Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-3221\2 AI generated

Court dismissed prosecution appeal against administrative decision regarding detention of a foreign national.

Case Number 1-07-3221\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the prosecution's appeal against the administrative decision to detain a foreign national pending deportation. The prosecution argued that the detention violated the principle of proportionality and lacked sufficient justification given the short duration. The court found that the administrative body had correctly assessed the risk of flight and the gravity of the offense, rendering the detention lawful and necessary under the relevant immigration statutes.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993; s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993: Administrative detention of a foreign national is permissible if the decision-maker demonstrates that the measure is necessary to prevent flight or ensure the execution of deportation proceedings, and that less restrictive measures are insufficient.

Keywords

AI generated
Aliens Act 1993 administrative detention proportionality principle deportation proceedings foreign national prosecution appeal risk of flight

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text











 









 





 

 





  



  







 ! !"#$ 











 %



&

!!'((

)

*+'&

,(&' &



 











-

 '* 

 .%

& / %

& *+

&  +,

++&  &)







  



  !"#$%#%$$&   

 



# 

'  



 







#

'

  ( 







  









 

#





)



 









' *, 

  01 2 *&&  

' *'&*& ! !   

 3  2

&&* , -

 '*   %

& *+

&

, * , 

&  

%  *+

**!4

& *+

&*+*&-

'* ,& +%*&&* ++

&&$&& '$ ' **  (+'  ,* &   %$,+'&& 



*&' & , && $&' " '  %$,&&  &&' & *$%%' "

&&$&& ',$& '&'  , & & 

+ &

+  + ,&' !

'& 

 &+ !

%% ,

!*  &&( &

 &   )+* * &*" ' 

(*,+)"& ' 

*++-

'* 

++* 

'%' &" '((

 '%' * * 

   2"0 ' *, & 

  , '55





+&

 !



0!0!6 *$%&& 

 %



&

 

  %



 )  -  * 

%*&'&* '&&+

' *,"%



) * + "& -

'* 

,&  ' -+ #  &&( &

 &   &   &&&+ 

&

&&&& '%' &+%*&!



-&+'((

& -

'* %

& *+



!*%*&  %



&

!





 

 %





# !6!6'((

&5 && 

' *'&**$%&' 

'((

!  %



 $& & '((

 &&( &

   &* &+

 &! &&+ ,(

 + ),%*& *&++&& +&+

&+   * &*& &+ -

 * '*   , & &' !

 %



&'&*,&

' *'&*&,(&' &&'-

'*

  ,& * '& & & 

 3  2 (&&&+ 55& *!

 %



+  ,+*&( +*&5**&,&* '+-+#

,-  * &+",' * ,&**"&(

5 ',$&

$  & 

  *+  + *)&+  '  ''%

 , ' +   ' * ,&

&&$&& !



 %



&

 *()   %



&

'((

&++'&*& ' 

 +%$,*%



) -!* !!6'((

*$%&

' *,



 01 2 '&*!   ,) 

'*& &+   &&( &

 !  

&*" '  $&   %



&

" * +  %



 ) " &  -

  '*

  ,& * '+ * + 5 &+* + &&$&& *& ',+* &  & ,

'

&&"  + %++ &$+ +  &" & ,& * '+ * + &+* +

&&$&&** &',$&& &&&$&&

(' %*& % &* &!

-&+,* && +%(

&&-

'* ) * &' &"

' ,(

*&& & (

+5*+*,&&& *&+%

& '&*&!



 %



&

''((

!!,(&& 5**&++'((

'&'& * + "

&)

*+'  **& * &$ ** & +,&( + +%$ & !

&&( &

 !  &*,)  %



&

!6!6'((

&+$ * 

      $&&+  +  '&* ( !   &* & +



' *+ *&&' && &'

&&& 

&$ * 

  +'   '  &$&& $ '&!  

' *, '&

,* +& (&)" &

+'  &

' %+ % +,   +,   $++    & *&  



&' *% & &* + ' + , '&  % + *()

(( '   -

 '*  

 +,& %+ ' $$

+'  , $* (+'  !

 $  '*

 ,&* '&*&$%*&&

+&&' &%5 +

'"

&

% *&,&%5 &',$&& *(*,,+!



  







6!!  & -

 '*   %

& *+

&

!* , !

%    +,

++&  &)  %



&

!!'((

%*!



)  &, $&) '  &(&, ( &*  !   )+* & &&

'%' 



*+' *

$ 

,&

* '&

&&





+

$$

+' &

 ,',$&&&* %$,&' !



'") &,* )"&((

$ &"' %+&),(

*+ 



 3  2   %+'  -

 '*   ,& * '&  &"

*$  %$,*" &  '&&+   *+'    $ '*  ' 

 +*&' ,* +** + * +&+&&'&!



 ' *&&'&

,* +&(&)"&-

'* ,&* '+* +*&

&& &&+* +"&(

5  %(',+&&&



  $$

+&+ * '%' *   & (

5    

 *+



 

*&

+

+ & !1!-

*'*  +&

 !

* +

,& * '+ &+* +" '   

+   & (

5  

+  + *+*&

 +$*&& %+ &+*&

&& % & 



 

!    

+  * , ((

&* * + '*   ,& * '+

&+* +(

5 &&&"' +* +

'+ ' *, &

 !

*&+ **    5  ,& *   +  '$ &* *&  &" &  

 

*&

&

+ $ '* &+' ' *, 

 

&$*&

&  )

  & &$**+,&!



) &,* )"&((

  %



&

$ &*&+ *"&

-+#,- &%+)

3 2 !



)  &, %*) &5 &+  %



&

 !! )

*+'& ,(&' 

'((

 &*&+

' *'&* &

' * + '&*' 

 (&&55+ && &' %(+*

' &*!



  



 

#



)* &"&((

 *&+ &

3 2$ '* * *!

*

+"-

'* ,&* '&*% + (

5 ',$&

*'*,)&*"&%

& *+,(&   &'&*& &'&!



'(

 )"& 

3 2 &

32'(

 &+"&

',$&%)&*' 

 !-

 ',+&%

+* !,



 !+&')

!

&* &',+&

 &+ *,'*&!, *

!8 & ' &+!,+&

+&*)"&,&,$&&+

  , *     & (

+ 5*+* & ' 2!, * !





' *$ * '$&&"' 

)

36*(&&&&" *-

'* 

,&* '&( &' 

3 2&&(&+

& !



4

& *+

&  +, ) '(

 & ,& * '& $ '*  

&* 

( &' & ,%

+ &++& %*&",&* '&*

% + *'*"&(

5 ',$&!8 

3 2 

32&&(&+

&  99 &' 

&" '  ' &(& 

' *+  ,(

  *  0 &&! 0 :

&&(&*&& '%' &,*$%%&+' '((

!

" 

*+  &,  *& % +  (

5  ,& * '&* *'   *,'*& ,)  !

%&')

**"&(

5  



+ &

 " *)

& %(& '    (* ,    & 

&$ * 

 +' +   %



&

'((

'&*&*&'&,(&' 

&&*),(&&'&'&!



, +)



32*0











&