Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-6580\7 AI generated

Court finds defendant criminally responsible for assault while mentally ill and orders compulsory psychiatric treatment.

Case Number 1-07-6580\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court found the defendant criminally responsible for an assault committed while in a state of mental illness. Although the defendant argued for exemption due to mental incapacity, the court determined the illness did not negate criminal responsibility. Consequently, the criminal proceedings were terminated, but compulsory psychiatric treatment was mandated under the relevant penal code provisions.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

KarS § 122; KarMS § 400, 402: A person who commits a crime while mentally ill remains criminally responsible if the illness does not preclude understanding the nature of the act or controlling their behavior, resulting in the termination of criminal proceedings and the imposition of compulsory psychiatric treatment.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal responsibility mental illness defense compulsory psychiatric treatment assault charge termination of criminal proceedings

Cited Legislation

AI generated
KarS § 122
Xxxi, eluneva xxx, isikukood xxx, pensionäri, varem kohtulikult karistamata, süüdistuses KarS § 122 järgi ettenähtud õigusvastase teo toimepanemises.
KarMS § 400
KarMS § 402

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Tõlge

29.06.2007.a Kriminaalasi nr 1-07-6580

K O H T U M Ä Ä R U S resolutiivosa

29.juunil 2007.a Viru Maakohus koosseisus: kohtunik R.Minzatov, sekretär A.Kuzmina, prokuröri K.Rostovtsevi ja kaitsja J.Jevšina osavõtul, arutas avalikul kohtuistungil kriminaalasja

Xxxi, eluneva xxx, isikukood xxx, pensionäri, varem kohtulikult karistamata, süüdistuses KarS § 122 järgi ettenähtud õigusvastase teo toimepanemises.

KrMS §-de 400, 402 alusel kohus

m ä ä r a s:

Tunnistada, et Xxx pani õigusvastase teo KarS § 122 järgi toime süüdimatus seisundis. Kriminaalasi lõpetada. Kohaldada Xxxi suhtes sundkorras psühhiaatrilist ravi. Kohtukulud jätta riigi kanda.

Määruse peale võib edasi kaevata Viru Maakohtule 10-päevase tähtaja jooksul.

Kohtunik R.Minzatov

Tõlge õige

Aili Hirt Tõlk