Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-5937\15 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against deportation order, ruling it was not arbitrary despite procedural errors.

Case Number 1-06-5937\15
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against the deportation order, upholding the decision despite procedural irregularities. The appellant argued that the deportation was arbitrary and violated rights, while the state contended the order was necessary for public safety. The court ruled that the deportation was not arbitrary because the decision was based on relevant facts and followed the proper legal procedure, rendering the procedural errors insufficient to overturn the outcome.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993; s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993: A deportation order is not arbitrary if it is based on relevant facts and follows the proper legal procedure, even if procedural errors occur.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order arbitrary decision procedural errors Aliens Act 1993 public safety appeal dismissal proportionality

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

            

    

            !"    #$ %& '( )  *'+' )$(#$,$ +             ()    

%!)-- .$''% $/$ '-/ %)%&-%) $%        0$ 1 )-- $/    0$  1 2  ( "3""+ $'% 444444444 555+ 6 + #$%  /   ( + $ (+$)$$'$$$$'+$ %77% %' '% %%(8 (     9$% $:    ; )%$    !"#  !   $%&'(&)''%  *   + ,-       #     $'&'.&)''%           /  -        &                   )0&$'&)''% -   $0&''&       /-        &    1    

   /  %$ '-/ %) $ <'()$$%'$ 

  ) '  0$ 1 <<( %$ =!!'.3+8&-   !  /  %$ '-/ %) $ <'()$$%'$ 

  ) '  0$ 1 <<( %$ =83'.+&='.&-  

%"8)-- $<$(%  ) '&(  !"& 3 <%$)$$%'$&'$% . & ) '   !"   8 % % ' $ % .   9$%  $:  ()$( ( %(  ) '& '$..$ '() $ % % ' '( 0$  1+ $% / ') %( '$..$%  + %/ $''$   (  /%%' '% '$ '$..$)$$%'$ '() $+ '$..$ ') ) $' '( ) %$' % %$% >  & %&%$% (') %('$.$% 

%8%$% %% 0$ 1<<(  =83'.++= '.+=!!'.3+8&-   ) %$% %''$ %$ =83'.+&-   ? @%% %%+ ='.&-  ?<@% %%+ =!!'. 3+8&-  % %%'( =3' '$$ $) %$ $% $) %$&) % ' % %$ ? @%% %% %$-  () $ '$ '$%   0$  1 '$ ' %( %$(   %) $ &-$%  )%)% ='".$'% ))!  A $$ % &%    )( $  %$$' '%$$'(( B'$&--())33  %%% 0$  1 '$         "8 $ % 0$  1 %$% $ .$''% $/$ $ %) $ %$% 38 /  %'$ 0$  1  .$''%    % 8 %$'$ ) .$''%   .' 0$  1 % %( )% %  '-/  ) $ $/$('  & %< %(  % 8 %   %  ) ' $ %) $<'(

  + (( '-/   ) '% )  )%$ &' ( & $ %%( .$''%  + '$ ( + $% 0$ 1 .$''%  %8%$'$%'$/&-%%'-/ %)%& %%(.$''( '$ %'%  ="!'.$ '(%'$..$)$$%'%+  $''$$ %<<( %%+%$) %&&.  % "8'$..$'$' (''  &%( .  +<<( %%& %&% % ''(<<( %%+$% / ') %( '$..$%   & %/ $''$  '  $ '+ $% %'%   ="8'".3.$''%  $ $ %('$..$)$$%'$%$%(%%$ .$'$+ -'&  %( &'+   %$$) %  -$'$ $(%  ! .$%<   & -%$%$

) $+% '' ( ) '% ) )%$ &'$+<<( %%.$''%   $ '$ ((-$'$$(% !.$%< &-%$%$ )   

