Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-9187\2 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement of a 1990 administrative decision against a former prisoner for procedural defects.

Case Number 1-07-9187\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement of a 1990 administrative decision against a former prisoner, ruling it procedurally invalid. The defendant argued the decision violated his rights as a former prisoner, while the authority maintained the original order remained valid. The court held that the decision was void due to a lack of proper legal basis and procedural compliance, rendering it unenforceable.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 100 of the Administrative Procedure Act; s. 101 of the Administrative Procedure Act: An administrative decision is void and unenforceable if it lacks a legal basis or violates fundamental procedural requirements.

Keywords

AI generated
administrative procedure former prisoner procedural defects void administrative act enforcement dismissal legal basis requirement procedural compliance

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 100 of the Administrative Procedure Act
s. 101 of the Administrative Procedure Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









        







 







 

 !"#$% &'











 

()"" %)"*

   



 

 '*()""'"%



+),-.##'/,#



 

&*))0

$%

) " &*))0&" *  '* *"*%

")*" " "" *  . ()"" ")/*"*

 "



















1)  222 0    # 1 0*#

""0#"&"")%"*""")# 33 222

"&   4 %"&  ))    0 

)

   

5"* "*6%

  



&*))0&" * '**"*%

&*))0)*"()""")/*"*

 

*0"0% 7)*6")*%

    









 

 !" #



$ 

% 

 

 



# &

 



 



     

&

 





    '()*+











  

 





, 



  

 -



%

.   



  



     



      /

0

&,  





  . 

 *++1



 

2





 

3 45

 



/)'&8 " 0    )"! 9)" *0 *0&* ""& %")0%")" *

 . 1"  :-*, %8 %")0%")" *  

*-*,#

% "*&!".  )0%8!%!  ) / &") 0')

  "'8 &"" " #&/0" &"0&"*0)"#"  ","& * )0"

&",#& &*)'*&!'"%8"))""" * )0 *0







, *8" " &" &"% *,0 )"! " 0    $%  &'

* ")""



  0" "  / )" / &" -/"%&330&")  "'8 &" #

990)*"")",*80"0%!  ) / &"'') *0







 



//"-")"%8!9&*"-/"%')% "&//"/ "&")"'/,*"% -/"% 

" 0&//"!" $% &')"



 ,  &  



 $% &'  ",*;'*, 

.;  ",  &8 "  ()""  ")/*"* 990   ),  - .## '/, '

  %*, ",0-/"%

' .&//",%!  

()"" ")/*"*  " *0&"  *,& "" / ",  "',   

 &//"'8 &" '&//  "))" / ' $% &'

&*))0 &*))0'  '* *"*% '/")"%)%" )) **,

  '/,& +;),-## #.#;/ "  0* ))*80"04

 ")& &// 0))"")0")4222

 )&& &*))0' &// 0 '%"&" '/") &*))0*0

", ""&")"#

 ))& &*))0' * )))" & ") **, " & ))" *0&"0 &

  " / &"'") %"*0 " #

. &&*))0&" *) "")*"%)") )&""&

%" " 9&*"-/"%#

; &&*))0&" *) "")*"%)")'8--&%" &"

()""")/*"* ")0 % %)  +;),#.'/,& 4

 ", ""&*" &*))0 "&"" )&"  ')  0

"")*"%) )"- 0-/"%0")#

 & " % 0))'* &" "'')#

 & "")0&*)  0 "&*))0') )!  )"& #

. )"0 )!-,&&0"#')&*))0'-!#

; 0 33)" " */0) ') ) " %!*"&" -/"%  %8 %8  "*0

338%"&"  33 *%")"#

 %8)*80"  &"%8 9"*0   / ,')-")"%!*"& #

 ,") 9% 0 %),'" 0&*))0')""))"  8"*0



'   .   &// '8  ; '  ()""  ")/*"*

%!  %*,) 



 !    $%  &'' ")*" " "" ()""

")/*"*   " " "-*", -33  ()""  ")/*"* -)   *0&  '//*0

 " / &")""""))",#"  "&")) ")"& " % 0))'

* &"  %)  <) "&"   ",  *0&" ")"  ()""

")/*"* %// "())"0"+)")



1*0-) '  0")" '()""")/*"*")" #" %!&8!-)&#

* "'88) % & "))")"#"  * "0) /"*0%  " " "!

"  '-)! ) & "-33  "&)"   / &")"





 

  *,) -) &*))0' -33  ()""  ")/*"*) *0&  '//*0

 "  / &")" * &*))0)*"  "" / ", %! &"

*,&"



 ' -) '/  &*))0&" *  )" ()""  ")/*"*    "

/ &")"-33&" )0& ()""")/*"*!&%,0" #  

990  (%!# "    " / &")" -33&*" " )"   !" <) & " -33 

()""")/*"*)"*0& '//*0 "#%*,  # / &")"



<3 %!# "  &*))0&" * ")*" " "" ()""  ")/*"*

 "*-8'"*0 0')!)0&")"()""")/*"*-"! / & "0#

& )0 -*00 "&)" *,& "" / "," %! &" /, * %  0# "  

 "') -*00  ()""")/*"*"0 #-3)

")") & " " 0"  0") " "" "", )"! +),;)")

-33 ()""")/*"*)" $% &'  ",*

;&8 " 0*0& '//*0 " / &")"



 

 



# )/! %0*0 & & "')0# / ) 0 -) " %&"0# )"!# "  )"!

"")00 &*))0&" *  )"  &8 " 0 *0&  '//*0  " 

/ &")"-33&" ()""")/*"* "



%8 !%""#" ()""")/*"*  &990#" "'-)! ) 

& "-33  "&)"   / &")" &*))0'%&")()""")/*"*

9)" &*))0" " &*" " )" -!)""&*" **, &*))0&" * *0!

()""")/*"*/ &  "'))0%   "'') "& / !8

 "0# & ) -*00 "&)" *,& "" / "," %! &" /,  ()""

")/*"*")" "')')  ", &"-0 &!))  33 #")!

   ' 8",# "&  -)    0 %// " = *"*" &*"  "' ')

()""")/*"*&*""-0"%) ")&-99!& &")%



"",*%""*0*0#" ()""")/*"*)"&8 " 0*0& '//*0 "

 / &")" -33&*" " )" /")"%) ')   !"*" * &*))0"

""&/,0*% &")#" ", &"-*"&"&*0 0



>/ 0"9))&*  '/ !  &*))0$% ) "

&*))0&" * '**"*%")"" "*0"* .()""

")/*"* "&8 " 0 "/*0&  / &")"-33&" )0& 



 ""!&//" ,*"0""") 0)"''*00" . ), 









()"" %)"*

 *