Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-5756\2 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement of foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects under Estonian law.

Case Number 4-07-5756\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tartu Court of First Instance dismissed the enforcement application against a foreign judgment. The applicant argued for recognition based on the foreign court's authority, but the respondent contested this citing Estonian jurisdictional rules. The court ruled that the foreign court lacked jurisdiction over the respondent and that the Estonian court was the proper venue, leading to the dismissal.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment cannot be enforced in Estonia if the foreign court lacked jurisdiction over the respondent or if the Estonian court was the proper venue for the proceedings.

Keywords

AI generated
enforcement of foreign judgments jurisdiction of foreign courts proper venue in Estonia civil procedure enforcement recognition of foreign decisions

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text











    











 







 

 



  







 

!"#$#





%!&##'(()





 

 

% !   '  $#"* +"# 

$# "#*



 



, !+'$#"*%!$#"#-"#.$-* (

,, ##+/#,00,000-&'#-#"#.*

1)"#' #,*#2#*'"#3

, ##+/#,,-&'#-#"#.*

)"#' #1*##*'"#3

,1 # !##' 00,000   - &. * ,,)

"#' #,*##*'"#3

, # !##' ,0,000   - &. * ,10,)

"#' #,*##*'"#3

, # !##' 0,000   - &. * ,1,)

"#' #,*#2#*'"#



 "$$ -*#3#*'..$##









 



$$+ ##'"$$ 

 ".,+$ 

.'"#



!





4 '&1).' &)*$#4+-.$-"#'%





&)

!  "#'  #' #*'"# .'(   ##+/# ,00,000 

-*1"#' ,*#5 ##+/#,,

- *  "#'   1 *#5 # !##'

00,000   - * ,, "#'   , *#5 #

!##',0,000-*,10,"#' ,*#

. #!##'0,000-*,1,"#' 

,*#



% !   $#"* +"#  $#"# -"# 3 * 

$#"#*"66'*'#'#&)78-,+1$'$-



    

"





$#4#&1)3"$-#'$#"#*#-*'3*

 *'$#"# * ' ' $' $. .3   ,

"66'"#  $# "*.  ."#  $#"# -"#* +

#-#$#' ##"#"#."$##"#*--"#-



!* ##+/ # & )3  % !   '  .$ '"3 

$$ $#"# -"#* + '' # -# $#' ##"#

"#-."$##"#*--"#-"#3*+#-

$#"*$# ##"#



# !# # *+'#" #   "$$' $. &,)

*'#.##

 #"







9$$"* '# &9

) 7 , - , $3  $  +:#

-#" :#"' *#*- "'  $# "*. *'# # *'#

$#"##"* ''.-'*'*'##*' # $#*

"*. # *'# # *'# $#"# +66*'  $#* "*. #

" *# " "$$- "*##  " #.#

"*

$#"*'#&

)7-$3 #$#"#-"#

$#"* +"#  * $## # -*#  ' *'"#

'$#"#*#"$$



4 '#'&83,,3,3,3).$##"# $. &303,3,3

,13,3,3,83,03,)*$ '.$-"#'.'(



 ##+/#,00,000*1$#"#$#

,,,,0005



 ##+/#,,*$#"#$#

5



#!##'00,000*,,$#"#

$#,,,0005





1&)



#!##',0,000*,10,$#"#

$#,,0005



#!##'0,000*,1,$#"#

$#,,000



 ."# . $#"# +66"# . #*'

'#-#"#

'# &

;) 7 11  # *' '# $#"#3 # ' # 

$#"#+66'1.-"#+$  

* ' +66# $#"#

; 7 11 $' $. .3 ## *

$#"*-"#***'$#"##"*''#



,0.#'9

.

71-$3*'##+66$#"#-$#'3#*"66'*'

 78 - , + 1 $' $- .  $# "*.  # 

$#"#+66"##'#:'

$#"* '# &'+#'#

)7 -, + $#"*

$$ . '  $# "*.  #   "$$'

 # #*' $#"# -"# 3 #  # #  # *'

#'#78$'$..

78-,+1&*#,#*''#*)$3#

$#"3# $$."#*"66'*':# 78-,+1

#$#"3# $$'."#*"66'*'

#'



 # "$-#' ' $#' -*''3   +$ ,0  *

'*'.#*'*##$#"#+66"##$#"#3#'*::'*-

$''3*'##$#'3#*"66'*'78-,+1$'

$-3 $. '##* '78#$#"#-"#+"#

#*-# '.'



*::'##,3## $$$#"#-"#

'' *# ,   78 -, +1 $' $-    7 

#



4 ' .3    ##+/# "$-#'  ."# *

"66'*'78-,+1$'$-*#*-+' '78#

$'  $#"# -"# +"# #*-# ' .'3 ## # 3 

 9

71#**'$#"#*-*'

 7 0 -   * #' *'# #*' "*. #- " "$$-

 #$#"#+66"#*'#:' #+##+/

""$$- #$#"#+66"#'#:*'

 #

"#

 #'"#*

#



#*'

:*

 #""

"#"#3 #'"#::'## - 3"# #"

$## $#"* '# $' ""#' ' $#  $#

"*.

$ .# -*#"#--##*' ##*'"#- 





&)

#'*' #"#



$  . "66'*' #-#   *#"' $$ ."#

 7 8  - , + 1 $'  $#"# -"# $- *# "$#3 

$$- "#' # &   #) ## . /## * $#' ##"#*

 '::'".'+#'##'"#::-'#"+*"#*#*-#

-#- 



  $

 7  - ,3  #  #  $#* "*. # 

"$$*'  # "# ##3     #* $# 

-*#  #  #* "# $.3 "# #  :" # , +$  -

+#"#1+$ 

7,-,3# # #*"$$'$+$ # ##

'  # "# $- # .$-# .  # $#"# $- # 

+#*'' *#*- -*# #  3 "# #* +663 ' $#

#*'. ' #*'"##-  #'#

7  $  $#"# +66*' " # #  * #*'

 $#*"*.3##$##.$-""-*+#"

*$'9

7,,,#



 * ##-# ,   &. * 11,) #'*'3  #

$#"#-#**#"$#3$#"#*##""##+#.

+$.###'3$## # #"#*'.#'

' $' $. . ''  #  $# "*. 

$#"#



 #3  # # #*  7 8 -  +' ,3 3 1 .  $' $$

$#"#-"#+"##*-#*'.#'3## $$$#78-,

+1"$-#'$..



%3#-*''9

71-.78-,+1$#3

78$'-"#$..:*'*'$#"#&"*

$#)3 ##  #-- "  7  .  9

 7 ,, $'

*'# '"# #*##* *#*- $$ &'#-#"#) 

 #$#"#-"#"" $$#"#'-

*-#$#"#-3 #$#"#"##-"

 " * #* -*' " '* .   <# 9##-#

+#'7,,.,1-$-

*$#"#*"66'*'78-,+$'$-*#*-+' '

78-+',331.$'.'3$#'

$#"#'$#"*'+'$#"#-"#



!"#$#

*#