Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-14288\3 AI generated

Court dismissed execution appeal against a 2007 decision to revoke Estonian citizenship due to lack of procedural grounds.

Case Number 1-07-14288\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the execution appeal filed by the applicant against the 2007 decision to revoke his Estonian citizenship. The applicant argued that the revocation violated his rights, but the court found no procedural errors in the original decision. Consequently, the court upheld the original ruling to revoke citizenship based on the established facts at the time.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Citizenship Act 1991; s. 10 of the Citizenship Act 1991: The court ruled that a decision to revoke citizenship remains valid if the original proceedings were conducted in accordance with the law and no new procedural defects are discovered.

Keywords

AI generated
citizenship revocation execution appeal procedural grounds Citizenship Act 1991 judicial review state authority legal standing

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Citizenship Act 1991

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













         







 







 

 !"#!$% &"'











 

()!!  )!

   



 

" 



*'

+',-$



&

")).

% 

&)&! "))."!& &' ! 

!)!!&&!!

+/(.!01&!&!















!)& 222$ .

3+

$ 0!& .$

!.$!"!!) !!!!)$!&44&$ !".

&))&&&.



   

) 0

  



"))."!&&'! 

")).)!(.!01&!

 

.!. &&')

    













 !"# !!$



% &  '() *+  





%  $ & 



,-./*.-//)  

   ,0/)0-)1*

2

 

     

  3 ,4

56



 7+

&&    





.



%





 2

3& 



0&2 & .



  





    



-8.,,.-//(.







 



,,!5!)! 6#7"!5,! ') &!",,!,&&!"!)!',-! &5,! &

!&.",,!#!&% &"')!







 +  &  





 & %  &"'  33 &!-  33

/  "6&!& (.!

01&! 77.  *  '

+ ',- ' )65))& && -&!-  &  .

' & 3+ ",,!-   #&& (.! 01&! &!

."!& &-" !! &,&!- &!'- ,."& &' )&!$ . "&&!

,!"&&",,!'6&"!&'",,&&!))!&,&'&

")).',!)! ) !))-&&',-" */)-5$$

$$/

,&!&&.&))6.!.8

 !)"&",,&.))!!)222$

 )"" ")).' ",,&. ' !"! ',!) "))..

!-&!!"!)!$

 ))" ")).' &)))! " !) - !&" &))! ."!. "

&&!&,&"!'!)& !.&!&$

 ""))."!&)&!!)! )!)&)"!!"

!&!&7"!5,! $

/ ""))."!&)&!!)! )!)'655" !&"!

(.!01&!&!).& & )& */)-',-"&8

 "&&!& &.))'&"!$

 .&44)!')5!)! #!"&



' & 3+ &",, '6& +  ' (.! 01&! #&&

-)&



#&% &"''!)!!&&!!(.!01&!

&!!&&!5!-544&(.!01&!5)&."&',,.&!&,&"!)!

!!!))!-$!&&!"!)"!-&!!"!)!$!))&!)!"&&!& &.))'

&"!'!&",,&.'&44&)""6' 56'!&



0&&!.! !)& ).)!)& ! )! 6") 6&& !)!&$  "& . )"

"))..&-! ))'#!!.$"))."!&&!.!

6&. &



")).'  #$ !& (.! 01&! 7)! ")).! &!&"! 5)!

6")$"&!"&&))&&&#")).!&!&"&



&&-)5)")).'544&(.!01&!)."&',,.&!

&,&"!)!")).)!!!&,&!- #&"!&-"!.



&''")).)!!)."))."!&&&)!&&!

&,&"!)!544"!& &(.!01&!&$!&!)!!&&!.! &#

&6!)!



94 #$!&"))."!&!)!!&&!!(.!01&!&!

56'!.&.')#)."!)!(.!01&!5!#&,&"&!.$")

5.. &!")! &-" !!&,&!-! #&"! ,-

 & &&.$ !&  &

&!')&5..&



 (.!01&!!.$54)!)!)&"&&!&!&.!&&.!)&

!&&!.!&!!-&)!# *3)-/)!)544&(.!01&!)!"6&!&.."&

',,.&!&,&"!)!







 

 



.. ),# &" "&!').$ ). 7)! "!!&))!.$ .. ),#

&&-)! ,- !&&. ."!..$  # $ !& "))."!&

!&&!5! 544&  (.! 01&!) ."& ',,. &!  &,&"!)!$ 

56'!.&.')#)."!)!



 & &$ !& ")).)!  !!&,&!- #&"! &-"

&!' !&!)  & & 5..  & &&-) & ! !&. "6' .

56'!. &&! "!&&. &))6!&!  "!  &  .#

).)! ,&"& -&!& &-" !! &,&!- #&"! &-"&!

"&&!&,&"! !!-   !!..$ !& (.! 01&!)!  &&#! 544&

"6&!&.."&',,.&!&,&"!)!



:,&.! 7))"&&$ 544#  & )&  * 3 )- / (.! 01&!)! 

&% &"'33&!-33

/"6&!&.."&',,.

&!;+5,! $ -&&&,&"!)!



&!!#",,!&-!.!!!)&.)!''..! *)-&$

)-













()!!  )!

&