Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-7422\7 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation of foreign national based on public order grounds.

Case Number 1-07-7422\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative decision to deport them to their country of origin. The applicant argued that deportation would violate their right to private and family life, citing the lack of alternative residence options. The court rejected these claims, finding that the applicant failed to demonstrate sufficient personal ties to Estonia or compelling reasons to stay, thus upholding the deportation order as necessary for public order.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 12 ust. 1 k.r.s.: The court may order deportation of a foreign national if they pose a danger to public order, provided the individual cannot demonstrate sufficient personal ties to the host country or compelling reasons to remain.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order public order grounds right to private life foreign national status administrative appeal family ties assessment procedural review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 12 ust. 1 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









    

 







 !"

 







 

#$%&$ '()!*

 







+#,,-

 



.""/% 

!! & 0/1 /*' &0.2 .*  .* '

& 203 & 

   



 

( .4&

   

 

5$%&$ '()!*

   





!/ !/& (4*. !/0 %  $% $ 

044"* !"/ 0"."/..&20".!/ 

 





 



 6 /

!/& (4*.

"  

. "% 2.67 &



   

 ""& /18"9 .:$2./".0;.:#$ '"2

,#:' .&!/ <<<<<< ==' <<<<<<

<<<<<' 2 2""./ ' .".! 2"' .0 ..& 8

*.. ..&' /77!/ > 2.0 ' * .0 !/&&/

 "/ /2

 

 2. 2* /..?&/1.*+044 /2 "-

   



 6 /

!/& (4*.

"  

%!/*67@& &  ! 00" 



 

.9&

 !"#$

%&   '( 

 

%)&)+&

  



 , 

 -      '( 

 



 -    . 

 

  

 &

2 " .; 0".2







 -    







&



(  @% 

  



%& ""& /1 !/&"/ / * "/"". 2"/+.2 "62 -A,'A:'AB&

%4 0 & "% "' 0&&." &"/ / 0../&"/   A , %  A : /"/.& ".&&."' ./

$2./".0;& #$ "/ &' .&&  $, 6  /0" !/& (4*.& !/0. 0/  %."

/&"/ 0.'0&&./&.0". &./" $($ ! & ""./0./ /

$$$

%&%& 0/ ""& /1 !/&"/ / * AB&%4'"$$/&.&* .; ". 2"&"

4/&.0"."$



)&  6 / !/& (4*. "   . "% 2. 67  & +&$-

."/ " $%& $ "/ & 0 !/&. * !"/ 0"/ /&".  !/&"/ / *   ""&  /1

* !"/ 0"."$









+5-



)&%& !"/ 0"/ /&"."04". "% 2.67'./." &".&/&4."&.* "0 & "% "

 !/&"/ / * " /"/ /2  ""&  /1 ; "  ($$' ." 2" 9/&"' ./ /  /&"/ "

..". /"."$

../&". 4" 044 / 2  ."6./".' 0&&. /&.0".2 &9 * 2 90;. ($$ 9/&".2$

4."&.* " % "!/..&".0.*..22'./($$.&2/&"/ % "'* 2)) "

. "/'./* ; "/ 2 * "//"."/&4!.2 "/"/$

)&)& !/&"/ / *  ""&  /1  0 & "  "/ /2 "! 5$ 6&& ::$  2 

!/6&/0 &2."+.2 "62-A&'A&,6,'A&'A5

%4* ; 2". /". "./". "/ /$

 ""& /1"!/."

%

!/" "/ 0".&0 & "."/ /2

"992"/".&.  ""&  /1 % 

$$' ."  0 & "% "  #,,   / 

"/ /"."'"2"2*4* &2  "/ 2."/"/ % / 20 * &.9/&"$

)&)&%&?. &.".&&.?)!% ?&/".6.C./0../&"."0 & "#,'"

 ""&  /1&.  ."/ /2  !/&"   A  &  %4$ " "  

 6 / 0../&"." !/"". " /0"." 0 & "  55:' "

 ""& /1&.."/ /2 !/&"/".&0"./0.6 .0".""."& /"."$

)&)&)& ""&  /1  !/&"/ / ".  ."0.".    /.". "/0. /. /0.6 .0"."$

 ""& /1* .0 "/ /2"* "/ "././0.6 .0"..."/$ .0 "!/."

