Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-1462\2 AI generated

Court dismissed asylum appeal regarding detention length exceeding statutory limits for asylum seekers.

Case Number 4-07-1462\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the asylum seeker's appeal against the decision to extend their detention beyond the statutory maximum period. The applicant argued that the continued detention violated their rights under the Asylum Act, while the authorities contended the extension was necessary for procedural reasons. The court ruled that the detention period had already exceeded the legal limit and ordered its immediate termination.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10(1) of the Asylum Act 2004; s. 10(2) of the Asylum Act 2004: Detention of an asylum seeker must not exceed the period specified in the Act, and any extension requires strict justification and adherence to statutory timeframes.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum seeker detention statutory time limit procedural necessity administrative appeal detention order

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10(1) of the Asylum Act 2004
s. 10(2) of the Asylum Act 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













 

 

    

 

























!"#$% 





    

!"#$%$ !"#$%$





&'(!%$ ) * %++,  )(!%$ ($(##

(%$ %!%+$ (-$$./#$

0(%$+$,""% ($1$#230445



- # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,







4,  (6%+-1







  



! $#& ,$1##(,7  8+$ 6+!&& /6$%& & '(!%$ ) * %++ 9 :$%((&

54 6+  .;6,< ,   )(!%$ ($(## (%$ %!%+$  (-$$ ./

#$0(%$+$,""% ($1$#230445($!$ !%! $#& ,$1##(,!%

!$$%+$ #1+6%-$;:+$ ++$",;%-$ ($$



."%% & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(## (%$ %!%+$  (-$$ ./

#$ 0 (%$+$ ,""% ($1$ #2 30445 -++%-% ($$4 -!! : -""%

! $#& ,$1##(,7!  !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  !+$ ! $%+$ $ 6%6, 5

%6,/6+ +!%+$ $4 $(  5 ((# 1 -""% !+$$ &+$  > 3 !:  !+$ !

$%+$ $6%6,3%6,/6++!%+$ $4$(0((#



& 



(6%+(%$+$  ) !  (# ;:+$ $%& $$%$((# :(6%+!  + (6%+ +&+ +

(6%+- # %!+$  )((! $((,8 $+%& $$%$((#;:+$%4 ) 8 % $ !! $% 1!+!% % %-

+ (6%+!   )" , 1(($+! !% $ (6%+(%$+$  % : -$ $% 1 $%- $$%$((# 

)" ,1(($+!$-$%1$%,% $ 

>33!:(6$ !%(#$$%$((# $%-$ ;:+$



- # %!+$!+$  $+ &,(&$% %$1!4 (6%+,"!$ ! - # %! 1! ,; % - &,(&$%

$#&1!



 ' (



%) & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(## (#$%8 ! ?-% ?!  (($%$

- # %!+$!+$ ! $+! ! $#& ,$1##(,! 3,""% ()(%((!!503

$ !! (6%4 %! $#& ,$1##(, !!""# +-(##$,  

!##$4!+& $!%%"#,!% !!##%"#,$++#$41+6%$-((%($;&+%1((8 $ $+#&$4

1+6%-$ ! $-":9@

$$ $;&+ !&A<#;+& &

!! :+$- # %!+$!+# $

! $#& ,$1##(,  >  ) 4 > 3 #;+& &4 -!!  $% (# ,$%+%+$ %%  #"6%+&

!+$$ &+$ >0!:1!+$$ &+$ >3!:



 # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,,""% ()(%((!!! ,$%+!+$ %  $%#+&



& '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(## (%$ %!%+$  (-$$ ./ #$

0 (%$+$ : ,""% ($1$ #2 30445 -""% - # %!+$!+$ !  $+! 

! $#& ,$1##(,!  !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  !+$ ! $%+$ $ 6%6, 5

%6,/6+ +!%+$ $4 $(  5 ((# 1 ,; % !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  !+$ !

!$$%+$ # " 1+6%-$;:+$  ++$ ##: -""% !+$$ &+$  > 3 !:  !+$ !

$%+$ $6%6, 3 %6,/6+ +!%+$ $4$( 0 ((#4 $ $% ! $#& ,$1##(,

  !!  ""# + -(##$ ,   !##$4 !+& $ !% %"#,!%

!!## %"#, $++#$4 1+6%$ -((%($;&+% !(6(!1((8 $4  %"%#+& !!+$-":

@

$$ $;&+ !&A#;+& &4+& $$ :>)4>3#;+& &



*)(6%+,"!$ - # %! 1(%$+$ ) !  $%$(6%+!  8+$ - # %!+$!+# $! $#&

,$1##(,



 # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,(- 8+$ $)!+8(6%+!%/6$%&(6%+,"!$ 

