Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-10423\10 AI generated

Court dismissed execution appeal against a suspended sentence, ruling the fine was not yet due for payment.

Case Number 1-07-10423\10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the execution appeal filed by the defendant against the enforcement of a suspended sentence. The defendant argued that the fine component of the suspended sentence had not yet become payable and should not be enforced immediately. The court rejected this claim, holding that the obligation to pay the fine arises upon the expiration of the probation period, not at the time of the appeal.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A fine imposed as part of a suspended sentence becomes payable only after the expiration of the probation period; enforcement proceedings based on the fine before this time are inadmissible.

Keywords

AI generated
suspended sentence probation period fine payment execution appeal enforcement inadmissibility

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







   

 

 







 ! "#

 







 

$% &'()'%!*+,"&

 









 



""!- (./!. &*'&!'&!*-!0( 1!-!

 







$% &'()'%!*2!-(''.-#

   



 !! ". !&''  ".(!2! 3% . ) %!

 ".(44#!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#' ".!

 





 

770(,#.'. 8(!!-" -0#!-'9  -0'(! 0#

8#7!' 3% . )' 3$%!9  # 0 $3:3*

'#.

!)!

 0!*

'#"!0#*

'- ".

;;;;;;;; <<* ;;;;;;;* .66.!# (..'!('.--.

 #!-'".#'-*4'# -'&!-!2!-&))50!(# "!#*

(!!- !#!#.!.0

 !"#

$%&   

 

'(%  '))*% 

 



 



 !

  



 

 

 %

0!#!')!(#' 0





 

 +,  











%



+



=2! 

  



$%!! ".!&'' ".(!2!3% . )%!(44#'!566!..4.(#'-' -0'(!

0#'-'44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'! !#.##'!0#.8'0!#50 !9

>33-50'*2!*?24(,#.'.04!!0(!.!!#.#87#9!!#.!87(('9

08!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#.8-%9%



'%44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'!.#.!. -0'(!0##770 !

>33-50'*2!*?24!#.#'#(,#.'.8 -(9!!#.!.387"'#!90

&!#.#.% !>$?-!-#'-- '.!#.#!2!"-!''-&!#.#'#&).0!'*?%(!#.

%2*#% :8!#7(('0&#954'&!&!#.#.@% . )#.

%#'5.'():%!*#% 87(('90:8!#7(('0&#954'&!&!#.#.* 

87#.'#.908!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#.% !#.#.24!0!8!#9!!#.!.3

87"'#!9087(('954'&!&!#.#.8-%3?9%

'%$% !>$:-!-#'-#'0!.('.!.0!#.#.44'!! ".:%#'5.'()

:%! ". .##'!8-%$?9(,#.'.0!#.#'87#9!!#.!8!#90&!#.#.&,!

-.!#.#'#(,#.'.8 -(9!!#.!.87#.'#.9087(('954'&!&!#.#.%

!#.#'!0(#'!2!!-#'#- '.:%#'5.'()':%!%

'%'% !2!! ".8-%9(44#'!%#'5.'()#.%!&!)!#.!. -0'(!0# !>

$ !-#'- &!#.#'#. .(# ''.4".!'#'-.% !.#'!2! 5#'# (44!. 4!!0(!.!

!#.#!2!-!.#.''-&!)!#.!(#'#'#!*0(..'&4"'(87#9!!#.!8!#.#'





 



8:9



!2!-,55:%!#.3%!9% !.#'!2!'#.'-  -0'(!0# "#.!.024(! !>:

-#4.'#.!.024(# . --,0'0A

'%'%$%'-!(! ".(44!.0!-!-#'#'- "!#;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<@

'%'%'%-((!(!!-" -0!2!5 -.(44!.0!2!&!"'('24'-(!!-" -0# #! 0!

'#.''(#'-'@

'%'%-%!--(! (!!-" -0!2!  . ---' (! '- "!#  '#.!(! .!--' !0('0 (!

 "#.#.'.4.(#'2!'-!.#&!"'0.' ".!@

'%'%.%#!!(! (!!-" -0#!('.-. ''-'&! - ! '- "!#. -!"(#'# !'(!# 

&'.'#.7('#54'&!#@

'%'%/%#!!(!