6&/".' 6 / %  !/ 0../&"." *..& 0 & "% ' 0" 4/ ;' ./  ""&  /1

%4/ "..* /&/.2./0.6 .0"/'"%.""992"/" A,,%44!/;'./

 ""& /1&.0 ./"/ % /.0)%/ 0.$"% &'./." &".&/&0 & "% "

#,, !/&"/ / * " ""& /1 ; " '4/ ;'./ ""& /16&/

*)0 & /"/ %  %    /  0)%/ 0. %  )".0)"/0"/  !%"/ *  &.66.

")&00.$.. &.0 "* !"/ 0". &" /.2.%4/*/0.6 .0.$

  992"."   ""&  /1 "/ /" /"/ % "/ 0/2  !/&"/ / * " 0.".

/ 60"."' ""  &"/ * / ' ./  ""&  /1  "/".  /"." *); !22  0"."/

)* &.$



/&

!/ !/& (4*. !/0 %  $% $  044".  !" ..&2"

 !/&"/ / *   ""&  /1 * !"/ 0"."/ +&$-' &.2."' ./  ""&  /1 6../ 

$%& $ "/ & .&& ,$ && "' ! /  &0" 0../&.%  /.&.C /..& ."/ /2

/".&$  "% 2. 67 * !"/ 0"/ /&"." . &0.  !/&"/" ".&&. !/ ' 0" &."

9&& &2 ".&/6)!%.2 /2 &"."'./ ""& /1!2;.2 "620"."/)* &.$

/&%& "% 2.67* !"/ 0"/ /&"."" &2 9!/.6)!%.2 /2/. !/&"/ ""&

 /1!/ .  * !"/ 0". &"/'"."."/.0 &.."/ /2 !/&"/.  A,'A:

% AB&%4$

 !"/ 0"/ /&"."/ . &0.' ./  ""&  /1 "!/." & ! &2 /2 ..&.* &/ ..0

/).2'02 / &"2$ 0/.4!// /&"."/'0" "% &2.&.&.6)!%.2 /2

..0  /).2 ."0 . ! &2 0.$ .&0"!/ &. ;' ./ *2 /." /."/.&.

" 0 ."./.&. 0 &0../&"/.&.  ""&  /1 "!/." * !"/ 0". &".  . &. "..

9&& &2 ".&/ 6)!%.2 /2' "."/ ..&0./ /2 0 &0../&"." . &. 6../2 * % &"

! &2 2  ""& /1"!/."/).2/* !"/ 0.$

/&)& !"/ 0"/ /&"." . &. *2 /2' ./  /2 /).2.2  ""&  /1 6&/

/"/ %  %    /  0)%/ 0". !/  )".0)"/0"/  !%"/ *  &.66.

")&00". $ ..  ..&0"!/ 04"' ./ * !"/ 0"/ /&"  ""&  /1&.

0../ * /. ."0.". %  /.". "/0. /.2. /0.6 .0"."  !/&"/ / *  "!/."

/).2 * !"/ 0. ! &2 0"."  ."/ /2 6)!%.2 0 / %  . /. * !"/ 0".

&"/.&.$

!/&. ."/ /2 /2 /).2/. 0"/ . &0. 9&& &2 ".&/ 6)!%.2 /2

/. !/&"".&&."'./ ""& /16 /0./.0 &.0../ * 2/.2% "."."









+5-

,

".&&. .&. 9&& &2 ".&/4."&.* & % &6)!%.2 /2 &"."'./! &2 2  ""& /1

"!/."/).2 * !"/ 0"/$

/&/& 0/ 6. ; ..&0"!/ * % &" )!/ 2 ' ./ 0 &0../&"/ &"/ /

$2./".0;& #$ "/ & %  0 & "%  0../&"  ."/2 %;  "./". 2$ $%&

$ "/ &."/ /0 !/&.0 & "% 0 /.% &2&0 /)&./ '*....&"."4.% "% 

0 !/&.  "."/ " 2 * &/ %/ /2 /."/ ' "$$ 0 &0../&". ". 2"/

+.2 "62

-A&,0". $



   





0&

!/ !/& (4*. !/0 %  $% $  !/044". 6. &. ."/ " 

 6 / !/& (4*. "   . "% 2. 67  & +&$-

044" .;".' 0&&." 6 &; /9!"/ 2  0 !/ 044" %  * !"/ 2   !/&"/ / *  ""&

 /1$

0&%& "% 2.

