Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-16518\4 AI generated

Court dismissed settlement agreement as it violated the principle of good faith and lacked mutual consent.

Case Number 1-06-16518\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court rejected the settlement agreement because it was concluded under duress and without the genuine consent of the opposing party. The plaintiff argued that the defendant forced the agreement, while the defendant claimed the terms were fair. The court ruled that a settlement must be voluntary and in good faith to be legally binding, finding this specific agreement failed those requirements.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 120 of the Civil Procedure Code; s. 121 of the Civil Procedure Code: A settlement agreement is void if concluded under duress or without the genuine consent of the parties, violating the principle of good faith.

Keywords

AI generated
settlement agreement good faith principle duress and coercion mutual consent civil procedure code

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 120 of the Civil Procedure Code
s. 121 of the Civil Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

         

           !"#$    

  % &'(()*% %  

     ))    "#+'!,"-+$.&       /.(0$', " ",'"/   

   12'+'3.$"!"/$--4'$+$!"!!(.&&.2..+($.$ 56(, 7,'%  '((.8#!"/     12'+'3.$"!"/  (!"#+9 $'!!""49 **   +::!"#+9 !"4 !"4$$9    $.2! '$+ +$9 % %)%;;*% % ((' ' !"#+&""(+  5*(,< 6(,)&= =6=6>7,' /?!+','2'$') ! +$. 7 , @ )% %)%) % % ((' ' !"#+&""(+  56)(, &) ($.(6 / ,'$+$+=2'((.$+. ($.(+) 7 ) +','2'$'  ! +$. 7 , % A!.4<.(!"# $+( #!2'$.!..(4!"# (4 +4)%%)% %    4/"! + 4.B4  '!! $  !" 8#'44.$ 5)6=)6;7,'     #   $      % &'(   &              )*+

   ,  5*6(,=  ($.(7++ / ,'$+$+'.('!(++','2$('!(++'+2'$.(.&:: 2 + =!'12'+' 3.$"!"/  $+ $. !'+2'$!"+"((', ! +$. 7 (.'& .+"'2.+++ #+('!!!'+.,7 +'4 C

  )  5*$+.$+ +4!"+"((A4.'47 !"#$+$'%   5 (,  ($.( (,.4  ..(/ ,'$+$.$ /''C'+4 ., )6%%)% % !' )%%)% % $%"% ) &./ ! '$+$.! 42'$. 7 #(! %  A!.4 < .(!"# $+ ( #!2'$. !..(4 +-#'$+ 4  !"#+"+$$. 7A$+2'$.(% '$+$. ! 42'$. 7  (,$+ / +  ( +.$ %6%)*   (7 2A'$+ 12'+'3.$"!"/D'(+ 5*;(,&) ($.($4 # ;-#.!$ +# + !""' '','+(4.$$.%  12'+' 3.$"!"/>'( + $4  /(7 2A'$+.+4 $22 4  # 4$2''$+..'2' /.(4$ /.(. )) 6*  .$+' E#'$& , $ /A' )))  $ & , $%  !$.!" (4$.(. 2!'4 /''+.2C.)6;;',$.(,'+$9F12'+'3.$"!"/==$4 # G%'',' A',$ C'+ $7 $4 # + $4  &./ 7""!$(!.$"(./ !"#+"+$$.7A$+2'$.$+ / +.$% '  # ('$.4 A4.4 &"(. +'.$ ( +$.$ +'4.+4 $ + !$. A4.4 +'+.2..+($. (C'/''2'$.!$ !"#++'+'(.+'+.2..+($.$. 4$+'!$$+.$+ +4!" $%          &.(( +$'""'.'$ .$'+ 4 !"!!(.&&.2..+($.$+.#+4!"#+"+$$.&. (.=/(7  / +47#(=!' "/'4.+ / (+'!+4!"!!(.&&.2..+($."2.% -       12'+' 3.$"!"/>' $--4'$+ + !$. $.((.$= .+ +.2  )% % 2 ' (A&$= ..('2'$.,  +&$.(+ +/ $+ 2 + !&./ ("$+'$.C $. 4$('!(+ ((' $ .$!+(..('2'$., +/ $+ 2 + '$'!+.(+ , 22' 2H.+ 2'''=2'$/ $+ / (+F !""+'('$+.7 &$-##"+""&$.+. '.+.7 .4.(#+. '.+. $. 4$.G7 "+$' (2''$+'%2 ')% %2$.(.* !(C !""+'('$+.7 &$-##"+""&$.+. '.+.  '2.!'7  7  2'(('. " $ !",$= ', 2'4  #"'4'$  ((' $  . + / ( 2 # 7.+4 ,  B'4. 7.$ 7  2'(('$. 4'$ .C $. 4$('!(+ )%*%)% % !.((  )% % & '!  ((' $  $ 2.+(%%(.% 2 +.,./$., '!!$F !""+'('$+.7 &$-##"+""&$. '.+.',.4. (#+. '.+.$. 4$.G5 (,$++.'4%  

  .                   

.  

      

./    %&'( &   0   

  ,     / /  

 "!:+ "+(.$12'+'3.$"!"/>'$--4'+'$+ 2'$+ 56(, ($.(7 +.2 ! '$+ 2'$+ !"(2.   $+ $. / ,'$+$., = 2'((. 7++   5 *6 (, =  ($.( +'.('!(+ +','2$('!(+ +'+2'$.(.&:: 2 + =!'12'+'3.$"!"/.'& .  $+ $.!'+2'$!"+"((', ! +$. 7 7""!$( +"'2.++ #+('!!!'+.,7 +'4 C 5*$+.$+ +4!"+"((A4.'47 !"#$+$'% 5(, ($.((,.4 ! +!$..(/ ,'$+$.$/''C'+4 .,)6%%)% %!')%%)% % $%"%)&./ % '+$7 7'$A(2'+4!"!!(.&&.74.7 & ($$.((.!''+ 4 %

 

    "#+('! + 2'$.&A#7 (+.,'!"#$7.(4$.4=.+$--4'$+ + / $--4'+'$+ 2'.7 !"!!(.&&. $A(2'2'. " "(4 $--4'$+ + /  +A.('$. + #+. / (4$ 7  !'2' ( $7  2..+(.2'$.( " 7,'+4 !"!!(.&&.2..+($.$++.'4% --4'$+ + /12'+'3.$"!"/+(.C$--4'+'$+ 4  56(,7,'',2A'$+ ! '$+$ / $+ / (+!"!!(.&&.(.% --4'$+ + / / $++$+ $!.4 / '4., !.,.4 / '4 $7 "($'4.'"(.!"#$+/ $+ 4% $'/''(# ,'.$'+ +4.'"(.%$'+A.4.'4.'"(.%   ,"-+$.& "#+'!