%!)-- $.$'$$ %)-- $/$0$ 1 <<( %% '$ /+ $% %   & + ) ' %  ' . () %$ %..+ )% ) %% '$..$)$$%'$% '/( %&%+) (%%$  <<( %%% ') .-$$$% % %% ;&  )$'$)$%'  &+) ''$'/8 ') %( '$..$% )  & '/ %   %& 9  1$'   %$$%$% & .' $('$ )-- %  %&   .'%  % % '$ %  <<( %% .<%  & %$  ) ' $ ' $ '($  % >- % $( ' %  %' %  



% - '$'<%'$.  <<( %%'$+$%<<( %%  /%$)$& % '$..$$ %+ )-- %$%''$ %$%% %% <<( %% $ '+$%.  '(%''$ $%&'  /  (<<( %%'-$($(+$( %$ %%(. %+ %' %'%%%) %'$..$%( <<( %%)-  /+$%  '$ %''$ $%%$ %%$ ')  %& & $'$% <<( %% $  '$ + $% ) '$  %$ -  () $ &  <<( %%  %$ .$  %$- () $&'$)  % % ' &-  <<( %% 01 ) )-- $/$ & )-- $/$ %((.&$(%$& ($&  %$$' (+$%$$)% % %%$%% &' '% % '$+ $% $  % '$..$)$$%'$ '() $ & %%'$/+ $%  )-- / %''$  %&+ $% (% 91$'  %+ $''$ %' '  '$.$+ % '// )%   % )% % '$'((+$%'//(%91$'  %&'$..$)$$%'$ '() $% 

<<( %% 01   %& ((  $)/  9  ; )%$  '$ ( + $%  %(  %$ % & $(  -  % %  . %'' %+  01 -- /+ $%  / '/( %&%& &%$''$%'($'<<( %%%%'$- & ' %' %+  ( '$( % $''$ % $  %$ ( $$ .'$ %%(  %$'$  %$   $  %$ (  (' <<( %% %$' % %$% '$..$ ') ) $  $  '$ %% ( %$ '$( % '$..$)$$%'$ $$    = 3 ' 

) $+ $$ %$ / <<( %%' .$''%     %& .' $/ '((+ )%)-- %< %(&%%.$''% )$$%'$ 

 .  % .  9$: '$ ( +$%)%)-- $(' & %< %) $'$$ '         +%%()-- $/$&$/$'$' %()%$ &' ($+'(-   %&&.  +'$ /+$%<<( %%0$ 1 )-- $/.&$(%(& '/ '() $'$   %/ )% $ + $% %'%    = "8 ' " . 3+ .$''%   $   $ %( '$..$)$$%'$ %$%( %%$ .$'$+ -'&  %( &'+ %$$) %-$'$$(% !.$%< &-%$%$ ) $ )'&'$  '$ '% &( )%  )%+ $% % '' ($  ) '% )  )%$ &'$+ 01  .$''%  +$ '$ -$'$$(% !.$%< &-%$%$ )  C'C  #)'%)-  / +$%$$% % %<<( %%01+)'($ )%'$+ .' )-- % %''$  %&   .'%+  % '// (% 91$'  %+ $''$ %' '  '$.$ C  

    C $(    %( 01)% % 'C' +"3/C %'%  =3"'.)-- / %& +   <<( %% $  '$ $('$  %&% ' (+  (  %%'$(  %& )-- ) % %)% <''%('$+ )+ ($    = 3" '  .  ($ (+ $  )-- ( 01 '$  %&% & $  $$$ ( <'($ %( <<( %% %%'$ .$'$ C         C  <<( %% 01 '  $$'$'%  %& 91$'  % '/(&)$ '(%''$)-- (% %&%+ $$%-$(/+$% %&$ '$ %)$$%'$ '$( '$..$)$$%'$  %& '$) $  %'  %'%  =""!'." ) ')$$%' $ ) $'' $+  %&$ 

'$%)$$%'$'$(  =""8."-%$%/+$%%%$.$''%  

 %< %) $ '$   ) ')$$%' $ '' $

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