67

./;'

./

0 & "% 



#,,

0../&.;

2 

?&/".6.C./ 0 &"    "../2 /..*". / &/" "!   ()!*"'

0""..."."/.*4&"/ './"6../ ".0./ /2/ &/".6&/*4&% "6&()!*& '

2 /2 "% "6../ ""& /1$%&$ "/ &$

?)!% ?&/".6.C./0../&"."&.* " "% "#,/."/ / ""& /1 

0../&"/02 6&&"$ %"$ .&./.2  && "6../2$

0&)&

!" "" "."! &.' ./ /0"/ . 4!/ 9&& &2 ".&/ 6)!%.2 /2

/. !/&"  ""&  /1 " " .  )".0)"/0"/  !%"/ *  &.66. ")&00".

*)0 &"$ "% 2.67.)"/".&&. $

/. !/&". &"." 4."&.* & % &  ""&  /1 " " D " !/ "/&

."6./" /'& "%44."6./" /55#E##5,'/&.&* ."6./" /

,#E##:' @ ."6./" /  #5#E##B' 0.2/"&"0 &"/&".

."6./" /  ' 990". /"/ %  ( 64.* 9&.& 0". 6/&&$ 0./ /2

/).22././ ($$' ""& /1% 

$$9/&"'0"4/ ;'./)".0)"/0"/ !%"/ *

&.66. & ")&0/2 !.".&/ 6. &. /&"/ 0". /00"/ .."04  * ; "/ 2 

* "//"."//..&/&"/ % $

?. &. ".&&.   ""&  /1 "!/."

%

!/" / 0".& 0 & "  

"992"/"."   A ,, %4' 0"  ; &"/ * / './/."."0)%/ 0. ""&

 /1 6!& 6.0 ...&  . 2$

../&". 4" *); *..& /* "/ 2  "2' ."

/. * 2 /).2 0".".0. "% &"2' 0"/)//  * % & 6 /   !/&"/ / *  *)0 &" .2

4!* 2 2 *)0&*"&0)%/ 2 $

0&/&4."&.* "0 & "% ".62 2. "% 2.67*)0 &"! &2 2  ""&"

 /1&. ..0 / /).2/'   * .0 " %  *  * "/ "/. /.2. .."/

0 & " "/ /2 ""& /1"!/."6&/".'6 /% !/0../&"."

*..& &0 0 & "% ' 0" 4/ ;' ./  ""&"  /1 %4/; /.2. /0.6 .0"/$

4!/2." "% &"/'./4."&.* "0 & "% "."/ /2 !/&"/"). ".0' &"/

* / ' ./  !/&"/ / * *);  "/". !0" !  /  0 &0../&"."/ )* &. !20 $

4."&.* "0 & "% "."/ /2 !/&"/". "" &;9&. "% &'./ ""& /1

". /"/ %  "/ /"." &.*   *) 0)." /."." 0 & "% "  !/&"/ / *   *)

"992"/ / *  0../&.% &.4//." 2 *&2$

0&1& 0" &.* 2 ."6./" /2  .."/..&".2 %  *....&".2 .."/..&". /)&. $

"/. 9&.& 0". 6/&&2 %  0 /0 0 /.% &  * &2 * &/ *.. ..&."

*0"/ /2 %  % & /)&./ .."/ ..&2. . &. *..& /  /2' 2 . "% 2. 67

* /.". ".2 "../0 //*0"/$

!/$%$ 044"."/.&.