(!!-" -0#!('.-.

''-'&!

- !

'-*

.66

&,

,55(# "!

&!"'.!(#'#%

'%-% !>:-!-#'-(44!. -0'(!0#'-'!--24'&!0 "#.#'0A

'%-%$%!#0!.66-'8!"'940!-!2 #-5'!-'&!)!'(#.@

'%-%'%(..'.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('%

'%.% -0'(! 0# (44!. !.#'!2!#  !! ". (!!-" -0# #! ! 2"!.!2!

5 -. (44!.!&! (!!-" -0#!('. 24'-'&!-&' !--!% 770(,#.'.  -0'(! 0#

&!)!#.!. !--! !-!#. :%#'5.'()- %!!#.!- .'(! !#.#' 4!!0(!.! #!

#'#! :%#'5.'() %!   87#9 !!#.!  87(('9 0  8!#7(('09 54'&!

8-%39



-%% . )- %!!#.!-  #!!)# (!! ".-'  !! ". (!!-" -## #! !

!&''.!-.#'(!!-" -0#!('. #.!B"6)''! !-''..'!'8-%9

(!!-" -0#!-#'-'  -0'(! 0#'-' (,#.'.0 2! 4!!0(!.! !#.#' .4.(#'-'

566!(#'#*#'#.(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0##.!--' ".(44#'! !>

:-!-#'-(44!.0 . --,0'08''-!0-!#(44!.0 "!#*''#.!0 ('.'

 "#.#.'.4.(#' ".!92! !>:-!-#'-5!00 "#.#8'!-- "#.#'-'(..'

.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('*' .#(44!.0!2!#.66 ".!9%

-%$%#.!.0 '! !-#'#. '..'!0'#. 4".)* '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# '

'-!0 ".5 -.(44!.0'- "!#;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<*&!0'-!#;;;;;

;;;;;;;; <<<<% !!.!(!.! ?%#'5.'()- %!!#.!- '#(! ".(#'- -)!.-' '

!#0 (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# 7()'  ". 5 -. (44!.0 '- ".!

;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<%

% . )- %!!#.!- #!!)# (!!-" -0#.!-.##'  -0'(! 0#' '0#'-.

!)!!#!-. C * '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# '-!) ! ;;;;;;;*

;;;;;;;;<<<<*''-00'##'!-.-!"(!#.%

-%'% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# ' !--0  ". 5 -. (44!.0  "#.#'-'

(..'.!&.!0!!.#'!2!-!- " -%

(!!-" -0#!-#'- -0'(!0#'-.&!#.!.0!D -.#'5'C'.5 -.% . )-

%!!#.!-!- " -2 &'*(--' ".! $% . )-%!!#.!-(!!-" -0#.!-.#'#

'#.''.05 .  --%

-%-% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# ' -' !#0 .66-'* (0! .!  ".(44#'

 "!#'-.  8!"'9 40!-! 2 #- 5'!-' &!)!'(#. .''(! 50% #.!.0 '! !-#'#.

'..'!0'#. 4".)* '. .'#'-'  ".(#'-' :% . )- %!!#.!- (!!-" -0#!-'

 -0'(!0#'-(0*! -&!"#.!.0!".-#.!.!'.' . ('5!'(#'#%



.% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# #'-.!#  ".#.-* '. .! '-!) ;;;;;;;*

;;;;;;;; <<  7#'# :%#'5.'()- %! 2! $%#'5.'()- %!!#.!-  

% . )- %!!#.!- - .! ;;;;;% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# &4.#* '. .!

.66.!#

(..'!('.--.

 #!-

'".#'-

'..'&,.2!

E

0!0

+! )# 

2'#%

(!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# !&!-0!#* '. ! .!- ' -' 7".' #. .,'0!&!.





 



8:9



0 ('.* ## ' #!!0 .! '!#. !('.--. .66-' & (#.!0!% (!!-" -0#!-'

 -0'(!0#.#.!#*'.% . )-%!!#.!-*.!--'5 -.#'24'-'.-* -.!''-'&!-.

4!2 08*-90F%

.%$%D 6-'0#*'.(!!-" -0!2!'! !-''..'!' 5,"2'0!.0 -0'(!