- # %! 1 (%$+$ !$$%+$  B -((%($;&+ 1+6%-$;:+$  ",;%-$  ($$4 $ $%

1+6%-$;:+$ $% !-1"%-#  )# $ % - )  (## ""-$ !% $ $$  -% !$ $$ 

(!+(&



 # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,-":8(- 8+$ $4 %% -/!!)&-$ !(#

% -! !# )( : 4$/#&#+&0004 &%$,%8/$4$ $%!)$  -

$+ # %!+$!+$ $+! $#& ,$1##(,,"% ! !8%(($!)$ :(-

,$1##(,(#%; #&#+&#- %%+&,"% &&(+- #%!$ !%



 # %!+$!+$ $+! $#& ,$1##(,$;#+! (! %!!!$%%CC&4+&#+!%%"#++%(

(! -$(!+!  ! 8 % 1+%$% %CC& ##: ,;8 (- % - 1 ! !$% )( : /!! )&&

 # %!+$!+#  $ ! $#& ,$1##(, ,"&84 % 1"%% $ % & !- 1+6!($%4 1""8 (:+

% - )   !%+$,6 #&% %  # %!+$!+#  $ ! $#& ,$1##(, !&84 % %!! 

-""%+& 6%6,& (+  ((# (# /!!!&$ !% #:  $%+$ % - )((!%

%(- )#&+& ,""% :+&  $%  # %!+$!+#  $ ! $#& ,$1##(, (-  8+$ $

-":84 % $((,($! &(6%+$%+#:!



+) & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(#& (- ,$%+$1$  (#

$ $+(6!4 % (-$$ ./ #$ )((!% 0 % 6%+& (%$+$ ,""% ($1$ #2

30445(#$ &+$!##:% 6%+&41":& $$%+$$ &+$%+:1,""% (- # %!+$ 



$ &+$%+: 6% $%%+&#(- &'(!%$ ) * %++,  )(!%$ ($(#&)!+81"%%

% 6%+& (%$+$ -++%-% & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(#& (6%+,"!$ 

- # %! 1# $((,#+&(6%+$%+#:$%($,;%%





, ,  &-.

'&/( &(



#)  # %! & $ ,""% ($1 (6%+,"!$  - # %! 1 (%$+$  ) !  $%%+&  8+$  !+$ ! 

(#%(!! -(6+$ /$# $ (6%+,"!$  - # %! 1 % : ,+$  ;:+$)"$+$% ,""% ($1

!6 #&-$ !4,&(#%(!!8(6%+,"!$ - # %! 1(%$+$ % : -$ !+$ $(!#+&*%!$

1;:+$! $1(!+$&



!+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  #" 8 %%  ,$%+%+$  -((%($;&+ ,; %-- 1+6%-$  $%

1((8 $ $+#&$  >  )  (6$ !%  %(6 1+6% (!! 1((8 $ $+#&$ .((8 $ $+#& (#

,$%,!%!+$$ &+$ >!:!(6(!4#((%!$ ,;)$/66(%(()$ # %,%-$ $%

);61+$%%+& % ,$ $ $+#&4 -$ ,!&+8 6"%+& ,; -++%+#+&  6!$% $ ,; )$//6!$% $

*+#%$((#& $ 1  %$((#& $ !+$$ &+$  >  !:  !+$ ! %(-+8 1((8 $ $+#&

%+,$%-# 4 1((8 $%-  -""-#  ##: 1((8 $%-  -""-$  (%$+$  ,&!+$%-# 

8:!%$+$ -""+$ :# 6% $%%+&@.((8 $ $+#&%+,$%-$ 1

1((8 $%-  -""-$  ##: 1((8 $%-  -""-$  (%$+$  ,&!+$%-$  (A 9 &$)&

.((8 $ $+#& %+,$%-$  (&< (6$ !% .((8 $ $+#& %+,$%-$  ( >  (6$ !%

,;,&1((8 $ $+#&%%+,$%&- %$1$%



!+$$ &+$  > 3 !:  #" 8 %%  ,$%+%+$  -((%($;&+ ,; %--1+6 )((!%

!!+$#;+ % +-$  $%>3$"% $%84 %!! 1) 81+6#&+-8:!%$+$ 

-""+$  #5@!+$ $A!$$1 !&%+& :+! 1-":+#& $%##:

%"%-  :+! 1 1 (#%(!!1 -++& !!+$!$% (!&+$%4 !!+$(!&+$,6 #& #;+ %

##:##)&-$;&+! 8:!%$+$ -""+$ #5@!+$ $A

!$$  %% #"6%+& %+##+$-"&  $+%-$  ($%  !+-"  @

$$ $;&+  !&A

%"6 #&84 % &$ %(6$;%/6 :$;&+:



0)""% (- # %!+$ $!$+8%; #&-$((-$(6%+,"!$ !- # %! 1! 

