Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-14009\5 AI generated

Court dismissed asylum claim for a former soldier who failed to prove fear of persecution in Estonia.

Case Number 1-07-14009\5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the asylum application filed by a former soldier who claimed fear of persecution in Estonia. The applicant argued that his military service and potential return would endanger him, but the court found no credible evidence of specific threats. Consequently, the court ruled that the applicant did not meet the legal threshold for asylum protection.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

AsylS 1994, § 1; § 2: An asylum claim is rejected when the applicant fails to substantiate a well-founded fear of persecution based on specific grounds, particularly when the risk is deemed general rather than individualized.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum claim fear of persecution former soldier Estonia well-founded fear procedural dismissal protection status

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AsylS 1994, § 1
AsylS 1994, § 2

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

         

   !"#$% &'#$% $("  

     ())(*+,"-(../0   1 1%!2       %  

     1%%  3341  5 ** &621' 1 1!% 33415"-.7(&5**&621%77 %  3%%181             114 .-+9""-9(: %: 7$1142:1 !112141: %1%:/;) %1 <<$1 2:   1 1% 14= (0.9(++ #$% &1  2   5 (+9 %2"   &621 .) !42: "0 "/(((++ #$%  2   5 (+9 %2" &621 ") !42: .0(*("(++* #$%  2 5(+9%2"&621")!42:*0"-((++/ #$%  2   5 (.+ %2" 7. &621 9)%1 !42 121 11 ") &2: 9 0 "+-(+++#$%25(+%2"7"&621*) %1 !42: -0 /(+++ #$%  2   5 (+9 %2" &621 /)%1 !42: 0 (("(#$%25(.+%2"7"&621*) %1 !42 121 11 ") &2' 1 #$%  (/"( 662  7<<4 61 1%: /0 ".*"*#$%25*"*&621.76 21 3 $141 &1 1 $12 6$ 12 ( :+0.+"*#$%25(++%2" 7 *' &621 . 4 21'  5 -9 %2 ( %% * 4 21:(0((""*#$%25"" %2 (: (++ %2 " 7 *''/ &621  4 & "* 76 21: ((0(("-25"(%2"7('* &621"421:("0"*/"-2 5"--%2"7.&621.7621:(.0--" 25)4"--%2"7('("('"-.7(

",*0 &6219421' 14:$4)%% 1 %4      114.9*/(*"9:%:142:1

!1121 41:  % 1 %: << 1  :   1 1% 14= (0.*". #$%  25(.+%2"7.&621.421121 11(  & -)%1 &2: "0.+". #$%  2   5 (++ %2 " 7 *''/ &621 - 4 21' 64 1% * 4 & " 76 21 121 11 ") &2:.0/*"*#$%25"-. 7 ( & * &621 %1 1 (/ 1' 1  4 %212 & 1% "/("*)/*"*: *0(.9"9#$%25"9%2('"&(++ %2" 7* & -9 %2 " &621 9 4 & " 76 21: 909"9#$%25(++%2"7*& -9%2"&6214&"7621:-0(*+"- 25"9%2('"&(++%2"7*&621( 21:0"/."25(++ %2 " 7 * &621 " 4 21'  5 -9 %2 " %% %$7%1 1.421' 14:$4%% 1 %4    

44#>6  !"#     3341 $15**&621&14212.,% 04  5 -/ %2 ( %% %24 1& %    1%% 1 %21 11!14 2 (9+)(+"  . 76 &                     $% &$'(    )   1%% 1$4?%% 1%4)&641161 1% 7<< 11  &$ 1% 4   1%% 1   7% 4 1 6214&%&1%  14   1%% 114 1% !%1 11%  1 % %&62% 7%117@1%  14 & 7124 1 4      1%% 1 21  4 1 & %2  %   1%  114 $11 1      3341 $15**&621&14212.,% 04     3341 $15"-.7(&621&14212.,% 04  5 -* %2 ( %% 311 1  4 1 % $1  1 1!%1% %1119,110421 5-/%2(%%%241&% 11!%1%2111!142(9+) (+"  .76 &                *%  & $'(     1 1!%1 $4 ? % % 1 %4 )  &6 41 1  61 1% 7<< 11  &$ 1% 4 1 1!%1   7% 4 1 6214&%&1%  14  11!%114 1%!%1 11%  1%%&62%7%117@1%14&712414  11!%1214 1&%2% 1%  114 $1

.,*0 1 1 

6%& $1  1%% 1% %%449*,11%1401 & $12!1   (9// ,3  114 3 4 0 1 - 1 1121%4

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

*,*0 6%  & %$1  1 % % &%2 6 4 2 7$&1  147$&@331%1% 2 11!%711 %11 1621%%2'5"-.7(&621 %1@111 

% 3341       %%'      1%% 12 (9+" %%+.71!111!1%33#$%%1&" &1 !*6%1 % 1 ' 1%% 2&6&%  31  22 7$&14   1%%  & 11!%111!14>' 'A ' & %%121% 2 11!%711 $$&33 1' 1%%2%17$&411 %% &1%'5**&621%1@111   (    3341 1%% 1' 1&&7<1!1%$% 14%77% $! 7< 3341% 1  5 **  64 1 1 7 1 .421' 1%%%24%2111!142.76 3341 1!%1  '   1& & 7<1 !1 % $% 14 %77 % $! 7< 3341% 1  5 **  64 1 1 7 1 .421&5"-.7(&621.4215-*%2(%% 311 1  4 1 % %24 1 1!%1 %$7%1 1  9 421' 1%%%24%2111!142.76     334141114121%'%774&$4%%2 33411&&7<1!1&614121%%7&4 %1  1 7$&%  %1!'  %7  $% 14  33414 6%&44   $%1   12 1 1%& % 1%  &6214 %77 %614 3341  1%% %!3341 $15**&62112%%%! $1 %7713341 11!%%!3341 $15**&"-.7 (&62112%%%! $1%771  %%  5)  (/ %2 ( 31! %%4 3341 $1 6% 1 1%& %%43341 $124('97%2 % 66      9* 1  & 1121 $12!1  664 1&% (9//'-1' 1%! %13341%1121%46%& $1