0#'-' ". .##'24(,#.'.0!#.#'4!!0(!.! #!87#9!!#.!87(('90

8!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#..-')566!.!.4.(#'-'%

.%'% !.#2!5!-#24..!(!!-" -0#!('.'..'5!'!"-0!(!.!8-%39%



/%!! "#-'0#*'.'#.!.0.! .-#.(#(,#.'.0!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'# 

5,"2'0!.02!-)!"-0!(#'-'%

/%$%!! "#(4#(44#'5,"2'0!&!# #!#8-%9*'. -0'(!0#&!)!#.!.&!-!#.

.(# '' .4".!'! !-. #'--'- .(#'-* '. .! .40!)  . --,0'0 2! .!--' 5!00

 "#.#% !! ". !&!.'# ' -' .,'0!.0 #''* '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0#

-'# (!'- "!#.;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<-!"0;;;;;-''-!(!!'(!#

&'.'#.7('#54'&!#*#'#.#' .!6'-0#'0!*'.4#;;;;;-7#'# -('-54'&!-2!

#'0! -!#.' 54!#.  (!!-" -0#!('.-' -!'# C   -0'(! 0#' '0#'-.

!)!!#!-.% . )- %!!#.!-* '. -0'(!0#'-!) ! ;;;;;;;* ;;;;;;;;

<<<<*''-00'##'!-.-!"(!#.%

/%'% (!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0# 6'-0*'.!('.--.'#!!0.!'!#..66-'

& (#.!0!'! (!.66-'!#(#.(!!-" -0#!('.-'0 ('.!!-#'-..,'0!0!*#'#.

.!-' -07".'#..,'0!&!.0 ('.%''&40'' -'(..'(--'!7()'-7!.0%

(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0# &!"!--!".-#.!.!'.' . ('5!'(#'#*

(#.,.. ".(#'-':% . )-%!'#!!0.!'#.!0!(!!-" -0#!('.5 -.

,.0 0 ('.' (! .66-' !#(#'  ".! '! ! .'!&.!0! (!!-" -0#!('.

#-#'-. (!C!.-#'#..66-'!#(#'#.%

/%-% (!!-" -0#!-#'  -0'(! 0#' '0! 7.-#'!* 0! D -.#'5'C'. !&''

5 -.#' #! !5 .  --!!- " -2 )'.&!#.!(#' ".!0!!. &!"'0&,(,,.'#.!

!#.!(#'-% . )-%!*4".)*'. -0'(!0#'-.&!#.!.!- " -2 &'8*?$(G-9

 2 )'#'#0# # !''(#'-' . ('.!(#' 5 .  --! % . )#. %! 

.4'--..,'0!(#.-'00#''*'.(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0##% . )-

%!.'(!-' !2!! ".%#'5.'()%!(44#'! !>:-!-#'-(44!.0

 "#.#.(..'.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('%!! ".!&!.'#' (!(..4".##.#''*

'..''(#. 7"' 0#'(#'!%



 









0%

!! ".

!&''

 ".(!2!

3% . )

%!

(44#'

5'!-'

'#.!#

(!!-" -0#!-#' -0'(!0#'!.#2!&!0'!0& !!..!#(!!(44#!')#'*

(--'#5!-)(!! ".(44#.7"#.!0!8$?9%

0%$%44#!')#' "!#'-.',#.!.#2!(!! ".#'# ".!0'!2!-'!)*'.(!! "#

!####-#'-.#'# "!-'*'. !>$-: !)# -.'#!.# !&4#'(

 . --,'.' (' 8. !#&,  54'&! &,! '#.''(#'- "-'(' &, .66-'

!#(#' "#.#'.4.('54'&!#'"-'(#'!9. )''#'!!!#!&4-.(!.-.&!2!0#'

4!!0(!.!!#.#.4.(#'-'566!.!%'--'#..-''&!-.'50!0 "#7-0#'&!2!-#

!!-0!(#'#'- (8!- " -2 &' -&4'92!7"' 0##.%

0%'%44#!')#'5,"2'0!&!# #!#(4#!.#2!*'.#'!0#*(#'".'#.!)#!.# 0*

(0!.4.'&&,(5'!),#'2!#".'#!'0!(!*5'!)&,(!-0!(!.4.'&&,(-&,..!