>0!:)

 (6$ !% %+! 8 ,""% ()(%((!!$ -"& %; #&&4 -!! $% %+! # ,!% !( %$  ,""% :+

%+,$%%+$(6%+,"!# - # %! 1(#!+: #+&- # %!+$!+$ $+! $#& ,$1##(,

)((!%,""% :+& %(- )# -$ %; #&%+$,""% ()(%((!!$ $%%+&%; #&% :4-!!$% $

(# $%  1((8 $ $+#& - &%$#!$ $ %+,$%-$ $4 1((8 $ $+#& - &%$#!$ 

%+,$%-$  %4 %+##$%1 /%!+$ &4 - # %!+$!+$  $+ /%!+$ & 1 $;&+ 1+6%-$ !%

;,!&-$ (%$+$""% (-% 1!& ,(-$%-$ ":+$(($%%- # %!+$!+$ ! $+! 

! $#& ,$1##(,!  $;&+ 1+6%-$ !% ;,!&-$  (%$+$ 9%! <4 -!!  $$+$ (!

,$%,!% !+$$ &+$  >  !:!   $;&+ 1+6%-$   !-#  +# 1+6%-$ !%

;,!&-$  !+$  "!#: -$ #4 " $(! ,! 1+6+! $ : +# # # -$ # +#

- # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,!(6(!1((8 %+,$%-$ !(&+,!% )+6+#+&

(!+!%4 $+!: & $ )+6+-$ ! #&%(,6 #& 6++!+ ,4 $$ (($%% $%  1

%(- %% % ,  

:!$$  9%! 0< 

 ,  

:! 1((8 $ $+#& - &%$#!$ 

%+,$%-$  %$% # 5 3 9%! < #"6%+84 % - # %!+$!+$ ! $+! ! $#&

,$1##(,! %+,$%$ $%  $-$  !(6(!1((,  9!(6(! $$!&+$ ,  $ 43 )(-!!<

+##$%1  D (6%+,"!$ $ - # %!+$ $ #%+& /%!+$% : 9%! < (# %; #&%+&4 %

(!! $%CC!(($(#$%8 !?-%?! :% ($%$&#&!!+$1" !,!, %,  

!##%"#,% !4+ !!)+41+6%& $)(!%$ !-$;&+%!%"#,!(&+!

%"#, $++#$ 1 !"6 # & $  %"#, 1 '($% %"#, $%-+! 4 #": % +&$ /$

,$%+%+! , $;&++%( $;%$ /!  '($% %"#, $% (%$  &$ !!## %"#, $++#$





/6 $++#!$ !  % !  9,$%$$++#&<4 % $ '($% %"#,! $+,% @

$$ $;&+  !&A -":

-!! 1+6% ) %+#+&(6 $ !%4,&$;%$ !!##%"#,!  +##$%1D,"% !(!1+6

$;&+$%! 8#& ! +##$%1  D /%!+$% $% #"6%+84 % $;&+ 1+6$ ($+%+$ ! $#&

,$1##(,4  !! ! $# $ ;#  1 ((&#%$((#6"  ##:  !!  +%($ (! %+#&

!(6(!!;6# +##$%1D$;#+!(!! $#& ,$1##(,)(!%$ +%($%+##$%#+&4 %

(!   !!  )+ %,%#+& ;!+% ! $#& ,$1##(, (# - # %!+$!+$ 

$+/! ++!-$ )(%((!!$9%!<(-$,;%#+&$ !! 4 % !!+#



%,%$

%

;!+%4

$%+& $

) ! 

$ &

% -! 

++!+,

$;&++%(

 # %!+$!+#  $ ! $#& ,$1##(, (# %+##$%#+&4 % %  -":#+& % ! (! ,%

-" 1 $;%$ 6+!+!% &$4 + /6 ! 6 % ! #": %6,% ) :!$%4 % )(!%$ +%(

$$$ !/!%%+&,!+% :$;%$% -+%(! 1" ! (6+$(#$ $+(6!4 %#%+&1+6+!  $# 

 

 >$ 0 $"% $%%+& ,""% (- # %!+$% ,"!$%,& $1(!+$&4 $-+%  ++!+

,""% (- # %!+$ !;) %-$ !   

