Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-3587\3 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement of administrative fines for illegal hunting, ruling the fines were not imposed by the competent authority.

Case Number 4-07-3587\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement proceedings against the defendant for administrative fines totaling 1,000, 2,000, and 3,000 kroons. The plaintiff argued that the fines were legally imposed for illegal hunting, while the defendant contended that the fines were not issued by the competent authority. The court ruled that since the fines were not imposed by the proper authority, they could not be enforced.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act; s. 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act: Administrative fines not imposed by the competent authority cannot be enforced.

Keywords

AI generated
administrative procedure enforcement proceedings illegal hunting competent authority administrative fines

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









   

 









 







 

 !



  







 

"#$%& '&





( )&&*+# +,





 

 

(   ! *#  '&#$#-# # .#$&# 

'%&!$&-#



 



/ ".#*'&$#-# ( ##'&$&##$&# 0'-#!+

// ! &#&.#1#&2//22#) *&#&$&#0-

2,$&#*!&/-&3&#-*$&#4

/ ! &#&.#1#&/222#) *&#&$&#0-

,$&#*!&/-&&#-*$&#4

/ ! &#&.#1#&/222#) *&#&$&#0-

,$&#*!&/-&&#-*$&#4

/ ! &#&.#1#&/222#) *&#&$&#0-

/,$&#*!&-&&#-*$&#4

/ ! &#&.#1#&/2/222#) *&#&$&#0-

/,$&#*!&-&&#-*$&#



 $'''&5 0( 









 



''#.# #!&%#&*$''#%#  !$0 #/.'#!

0  ## ##*$&#



!





5! *# #  - '& 5   .   * '&#$#-# #* (   #





),

0'-#!# ! &#&.#1#&#'&$&#+2%&/22#-2

$&#*!&/-&&#-*$&#4!##%&/222#-

$&#* !& / -& &#-*$&#4  !##%& /222  # - 

$&#* !& / -& &#-*$&#4  $'& /222  # - /

$&#* !&  -& &#-*$&# 0 /2 0 & /222  # - /

$&#*!&-&&#-*$&#



(    #% '&#$#-# # .#$& # '&$&# #$&# 4 - #

'&$&#-$66*-* &#*&) ,7 /.'#*'#



    

 



'& 5   #&%4 # ## $'&* # '&$&-# #&  # #-*4 - #

-*'&$&- *#*#'#*'00 4#--#/$66*$&

!' &#$#-# #0#0$&

#'&$&##$&-# .#%&### &

'&*#!&&$&# $&## ## #-#-2-*'&$&# ( //222

 $&-*! $$$&# #..#0-*!&-&4$&

8 #0''-*!&$$$0'$&-##-*%! #&*$&&#'&$&#) 

//,



 "#







(''#$#-# # #*& )( , 7 /  / '#%4 # '# #! .#8&

# ##&$ 8&$#* -&- $* !' &# $#-# #0 #-*& !&  #-*&

'&$&# & $-#!* #*0#%# #* #-*% #-*&#&-*!&!' &-#

$#-# #0 !& #-*& !&  #-*& '&$&# # .66-* !' &-# $#-# #0 !&

$ -& $ $''# $#-#  && # $ &0 &

$#-# #

'&#$#-# ##*&) ,7 '#%4#!&'&$&##$&#

'&#$#-# # .#$&#  # - '&& !& ! -& ! *# #-*$&# 

#*'&$&-&$''



5! *# # &* # )  ,0 '&& !# -'%4 #  !

 &#&.#1#&#*0&*0-#-*#'&$&# &'&#$#-# 0'$&# +



2//22   *&#&$&# 0  - 2 0 //22  0

'&#$#-#  &///229



/222    *&#&$&# 0  -  0 /222  0

'&#$#-#  &/2/2229



/222    *&#&$&# 0  -  0 2/222  0

'&#$#-#  &//2229



/222    *&#&$&# 0  - / 0 /222  0

'&#$#-#  &/2229



/2/222 *&#&$&#0-/0/2220

'&#$#-#  &/2/222







),

# 0$&# 0 '&$&# # .66$&# 0  #&-*  *&#&$&#

#*& ) :, 7  #  #&  -*  *& '&$&# #4 & #* #&  #

'&$&# #.66*0 # ###$&#.'#!!#

- #* .66& '&$&# # : 7  '#* '0 0 4 && -

'&#$#-# # $&-#-#-*#'&$&#&$-*#* & 



/20&*( 0 

( 7 '#%4# #-*&#&.66'&$&# ##'&*#4&-$66*-*

 7  / .  '#* '# 0 !' &# $#-# #0 # !& #

'&$&# #.66$&#& ##*& 8*

'&#$#-# # #*& )#*.&*& ,7 /#  .## '&#$#-# 

!''# 0 #* !' &# $#-# #0 # !& #  #  $''*

!& &#-*# '&$&# #$&# 4 & !& #&  # &# -*

&#*&7'#*'00 

7 /.)-&/#&-*#*&-,'#4##&

'&$4&!''##0$&#-$66*-*8 #&! 7 /.

