Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-3891\4 AI generated

Court dismissed enforcement application against a foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects.

Case Number 1-07-3891\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the enforcement application filed by a creditor against a debtor domiciled in Estonia. The creditor argued that the foreign judgment should be recognized and enforced despite the debtor's lack of presence in Estonia. The court ruled that the Estonian courts lacked jurisdiction over the original dispute and that the foreign judgment violated the principle of mutual trust, thus refusing enforcement.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment cannot be enforced in Estonia if the Estonian courts lack jurisdiction over the original dispute or if the judgment violates fundamental principles of Estonian law.

Keywords

AI generated
enforcement of foreign judgments lack of jurisdiction mutual trust principle procedural defects civil procedure law

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.
Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

                         

      !    "           #$#%&        '$ &     ()'

   ' %& %$ * +      %  &    +   &

& , &+  $ +  &  $ -   &       !"#$ . / ' + 0& $ - &  & / 1111111111111111111112 %1111111111111   $ %& %$ * +   ! $% "  &   '((((((((((()    *+,*-,./,      -0/-12..  3          

         - ')  ,   4 15 6 .           

        ,                4 1+   -       7 

  3

     

    

 (((((((((((((((((((((8       

   3

       

   8                         3   8       

 3    

 3

   6 38        

 3  08 0 3 66 

! 3   ,   41+ .             7      

-')3

  9 

   3     9 

                   

 3 9          3        

  3

 -'  ) ,                       ,  &                 6     3        ,   !     ,&  &$  ,, &3& & 4+ &  %    &"  ,,  &-  3,&$ "  0 & 3,&$ 0    $ %   $  ,, & & % $43%& % 

  : $%:!"!$%!;  % &    ))%

  %  5  !6 

&+  

" 

67!!"    &  8 +!30!0",+ 4 &%6  " 9% $ +      8 95 + ! &   & % % 4 &%     !!  !     3  

"  7 4 &%   &, %   0    %$ +  $4   +    &   4 &%9  6%$ +    8 9 + &     "    $ %&& $ +  & $-% &+0 !  9%" 9 3,&$ 0 43  , %  & & $    &   4 &%  %!63,&$  $ +    

3&& $    &+ + 5  !6 "  43&-!  !  89 +3!",+

% 

3&& $7!   " !  +  !6 ! 9 !9  ,, &+ ",       ' +  %&   &  %  &    +   &

& , &+  $ -   &   %    ! &%   ' + ' + 

& % &89 +

&   & 

3&& $     % &" % &   +   &

& , &+  $ +  & $ -   &

  &  5 !  & +   % &   %      &+9%" !3,&$ $ +     % &   $ &       %5 /    5   

 #

3   8  + ! 3 0  ",+    $ 5  2 !     #

3 86 +",+6%$ - % &  

 &  & " + 2      #

3 8 +!30!0" 85 +!",+!

 $ - % &  2 6 !!  !   3 86 +!3!089" 8 +!30! ",+  " %$ - % &  !  &  & " + 2 5 !6  !!   3 86 +!3!",+% &    ' + & - % &   +  $ -   &

&   &, "  433&    .$&  %& & &3 &  & " %0 ))% 4 & 0& $  & & ,

 "  &%  + ",+0 %  $4-     +   &

& , &+  $ -   &0  %

&  &0&    &, %  &  $,& &+   +  , 

 $4- $ % % 3 $ & 4"

3&& $ &    &&  & &     % "    && %&  3& - $4   "    -&   %  &   &

&, &+ &$ - &  "    , 

  &    89 +3! & $4- & &  && &3 &  &  ))% 4 &%     & " +   +   &

& , &+  $ +  &  $ -  % 0  ))% 4 &  &+&   ,  % % $,&  3 & 4 &%    " 0 % & $,&    %  % &   & & 4 &%   " ,  % %) &3 &" & 

 %  &&+    &  : &  &  $ +  &  &

&, &+ &  $ -   &    8 9 +  ",+   & " +   +   &

& , &+  $ +  &  $ -   & 

  &  $&  -  &  &3 &  & " %0 ))% 4 &  0$  & & ,  +,     & %  & " 0 & &  + " 

&%  + ",+0 %  $4- ))% 4 & &     +   &

& , &+     &  $ -   &    %  &   & %  & & &    ,-0 &    $ &  "  $ +   & 

))  %   ,    + %& $  & % & &   % ",& % &%    $, "& % 

$  & ' &  "  $ + &   & & %   ;<&  % &   +  &

&, &+ $ +  & $ -        "  &% 0 & ))% 4 &  $ +   &  3  & %0 ,- %  &% 

 "  $ - &%&  % -,  &3 % $ %  0  4 &  $ -  %     & -0 &  %  &    &- $ -  %   +   &

& , "  433&   $ +  &  ))% 4 &$  & & ,  +& %$ %4+   &%$ $ %

& & &0 & ,% $ "    % %  &  &  ",$    &    

  & &   %  $  -+  &     $4 % - $ +  &   +   &

&, &+ & $ -   &  %  $  & &+  + & & " &   $   %  =$,& % % &4+   & &3 &  & 0 &- % &   & 

  8 5 +  ,&  %  4&& &   & "    8 9 + 6 "  5 + ! &  ,,   ,& % $   &  $ %    &+   &  ' - % &   &  & &&& % &   %&  

& &0  4 &- %   85 +!36

&   %  %  << &  3& & $ - &    "&  )&  "   $4%  %  &   - 

&  +  430 &-&& &3 &  &&

&  &   & ,,       8 5 + ! 3  ,&  %   & & %         % &+     % & && &$     % &   $   $4         & 4&& +  &  )$  &   %  &   %        )&  &&4 &- 89 + &6+ &$  ,,  &   & "  3 &     ,, &&+&  & " %  86!9 + 086! +