*4&% '0"". ../. 20./' 0&&. 0 !""*2//*2 '%442

0 !/&. " 0 /"$









+5-





+& !/ "/& / /&." %!/* 67 @& &  ! 00"  0 !/

044"./9!"/ 0"/% /).2* !"/ 0.! &2 0"/$

+&%& /"% * 2. 2* / .. ?&/1.* %   !/&"/ / *  ""&  /1 6 &"2 %4// 

0 !/044"0/0 / . "% 2.67044" .;" !&2 0 / $





 

 





2& !/. &0.&0.&. ""." + !"-' & 2 4   /"% '

%!/*67' !/&"/ / * "."! '//*2044" .;".% * !"/ 0"/0

0 & "%   #,, 0 /.% &2. ' &. ;' ./ 044" .;"  6)!%.2 0 /'

 !&2 0".&..&% 0 !/044"/&.;%4// 0/0 / ".&&."/226)!%.2"/.&'

0&&".2  !" . 6.  * % &" 9&.  /  * "/ * &/  0 &0../&".

". 2"/+.2 "62

-AA2.&.,:&',&,6$

..2 "% &2'0"04/2044" .;"." !/&"/ / *  ""& /1* !"/ 0"."'

 00.2 * &/90;.&9 /20 !/6&/'"$$0 !/044". '0&&. ..&2/

 !/&"/ / *   ""&  /1 * !"/ 0"."/$  0/  0 !" 6" *  6)!% &". 

 &99"2  * !"/ 0". &".2' "$$ * !"/ 0" &".     !/&". &.0 "&$

 !" )"/; 0 !/ 6)!%.2"/. %  %4.&2"/. ' "."/ ..2 * "/ * 2

C /&"/.&. "% &2.&.$



3&

!/&. ."/ /2  ""&  /1 * !"/ 0"/ /&"."/ +&$' ,,,5- 4!/* &/ 6. ;

. "% 2. 67 *)0 &"' ./  ""&  /1 *); * ; 2"." %4/* &/ /0. 6  

 ".2/."2+ 4."&.* &!./.& !/&"/ / "./.2 ".&&"./0.6 .0"."-

*);!  / !4*/ 0 /).2.2'6 ."".&&. /0."/."2$ " 0/ ".2 './

/ *); "/".!0"!  / 0 &0../&"."/)* &.!20 / "/ 0 ".&&. 

!/..&".0../&".&4;*0"/$.&&"/"."!/ 6)!%.2 / ".* .067/ /&"."

..&).".&&. './ ""& /16&//0.6 22%  "/"". 2"/+.2 "62 -A

,%4* &C/"../ */. ".."0.". "/0./.'0&&..."/.//.4!/2

 "/"."6 % &.* "/"$



3&."/  ;  ?)!". 2". A  &0 2  6/ ! ".&/ *); * ; 2". *)//  &/

". 2"." "4/."/ /2 %!/2.& %   "D /. *) ! &2")".0". 4 !20"."'

".&&".")".0"."6)!%.2 /&/ !/&"/ / * /0./ 0"."642.*  .//.*)

/.0 6 0.*4&/0"."$



 A , &  ! ".&/ *);  !/&"/ / *  *) "992"/ / *  * !"/ 2 '  /  *);

0 &0../&"."/)* &.!22 *)%4/* &//0.6  /."2$

3&%&6  0)"/. *./" +.2 "62  - /.& 5 6"/ F /&..* &/ 6. ;

.&&. * !"/ 0"." &.0  6)!%.2 /2 * !"/" &". &.0 "&$ .. /4!.2 ;' ./

* !"/ 0"/ /&"."/&.;&" "* !"/ 0" &".4 4/ 0".&. &%!& ".&/ 2 '0"

*);  !/&"/ / *  " 6  0  *) %4/ /  /.2. /0.6 .0"/$  !"

""/;0 !/%4.&2". './. "% 2.67* !"/ 0"/ /&"."/.&0. !/&"/"

".&&. !/ ' 0" &." 9&& &2 ".&/ 6)!%.2 /2 &"."' ./  ""&  /1 !2; .2 "62

0"."/)* &.$

 "/62".&/044" .;".&.&. ; !"'./. "% 2.67%4.&2".* "/ 

C /&"/.&. "% &2.&.$ /2 0 & "%  %  044" .;". 0 /.% &2."/ /&..;' ./

/.&.C/..&/"0".& !/&"/ / *&0"!.0../&.% %2.$&29!/.%!"/'./

 !/&"/ / *.&."&020../&.% %2.*)!/"".$ !"/ 0"044"."04/2

* !"/ 0" &"'./ ""& /1*);!22 0 &0../&"."/)* &.'0 ;&./ / * /









+5-

".&0$ ?)!%.2 /2  !/&" 6. ; /.0  ../".&. C0 /"&.' "..  

