Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-11608\2 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's right to work permit. Appeal failed due to lack of evidence proving the applicant's specific need for employment.

Case Number 1-07-11608\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Viru County Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative authority's refusal to grant a work permit. The applicant argued that their specific professional skills and the local labor market conditions necessitated the permit, while the authority cited insufficient documentation of these needs. The court ruled that the burden of proof rested on the applicant to demonstrate a concrete necessity, which they failed to do.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

AsylG 2005 s. 10; s. 11: An asylum seeker must substantiate the specific necessity for a work permit by providing concrete evidence of their professional qualifications and the lack of alternative employment opportunities in the host country.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum seeker work permit burden of proof administrative labor market conditions professional qualifications evidence employment necessity standard

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AsylG 2005 s. 10
AsylG 2005 s. 11

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







 

  











 

  



    !"#$! ##  ! 







#$!







 %

 

%







&" '( )

!!  &!! # ! 

#!*







+! 









 & 





,

-,.

. # ,(! 

!  , !  #$! !

  /, #$! &   

 !   #!  

 ! 

!-! 

  &



.01.

.0).2'

 !##-

34 4 5'

-! 

'

#-#

- ! '

 $-! '  !#$ 6666' #$ 6666' ,   

 #   !-7 8

39%%



!"#$!## :4  &%,-! #! 



  3 &' 8 9%%



!"#$!## : 3 &%

$$,3##

'38  !"#$!## : &%$  

 !  3 ##

' 58     ! "#$! ##   :   &% 3 

,

 !  

      &' ,%%!- # 

      !- 3



# '$ ! ,



!- '



;;- !  : &%



- .,

  ;;-     ' '  54!6666& &

&!! ,&! 

-   !   "<  ! ( !- , !-# !'  

( 



 #-!, &!!  '($&! - 



! =;;   , !



 -  .,

 '   

     & !! , ! ($&! 

!- $  

,%%#$   '

# : &%, = ,!#



;;- ,' ;;- , &&#!*,$  ( !-#! #$  #



- .,

   ( ,  !  : &%3!!-,

 ! :

4   !   !!

-- ! !"#$!/,#$! &##    

( !-  !  %

-  #  #  !!- ,

 !  ,( &  !  

(   >!! 8 !!- ,

 !   :     !   ,  ! & $! 

 ,

 !   ,!- 

 ' # 3 ># 8 %, ,

 !  

-   

!! ! 4 !!- &  %, ,

 !  -  .,

   ! &  !   !-

   :   !    

-- ,

 !  3 >#  & !!;

8 !



; - ! !'   ,( $3%,$!

-' ( ! !

--,! &%%

345 !

- ;$ #

- !   ! ! - ? - ! !     &  %% 4

>,  8

!!-

? - ! !



  

& 

 !-

- 

.,

 

 

 $## -&%!  #

#  &#$! --; - ! !  & 

&% :4 ##-!-%!  #

# 

(!--:4   & !  

#$! - -  .,

   ,   #$#  &

##! 



 #   

#  #  



;;- ,- .,

 #

#!  ! 

!-&

(! !   





#!  !   ($&   #$!  &% -! '  ;;- , -  .,

  #



#!  ( -  ,% &

-

!- #  (   $ &  

  & 

     #



&%!- 

 ! &#!  

 ! ! ,- %-



- .,

 !  ;;-!

 -: &%



 (   ! , , 

#!  



": 44   % ' ;;- ( ,#$!# !  

 !  $ ,%$

-

#$! ":  % !- !

-$ !!! '!- #$ !## ,(

#$!  ' ;;- , - .,

  ,% & ( , !

-$ !!! ,(

,%$

--# 

-!,(



 , $ !-# 



9%$!-  ##-! &&!$

-!- ": 3@ 5' 4A

 44'3'3'33'34'

3'3#$! 



# !  7



;;-!

 -.01..0).: &%



 !   ( 3># 8

!!-,

 ! 



 : 4    !   !!

-- ( !-  !  ! "#$!    

#$!# ! &% ( !- ! %

- # 3># 8!!-,

 ! ,(





.01..0).2  !   ( >!! 8!!-,

 ! 



:  !  , ,

 ! 

 ' #3%, ! &$! 

.01..0).2 !! !%

-   4>, 8!!-& %,,

 ! 



 :   !    

-- -  .,

   ( !- ,

 !  345 >#  &

,;



 &8!

; - ! !? - ! !  %$&  %%

4 >,  8 !!- ? - ! !     &   !- -  .,

 

 

 $## -&%!  #

#  &#$! --; - ! !  & 

&% :4 ##-!-#

#

(!--7

8   #$! %%!-     !#$ 6666B

8  !   

 $## -& %%!- &,$  &%   

 $## -! # #

-

    B

38  !  

 $## -&#

#  #  !#$ 



   

- -# 

#$! ! %  & ! ,$

-#$B

58   

 $## -!  

! 

, # !#$  $!   !  !

, ;

 %, B

48    

 $## -!  

!  

, #  !

' 

 ,( (  #$

,$   



:4    !  #$! -- .,

 ; - ! !  &  

,  #$# &

##! 



 : 4      !   #$! - -  .,

  ; - ! !     & 

#    #  #  





- .,

 , - !

   ,$ 



" : 4    '     ' 44    !   ,% & (  -  .,

  



 ! ! !

 !

-$3># !$!! -8##

! !- 



% & (   ,   -!- ,$

- ,  ? .-,#-;## 

#

C - D$ - > !#$ /, 9- 8  !  3 >  !$ ;$  -

!! ; 

-$ ##

&3 

' $#

%  E' #54 ##

8

##

 ,

-,  .

 .  ##  %%!- #  ;;- , -  .,

 

 &

# !!-(!  



":4 5 !  ,% & ( - .,

   

 ! ! !

 & !

3 >  !$ ;$  - !! ; 

- $  ##

 & 3 

8 ##



! !- 

,

-,



.



. 

#$! ! 

 

 

 !  

,  !  &   #     



- .,

   !-,% & ( !- ! -/$

-! 

 ! , -! , 

F   ?$ 

 

  35 ,( 



 

  3

" # -!   %- ,

!  5



  !  "

 ! ! !-

 !- 3 %, &## !  % # , #$!# !  &(! !    ,  ! $  -

(!-- #  %  ! !   %$    !!-' !!

 

(!-- % 

 ! 

%,   #$!%! % 

 !  -! !  % !-# 



#$!# !    #

 #$! 

 !  ##   (!   -   ##

 !

/

#

#$!  ! "#$! !-! ;

  #!  

 !  ! ,

% !   #   .  ##

(!   !   ##,    !

"#$!  & !    %, &## ! '    #$!# !  !! !   

.  ##

  !"#$! & ! , ;

%,&## ! '  

%, '  #$! 

 ! ##  #

,(  #$! !,!-#$!# ! 



#$!

 





G G







%

 



(

)## =

















0H# !,



#$!# ! &(! ! 

 



)## =

















0H# !,