!&'##' ,#'(#' !#2! -#0A &!#.!#'- 2"-  #'!0# ')!5 5 .# !!-'%

4.'&&,(- 5'!) -'(! &,(!-# !&'#.!0! (.('##'0 !#2! -#0* '. &,(

.' #.!('#&!)!0##C44#'(#'! -'#5,"2'0!.02! #,-!#,#'(#'





 



8:9



!#2! -0'!% ' #'# #'--'! &.!) !.#2!  ". -!"'0-'  $ ?%!5--#.

%!%

0%-% !.#2!-'0#*'.(,#.!5'!)#'!0#!0(!&,(!-#'#!.# ''".'#.!0'#8 !>

$-:#4.'#.!.0,' ".-'566!.!!#.#&4-.(!.-..4.(#'-'9! ".&,(-'&,..!

!&'##'(#'#'- (%

".7-'#!''. "'#.!)!D,"#'!0#'8'0!#50D9>$.-''&!-. --!5'-!-.

#''*'..!7#'# #.!.'').&!#.!.0C!.-#.!#2! -2!'0)*'.' (!(..4".##.

!#('.!.0(' -7"' 0'&,(..'*!#'!0#'!-#'- !#.#'.4.(#'-'

566!('&4-.(!.!2)!!7##'--'.,..*'.(' !#'.-'00% ! -' ".

( .&!.#  !.#2!"!-.4'#.-)!(!.%#-#'-.  "# (!( .&!.# !

2,0024'-0#'-'*'..'(!4 - .''(#.#'!0#!02!8'# '".'#.!0 !>$-:

!)# -.#' #!.# 9 2! .4.'&&,( 8(!!-" -0#!('.* '#  .'0 (!

0#'.# -#' .##' 2! '#.!0 '! !-#' '..'!0'9 4'5'0#'!* (..' !!

#'#'#&!&,(!D>##4.'#.!.0&,(0'-!"##'2!.!#!!!-#.!.#'5,"(,..'#.

.-''&!-.%

0%.%44#!')#'  "!#'-. 5'!)  ".- !-!. -'(! &-(# 2!  "#.# !!-0!* !#

!&'#.!0'# (#' #'- ( 2! (!!-" -0#' ''#(4'  4!!0(!.! !#.#'

.4.(#'-' 566!(' 8&!)!0#,#' 4!&,.('9 5 5 .# !!-' 2! (,,0!# (''0'%

!.#2!-'!)*'.(!!-" -0#!('. -.'0.! .-#'!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'#

(.(' . --,0'(#' "#.#'(..'.4.(#'!-#'-% &,0 . --,'.'

&40'.!&!0(#'0'-'00 ".--(#'-.&!#.!(#.*' -'5'-!-.7"' 0#'

 "#.#' (#' .!!242'- !.#2! "!- 5 5 .# !!-' 4!!0(!.! !#.#'

.4.(#'-'566!('% "# 2440##-#'-..4'--.!&'#.!(!.!#'--'!*'. -0'(!

0#4#.66-8 "#-'##'0!#.!&!#92!!.#'!2!-,524&''-5#!&!-.!'!!0(!#

"!..'(!4.(#'-'!.-'&#%













*% ! ".'  -('-('-'  ##'# 8'0!#50  ! "#9* ..&0

(44#!')#' (!.'2!-0'!* (44#!')#' &40'.'!* -'0#* '. (44#!')# 

5,"2'0!(!.  !"-0!(#'-' ' -% !! ". (44#  #'!0#- 2! 5#!&!-.

( .&''.0.7"#.!(#'-''-%



1% ! "#,#.)(!! ".4#.-#'!*'.2"- -0'(!0#!.#'!2!-'

240  . --,0'0 2! ' .4.0 .!--' 5!00  "#.#* 566!) (!! "# !0(!.!

2440 !#.#' #! (!!-" -0#!('. '..'!0' !-#'- .4.(#'-'* #'0! '!(* '.

7-!-('.!.0,'.-'') !>$-:#4..'#.%

!! ".8-%*(44#'-'".9(44#'5,"2'0!&!# #!##'-.!.!#'5,"2!--.*(--#.'-

5,"2'0#.'- 566!. 44' !! ". % &'() :%! .##'! (,#.'.0 2!