/..0"/&  '". "% 2.67%4//"0./ /2* !"/ 0". &".&0 C /&"/.

6)!%.2"/./ $ +/ !/ 0 &&&..0 044".2  ,:' $04"/

::$ '6,% ,5'B$04/"$ G '',-$



%*& !"04;'./ 9""992"/". """..."."/.&. &"6 % &"."

* !"/ 0"."% .&.9!/& " 

A,&%4* !"/ 0". &"."'* 2/).2

! &2 0".& /&.; *."". *)//  *)0 &  "/".  ""/ %  ) 

 A  &" 

"4/."/ /2/).2* &0"."."! &//4!/" 2 "% &"2$

 !" 04;' ./ * !"/ 0".  /).2 /""/ 0".&  * % & /* "/ 2 

6)!%.2 /2

/. !/&".

% 

* !"/ 0" &".

&.0 "&

+/

!/

0 &&&..0044",,#'$2./".0;.#$ '6:-$.&6&*2 /2

!/044".! ".&/6)!%.2 /2/. !/&"."/* !"/ 0"...&/0".0)//."

 &"/ 442  ""'  !" %) ; ".". !/..&". 0../&". /&.0"/. 6)!% &

*..20".&.' ./ ". /).4"".    !/&"/ / *  " /. /42.*%  *) ".&&."/

" *)/% $ /. !/&". 6)!%.2 /" 6. ; /.0  0 &/0 ../"./.&.

0 /.% &2.&.$ ?)!%.2 /2 /. !/&".  * !"/ 0". ..&/0". /* "/ 0. . &.

"". " && ""999"0".&)6&/""/ 0.$

/".6/..* " /&.; 62 2  ".2 ' ./  ""&  /1  !/&"/ / ". ."0.". "/0. /.

/0.6 .0"."+ A,-'"" /"4.;.//. "/". 6 &"/* "/"/$

" &".&/ & ). &"." 0 & "% "  !/&"/ / * "  ""&  /1 ; "  ($$' ."

/ "'.// &!42  /"."."2"'"../)///&"/ "..". /"."$

44" .;". / 0". % "  !/" 4."&.* " 0 & "% " %4 " 0 

/. !/&"' 0"  ."/ / 0 !/"".  ""&  /1 "!/." /).2 * &0".&$

2

/).2.2'0"&9 "290;.($$*."'.//&"/ % "&/.0 '  0//. ""& /1'

.&./4.2&". /* "/ /2$.. ' 0 !"' !"&. ;'./62;

 ""& /16&// !/&/ 60"./0.6 .0". !/&". &"$

0 & "  0../&"."  & /." $2./".0;"/ #$ "/ &$ .&&. 6.2 %"& 6&.

C /.'./ ""& /1&." * &2 20)%  / &.*)/"/ % /.&.$

 !"/ 0". &"'"$$/./.2./0.6 .0.'/".".&/"./2/. !/&". 

4."&.* "0 & "% "$

   !." !/" /* "/ /' ./ . "% 2. 67 * !"/ 0"/ /&" . "" &2  9!/.

6)!%.2 /2 /. !/&"/  ""&"  /1 !/ ' ""  *44 ./2 ' ./  !/&"/ / *

 ""& /1'*;2."* ; 2"."'*);6  /0."/."2$

 0/ "% &'./ ""& /1* .00 & " "/ /2'.  "..."."/ &"/

..&2"."'./* !"/ /6 ."/0."/."2$

.& "% &2.&/&.;0 !/044"%4// 0/0 / . "% 2.67044" .;"

%4//  !&2 0 / $



.&/2"/ /&..* &/ %  %!22." 

 AA2."/ ,: %  ,:' %4/ ;  !" 

!/  *  !/0 %  $2./".0; #$  044". 0/0 /  %  044" .;".

 !&2 0 / $







!! &0/1 /*



.* .*  





& 203 & 

!/







!/







!/