# #&'&$4&!''##*#0$&#-$66*-*

##&*



 #&% ## $'&* #*# '#&*  #-**#4 #  .' /2  -

#*-*0#&-*-&&#'&$&# #.66$&&# #'&$&4&*-88*-# # 

'#*## *4# #-*&#&'&*#4&-$66*-* 7 /.'#*

'#4!&!' &#$#-# #0#!&#'&$&# #.66$&#& #

#*& 8*



-88* &&#--#/4&& #%!''##'&$&##$&#

 ** -& /   7 / . '#* '#!!   7 

&# #



5!#*# 0 4 #  !  &#&.#1#& ## $'&* # 0$&# -

$66*-* 7 /.'#*'#-&-.*!* 7 &#

'#* # '&$&# #$&# .#$& &-&!* 0 *4 && #&% 4 #

!! ( 7 &# #--*#'&$&-##-*

(  7 2   #  - !&* #-*& #&-* $#-# #0  & $ $''#

!&'&$&# #.66$&-##*& 8;'# & #&'#-*! -&//222

 $&*!&.#&*& &#$&# #.#0!& &-#$&-##

-2'&$&##$&#.#$& 7 .$#

5-*0 *#&'#-*#-2'&$&##$&#.#$&##! -&

! #&*$&# # **&#-*$&#!&$&#4-!&

$&#! #&*$&-##&#&-#*8-#!&$$$&#$&#4!&*# #

  #%$&88* #&&!###!4$&##%!&$'&& '&#$#-# #

#*&'#*$##$#&**#'&!' &#$#-# #0

'# #! 0 #& #! -&$& #&&-*!&&#-*$&#! #

&*-*!&$&#( -&-# -*$0-*#'&$&#

0 $&# #.#-&-&







),

'# #! 0 $66*-* 8 # #  -&$#* !''## 0$&#

 7    / .  '#* # '&$&# #$&# '# ##-&% ##$'&4 #

!''## $&#* &# )  !&, &&# 0 #1#&&!-# '&*#!&&$&-#

! *88* # #$0#*.&*&#&*$&#88#*#&$#.-#$&-&-&#

##&!#



# # # # '#%  7   /4 # &  !& !' &-# $#-# #0 #&  #

$''-* !& $& &&4 # ! #!&- '& --%

! -& # !& #!&- $&# '04 $& #&  # 8#$ & / .'#! #

.&#$&.'#!

7/ /# 4&!&#!&-$''*'.'#!#&!&&

* !& $&# '# #& 0'& 0 !& '&$&# '# #&  #

.&#-** -&- ! -&  #&  # !4 $& # # &#-# .664 *% '&

&#-*0 # ! *#!&#-*$&##&!! &#*&

7  '# # # '&$&# # .66-* $ # !& & # - #&-*

!' &-#$#-# #04&&'&&0'# #$ #$-#.&$#

-'#*( 7/// &#



 - &&& /  # )0 - /, #&*-*4 # &#

'&$&## &-##-&%##$'&4##'&$&-##&&$#%$& & .&0

.'0&& #&* 4'&&! &!&$#&-*0#&*

#*# '#* '0 0   **  !& !' &# $#-# #0 #

'&$&



 #&%4 # & #& #&-#  7    .*# /4 4  0  '#* !''##

'&$&##$&#.#$&&-&-*0 &*4&& #%!''#'& 7 /

.$'&*'00 



; 4& #-**( 7 0 7 /.'#$ !&&& 

- #* - #&-* '& )  7  '#* #$&'0 0   #%

8-# *-*'&$&,4&&&#$# 70( 7//

'#*#-*&# *$&#&-&&--&-'#-*!''##'&$&#

!&$ &#$ 4-&88* #$-& $## #- &-# #-*

$## #! *-#0! <#&(%&&&.&#*#7//0/ '#



-#'&$&#-$66*-* 7 /.'#*'#-&-.*!*

 7    .*# /4 4  0  '#* 0 *4 ##  #% ## '& #*  !

 &#&.#1#& # '&$&#  * '&$#-#  .#* '&$&# #$&#









"#$%& '&

-&