4!!0(!.!!#.#.4.(#'-'% ! "#,#.)'0'5,"2'0#'!%



(% 4.(# . --!(44!.0 . --,0'('&,)!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'

!-#'# --!7#'###*(' .!".-2!.!#.!)24'-'&!-'.' #.!(#.#770-!#'7-'

(#.',#.!(,2&5,"2#%

(%$%! !-#'#. '..'!0'#. 4".)* '.  -0'(! 0# -!"#  ". 5 -. (44!.0

'- "!#.2!!##'-!(!;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<% (!!-" -0!2!' -'!00

.!--'-)!'- "!#.-!"(#'#2!'- "!&!"'.!(#'#%'--'! .!0 !>#

: -  5 *  #4.'#.!.0  . --,0'0% )! 5'!) -'(! ''-'&* (#.,.. 5'-!-.

(!!-" -0!2!.'!&.!(''- "!&!"'.!(#'#.*'!!(!!-" -0#!-#'-',#.

 . --,'.'(#'#% -0'(!0# 0#'!0#'#..-''&!-. "#.#'-!0!





 



8:9

:

0-!#(44!.0  "!#* (#.,.. 5'(!. !'! ' -0 &,(!- .'(! #".'# .' #.!0!

4.(# . --%

''5,"2#44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'!(,#.'.02!4!!0(!.!

!#.#.4.(#'-'566!(#'# #''*'. -0'(!0#'!--0 ".5 -.(44!.0

 "#.#'-'(..'.!&.!0!!.#'!2!-!- " -8-%9%

 ! "# ,#.) (!! ". 24'-0#'!* '.  -0'(! 0#'- ' -0 ('0

)2'.&#'0 .!#.#  . --,'.' .4.(#'#% !--' !. &,(!-# 24'-'&!-' .(#.'#

!#.# !0! &!)!0#'#* 5!! ' # &0 .! #'0! !#.!0!% 44#!')#'# ' -'

'#.!.0#'--#'0!!-!0!#2! -#0*(#.#0&!0-#.!.0(44#'.7"#.!(#'%



$)% !.#2!&.'0.7"#.'-' . --,'.'(#.'-'' -'!#2! "!#'0%

$)%$% -''&!-. ! > : - * -.'  2!  #4..'#.* 2"-*  #770(,#.'. ' 24

 . --,0'0*&,'.40!.!--'5!00 "#.# (!! ".- -(&,(!-#.A

$)%$%$%(44!.!#770-!#'-'.4'0!&!0 "#.# #,-!# !>!:-@

$)%$%'%5'0!0!#770-!#'-'(44!.0!.#'!'!*0(..' "'(7"'!!#.!&,!@

$)%$%-%566!.!(,#.'.0!#.#.4.(#'-'%

!>$-:'4''..'&,(!-#.!.#'!2!5'0!(#'#&,#770(,#.'.-'.4'0!&!.'

 "#.#.'5!'(#.%



$$%.!.!&!# !#2!#  -'00 .#.* '. !.#'!2! '#.'- (!!-" -0#!-' #

8 -0'(! 0#9 # .!".--. .!--' 5!00  "#.# 2! ' 240  . --,0'0%

4(#.&44)#''*'..'0!!".-#.!.!#' !>24.' . ('5!'(#'#!.#'!2!

'#.'-8-%39.'(!#".'#  "!-0!.0.,'0!&!"#.!(#.%

 (!!-" -0#!-'* '#  !--.!.0 (!!-" -0#'-'* (--' ''#(4  .!!0!

.'(!'0!#',#-'#*5!')!.#'!2!'#.'-.'!0--.. (''.' *##&.!)#''

.#'#'-.(!!-" -0#!-#'# &(!.#'-'(!!-" -0#',0'0.4.!%



4".0'#''-. 0#.2!2"00'# (!!-(''.-#'#'!0#.>>0'#.32!324.!)

 ! "#(!! ".(44#'(.(!.!(44#!')#'!"-0!(!.!%











""!- (./!. &





'&!'&! 



-!0( 1!-!

 ".









 ".





 ".