Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-4467\2 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against prosecutor's activity, ruling it lawful and not abusive.

Case Number 1-07-4467\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal filed by the prosecutor against the prosecutor's own activity. The applicant argued that the prosecutor's actions were abusive and lacked legal basis, but the court found no evidence of illegality. Consequently, the court upheld the original decision, confirming the prosecutor's conduct was lawful.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure; The court's review of a prosecutor's own activity is limited to verifying legality and proportionality, and an appeal against such activity is dismissed if the conduct is found to be lawful and not abusive.

Keywords

AI generated
prosecutor's own activity Code of Criminal Procedure abuse of power legal review procedural legality

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Code of Criminal Procedure

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

         

            !"" #$%&        '  ( )"!"  +,+ ( -*( +(      

  +. & + -&+&((-  +,           !     "#$"%$&""'  (     

   ) * 

 

   $  +    !          *      ,    +*

       

     $  *   -!  

      

   $   +         -    ((  ""    ++(( + . &  &++"/&+',+. &(+( +(  01 (+ ' +2+(  (33(-(+(++&+4+#(+  '  +5" " 6 &  ((  ,+  -  +  ("+. & &++('%-((+- (%  + (++ + %  '&((  

# +(+ ( ,+  - *++ & ,   ++   + . &     (++ (   7  ! *(+((  (+"  "" %'+((   '  ( '  , / & 8+, ('(++(  +((  -#+. &   (+++ + (  ( +(   (33(-(+ +( (+( ((+(    '   (+ (((&#    * (+(& % &((&* (&-&(&( 7 - 7!"  /((+( +'++'33 " " +,+  '  ( +. &"

      '   , # ((&   ++(+ (( -*( + (+ - + - +,+#+  #+((  ++(( ((+('%-+(-+,

 ++ +  "  '   ,   + +# +( -%( & (+(+ +( &%  ( -  (++ ( + . &  '( &    + '&(+&% (+-#+,-+ -*   ++ --'%-(%++ & "  +  ( +(++&(++(+'%-+(% (   -  (+(+ ( - + . &  '( &* +(  (+  (   -%( & (+(+  (&((# +( '% +(%  (+ &+ +  '%-(  ((+   -(#& +. & +"         ""  + ( + . &  + - &+&( (-   +,+  '  ( )"!"  +'++"  +,++ (-++(,#+(". &-/" && ,  % (6 1 + 9 +" !) 6:;" /(( -(  ". &" 6++ &*-%  - ((   (  % (  &((((". & (% &*-% ( # '   -* ( - (%+( ". &  ( % (++# '+(+ ". &  (( #5 ++(  +" ". & '   -* (#   '% +( &*(  +  (" %  ( & , ' (+ +(  +  +(+" (-+ ,#+(% ( -(0 + (  8 ++ -+ 7 5 '" 5 %+ "  (++&+ %  0 + ( (( (&  +

# -(,((+ (+  +(+++-(+ & ++"0 + (  (++&+ 7 !+((+*( (++ "/(  (  + +++ ". &  +,+  ( + ' (+  (+( (+ '++ & (+-   !! <!"%((+#+(0 + ( (++&+ 8 ++ -+

 +-(4 (' (+ )"" (+& (+-". &  ( +(8 7 "-*   ++(%'+(( "  +,++ (-',(4 (  '  ( )"!"  -((   ++((0 + ( (+ 7 !-*  "          " # %  '  ( ( &*-   ++(+ (( -*( + (+ -    #  (( & (+- (+ -    !!<!-((&++(+ - +# ((&  '  ( ". &  +,+ ( -*( +  +# (  ". &   (- &( (-  +,+  '  (   -( +(++ + +'++# + ,# +(  '  (  )"!"    (+, (4 ( -   '  ( + 

+ +(++ +" -* +('%-+,-*  +(=  "  '   , # '%-++   (#   + +# +( -%( & (+(+ +( &%  ( -  (++ (   

             #+,-+ -*   ++ --'%-(%++ & " >  *  ,  '   ,    +# +(    +   ( +( ++&(+ +(+ '%- +( % (    -  (+(+ ( - . &  '(&* +((+  ( -%(& (+(+(&((#+('% +( %  (+&++ '%-( ((+-(& . & +"

   + ,#+(  '  , ('%-+++ +&(&%+(&# &((- +,++ ( (5"" (+'  & (+-    <! ?           

    ?#  +(4 (' (+ )"-  "(+- !!##<!+. &   (+(8 7-*  ( & )   %'+(-++(+" (++ #+((++&+(+ (0" ((+96 ;# -( . &# & 

"/(((+ +-%("  !"  '  ,  +(+ +&%  &*-+#  '  ( (+(,  '  (  '   ,  / &  8+, ( + ( &%   ((+" /"8+, (  '%-+    -  ((+( + (+( ( ++# +(

                  

         

                            

   

 

  8+ +#+((((&   '  +  % &(( &* (& -# +  4(+ '   , #   +   '  & *(++ +++ ,- +++( 7!@((+  "  " -#  '  , + #+(  &+(& (+((# (- &% (++ ( 

         " ++  '   ,  +  &* (# +( '&(+ &%  (+- ( &%  "  -#    &+(# +( & (+   . &  (+ %'+((#    ( &%  (  ((  (+ ((+ +'#/AB/ (-("  5"  '+, &-  *  # +( " . &   &( '33  ' (+ ++(+-'+#+((& *  (+(+ ((+& (+# +(( '33   +" (( ". &  +,(++# +  ' (+ ++(+- + (  '  ( +&*-+ (#  ++& (+ (+ ((. & +?       

      

?"  "  + ,# +( ++   ++(+ ( ( &%  ++( ++ +( +&- &*-+ (=  ?  ++& (+ (+ ((". & +( ((  "  ,? *- + ( &- + '+(  ( +  &#  ( &  ((   &%   (+-&% '&(+("  C? +,#+((  +(++&% # +++  7 !%((+"  ? $   4( (   +  + &%   *,  &     ++(( ((# +4   ++(+( +("  +? $#   4( -+ (   + *  + (+# +( ',    ++(+ ( +#   +  + (++ + (+,  -  &+(# +(

 '  ( '  , / & 8+, ((+( -  '  , 0 + 0&  (  &+&("  2? ( #+ +(++ +(+, &+(#+(& (+ +. & (+  (5"" (+%'+((" 

     8*(+ ++(( - - +    7+( <   ' # D 7( !<5 ' <# + ,

#+(  '  ( )"!" +,+ (-*( + (+, (4 (-  '  ( +

+(* +&(+++((  (+"         .