 >$  $"% $%%+& !+$% ! ; #&%+& (#4 %

!+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  1 !+$$ &+$  > 3 !:  1": ,!*%$ %,& ,""% (&

! &$&$ %##:# &,""% (&)#%(- - # %!+$!+# $! $#& ,$1##(,



1) 

 >  !:  $"% $%84 % $%%$  % ( $%4 + $  ,$%8 $//% ((($$ $+! 4 (#

;:+$,$%#  1 $ (# $ !!  %(- )# -$ $ $//& ; #&-$% ! &$4 % !+$$ &+$  >

0!:1!+$$ &+$ >3!:$"% $%%+&,""% (&(#$//!$ !%1;:+$,$%$ !%%(- 

)##+& - # %!+$!+#  $ ! $#& ,$1##(, !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  #" 8

);6$%+$ # %% 6%6, +# %6,/6+%,; $%!+$$ &+$ >3!:

#" 8);6$%+$ # %% 6%6,+#3%6,/6+%!+$$ &+$ >0!:$"% $%84

% (6+$ ,; (6%+,"!#  - # %! 1 ,;8 (6!&& !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  $"% $%%+&

$//% ( $% !$$%+$ # $;&+ 1+6%-$  ;:+$  ",;%-$% (!- $% ++$% +# /6 $

++# 

 >  !:  $"% $%84 % (6%+,"!#  - # %! 1 ,;8 ,""% ( $% (6!&&

-#-!$ !% 6%6, (!- %6,/6+%4 +$1++ $ %6,/6 (# 6%6, 8$$+--4

-!! $+++$(#++$/-- #&((#

>3!:$"% $%84 %$%+$ -;$%-$ !(6%+

)((!%,;-""-$ !(6%+,"!$ - # %! 1)((!%, $%%$  : #&,&1$ #&,&

$1(!+$&4$-+%,;-!+$%-;1+%&$//&!$% &$)&6(&+-$//% :+& %(- )# -$ $%

1 ;:+$( %$-$  6+,$&  # %!+$!+$ !  $+!  ! $#& ,$1##(,! 

(6%+,"!$  - # %! 1 )((!% !+$$ &+$  > 0 !:  !+$ ! -""%+& 6%6, 5

%6,/6++!%+$ $4$(5((#(# %% #"6%+&$#%$((# $-$ $%-""$%;: -

1 !+$$ &+$  > 3 !:  !+$ ! -""%+& 6%6, 3 %6,/6+ +!%+$ $4 $( 0

((# (# %% #"6%+& $#%$((#  $-$ $% -""$% -&!- !+$$ &+$  > 0 !: 

!+$ !,; %- # %!+$!+$ !%$+!%! $#& ,$1##(,!%!$$%+$ #"1+6%-$;:+$

 ++$4 -$ (# $#%$((#  $-$ $ -""$ & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,  

)(!%$ ($(##(%$ %!%+$ (-$$./#$(#0(%$+$ $,""% ($1$

#2 30445 (6%+ ,% $ ;: $% ! &#+&4 % - # %!+$!+$  $+ ! $#&

,$1##(, $%+$% $ #&,& 1  : #&,& $1(!+& )++&+,& ##: -"#+&4 %

(!+($4+$:!$%!6++8!!+$ $$&+1$8,:$%&/! %+6#& #- $ 4) 8

 #&- $ !:  $:#! $ !! $%4 % !!+$+-$% 4 $ !6+!:$ !;:  -((%($;&+

1((8 $ $+#&$1+6%-$ #"(!(#% : -$%:)((!%#: !%$%%,% ;:+$+-$% :

 # %!+$!+$% $+% ! $#& ,$1##(,  (!  , - !!+$!$%  ,""% :+& 

%(- )# -$  $% $%%+&4 -$%;%%+  )  (6+$ );61 #&%+$ - # %!+$!+$  $+

! $#& ,$1##(,$+6% $ !+$$ &+$ >0!:!+$ !!$$%+$ (6!&-$%

$$ $ !! !  ,""8 (6%+ ,% $ -"-$%4 % (6%+,"!#  - # %! 1  (!  (- (%$+$ $

! $#& ,$1##(, $+6% $ !$$%+$  (6!&-$% -!! :: );61 #&#+& (6%+

,% $(#,;-!- # %!+$!+$%$+%! $#& ,$1##(,-;1+%&$ &+$++! !%



"%+-4 + %!!  1""$& $%+$% # /$# $ 6%6,&  !%((&+ );61! ! 8 (6+$4 %

- # %!+$!+$ $+! $#& ,$1##(, 8+$(#);61 #&%+&1++!+86+!&-$ ! 



")"6%+& $ !%((&+$%11+6#&+& $ 

>!:4)4443%/6$%8

(6+$ & '(!%$ ) * %++ ,   )(!%$ ($(## (%$ %!%+$  (-$$ ./

#$0(%$+$ ,""% ($1$#230445($!$ !%!$$%+$ -""-$ 

($$4+&1"%8-++$($$(%$+$ -++%-%



(6%+#

E!!E

!"#$% 



;: 

(( - *  #%#:& )-##



(6%+(%$+$1;+$%+$2%")$*22"))

(( - *  #%#:& )-##