+%#&&/!%-99-8 %# :4"0.

"%&%+%#&&/!%-99-

%



 "% "&0%  &% !"0-+   .& 3  -

-/%--%%&%%".99%%""&%%+%-88-"0"

&"+"-%%&%+%-99- :4"0.&

&0+#&"/#%#&"%%-# :4"!%&%%0%

.%%-0%#/"



'#/"+"&0%/!%-99- :4"0.

& &0 -%-0 .#   : 4  "!% &  &%%

0%.%%-0%#/"+%%"%+##"6 :"!%"2

--&%%-0-

6  : 3 "0  " - #% "-% %- -"/" !%0  &&0

#% &%%" .99%- % "8 " "#" % " 80% 0

#&"/!% #% &%%" .99% % "8 0 #% &%%

&0 .%-+ %! %  ! 8% !-  &%% 0%

.% :4"0.!



%"#&%%0%.% :4"0.!+

%0%&%-"-#!"0-%""-%"#%%

 # % " #!%"%  &%% 0% .%- #!"0-% %

% !#"%%0 %%+ % #!"0-% %"  %%# &%%0  %-

%0% ""+  % !#" "" " % % #%

%!#"%%-%%-8-#%%%+#%""

"""!%88"%%#0#+%#!%&%%"&%-"

%&%&%#&"%-"/

&"#" /" % " #+  #!"0-% " %""00% %- #%





4(3,

%-!%0!#"%-#%%

&%-" &0%+ % % %- %-" &%-" "% / &%

%#!"0-%"+-0%#%&%%-!%%&%

-+ ""0  /" #&"/"0%%-+ % .!/" % " #!"0-%

#%-



 : 4  "0  .  &  &%% 0% &0 -% &%+ 

#&&0 !% % (  #%, %% / 1%%#- &%#%%%-

#"88""!/.%%%%880%.-%-%-0%

0!%0#



 &  :  "0 +  %  #!% #&"%- -"/ % " &&-

#% % %%+  # #%- &% -- #!"0-%"

#%#%-%&/+%%""8%.&#0.%%

.&#

:"0"+%#%#%-&&&.&#%#!%%

 #% % &0 % /&0% / #% &%% &0 % "

.%- -%-0 #!"0-%" % " #+ %""" %-! .99+  &%

%-!/""#"#%-%%0##"%%

:  &"  &%%" .99- " #!% %  - %-

#&"%--"/+%%&%%/&0""0-.!%!

-&6 :"!%

7"%&%%-""%#!"0-%".%%#"#+%%".%-.99

%-!#" %#!"0-%"%"-#+%%"%&%%"#/%"

#"#%-%%0



 - %%0%    (/ - 2, "%-+  %

&%%0"%--%&%+&%%-%%!%"%".%/

.&/%%"%"+&%%#"%#!%%-/%

 & &/ /" "  #!% #&"% -"/ 

&%%



 "%+  % % %-  : 4 "0  . + +  /  & #&&

&%%0%.%%-0%-/"%+%%"#&&&% :4"0

.&0%&//"



7"+%!"0-6 :"02/ :4"0.&"#%%%"

-0  - %- &% / %-!/ (  : 4 & 0%&/

/""8-"-&%%,+ %% %00 ! : /

6  :  & -% "% %-%%- -%-0 #&&

("!%0%%,  #% &%%0%  #&&

%  !% "0 #-0% &%%0+   #% &%% 

 %"%" 0  " - "%- !"0- "#"- /

#"<%6%%0%.!%:/"0&0



-&%%-99- :4"0.&&0-%-0.#





3(3,

:4"0.++/&/"+!""&%"

&%%"&%-""!.&%%0%!



 : 3 "0  " # &% &%-" "!.% " #

#%%#%%"/%0%%.%/"#""&% :

2"0&"0+&%"!.&%-"0

-"-#-&+&%-""!.%-/&%-"0#%

" #%- - &%% .&#+ %% /&  ' '  " # %

#%"&%#







$% &%

-%