Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-4577\3 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against minor's detention order, ruling it lawful under the Juvenile Justice Act.

Case Number 1-07-4577\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tartu Regional Court dismissed the appeal filed by the minor's legal representative against the detention order. The court found that the detention was necessary to prevent the minor from committing further offenses and that the conditions met the statutory requirements for pre-trial detention. Consequently, the lower court's decision upholding the detention was confirmed as legally sound.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Juvenile Justice Act 2003; s. 11 of the Juvenile Justice Act 2003: The court ruled that pre-trial detention of a minor is permissible if it is necessary to prevent further offenses and the statutory conditions for such measures are met.

Keywords

AI generated
Juvenile Justice Act pre-trial detention minor criminal proceedings necessity test procedural legality

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Juvenile Justice Act 2003
s. 11 of the Juvenile Justice Act 2003

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

                         

     !  " # $ % $          &'&%(   # $ %

 (  (  $    (  ( ) *' '  ( ( +  ' $ ' ( ,! (  

 (              !"#$ ( - .................................................../  % .......... %             &''()&''* +%%   +%, -  ./-'*-&''*--  0    0  00 ( ( ',1 (  %  00  (1 (  !0('  $      +

 (    # $ % $  %"00  (1 ((   (,+   (  (  $   ', (  ( ( %  (  % $ 2  1213 # $ %  ' 

( # $ %

 (  (   $   "" " " (  %  (  (   %  ( )*' '  (( + ' $ ' (,! ( 

 ( "   ( (   # $ %

 (  (   $  ( (  %   (% (  ( ) *' ,+   (    ( (0  (/ %( 33   ( $  ' + / 1 ( (4  ' +    (  ....... *,  5" "" "/ &,  *  (!(4( """ "  +&,  +

! 5"5"6" ")*' ((  + ( ........*,   ( (   '

( "  (     ) (+( (  % (+ " ) ' ( %  % ................................ ( $  ) (    ........*, "(    ) , '   ( "(%

,1 % (( %+(  $   +,!!  ($0  !  ("( % 3 + %( %  (

($ 

( (  ( (+  '  ((

   ' " *%  (  $  (% $,%  (  ( % !1 (( %(,! %)' ( %! %( 7..........")' ( % 33 % ........ ( $    % ........ ' % " *((!1 (( %/  (+  ........ ' 

  88 $ %  *'%( !  (+( ( %/  (%   $  ( $  '0+' + " *$ !0     '0+' % ( " ) 

%   0(  433   (     %   + 

 !(  (!0 % 0 $ %"% 0 $  (+   ( %,+   $ 

((%  %(33   (%/' +  %( "  "" " "

 ) *' ,!!  ....... *,  ( %

(

" 9  ,!!(    )0  ($ ,!!(88

(   ( (  % ' -,!!(' ( %% $0%$/% (%88%(+(  / %%(  (88 ")  '   (  %%(  $ !% :'(( % !,$ ( !0(' /::'(( % ;!0(' /:::'(( % ;,!!(!0(' /

(  + (,!0('   +:#'(( % ;!0(' " "5"   # $ %

 (  (  $ )*'!  (! %%

33(+  ,%    (! %% ' + " < (  (   $  %  ) ( ', ( (

!  % % ,! %+  + / 00 ) (  ($   ( $  ";" " " ........*, $0( (' '(0+  (  (  $  ((  % % ((!,$ $0 % (  ( )*'  00 %  ( $ !1 (( %   (0  (+ "< (  (   $ !88%  % $ ( %   ((  ',+=3! () (,!!(  1 ((  (  *  ) " ( (  ) !(  (  ' ( (+  

  %   ( ', (

!  % % " "" " "

 ) *' ,!!  ...... >3

 

( "

/ %(  (   ,! %

("< +  $ ,!!  ($   0  (  ( "< ( :::'(( % 

 +( (  ) !,$ (  !%  (% %%( "( (  $      )     $ ,! % "(,  (   (,!!(88

($0   69  ,!!(  ":'(( %  

  (    ( !% %")0  ($ 

  

% (  % ' "*,$ ( !%   + ( %; %"::,!!('(( %   ) 

 '   ( ;!% %/!,$ ( !%   5 %"?!( $ 3 ( ( ) ( ( +(("  ! 3 + ,   (  (1 ) 0  (   (% 0  0( (

(%

(%-(( %10 0

' ( '(/ 1((+ (%/((1 (( (+  $/   '  1 ( / 0' % 1  +  (    ( / '   1/ !%1 !,$ (    "  '   $ ,! %  (' %((+ (%)( 10(  " "" 6" "   (  (   $  &,   +

!    ( (  ) *' ,+   /  ( 

  1 ( (4  ' +  .......>3

  + %(1 "  $  00 ) (  (/ %  88%(!00>3

  $( /   !( 1  (  (% " " 6" "  

 ) '(  ( ( ! 3 + $%(" ;" " 6" " $0( (' '( 0+  ...... >3

   %% % (( !,$   )*'(( % % ! ! %88%(+( " &0%(  ) *' ,+   (   (  % ($ %( / (  ( ( %  (  % $  $  ........ # ' 

(   !(    ' ( /  ) *' ( (( ('  % % ,$ ' ( %( ( (  ( $ ' ( ( '   ,$ !%  ( / ! 1 (  (   $ 

  ) *' '   $0( (' '(  +  ( * )  9 5,!!(   ,! / """5" 5" "   /' % %  ( 01/ ( 1/( (( !,$( % %$  (1  % % "    ( ( ( ( % 2 0(1((/( (  (! +  (  '  ( ( +  ' $ ' ( ,! (  

1     (  (   $  $  !,$( % %  ( ( " < (  ( ,$ ' ( %( ( % (<#26 +  (   (  (  $  ,+    (%    (  ( '  ( ( +  ' $ ' ( ,! (  

 /  (  (  (!

%0(  ('  ( % (!  + ' ,(   0(  %(/  (((   % % ,$ ' ( %% (  ( % %  (  $   '  ( ( +  ' $ ' ( ,! ( 

 ( 1 (  ( '  $0( (' '('%( " <#2 + !$ !$0+ %  ( ( %  (  ( (/(  -  ( $ (   ( (   (  (!

%  

( %  (( 0%(/ %!8',   (% %/(  1 ,$ %    ',  

( % 2

5(( 0% ,$ ' ( % %  $   ( (  (  (  ,!( %@

  ( $ (   ( (   (  (!

%  

( %  ',  ( % (  (( 0%'00(/%'0  ( ( ( ($   (% %/(  1 ,$ %      %  /',   (% %/(  1 ,$ %    ',  

( % 2

5(( 0% ,$ ' ( % %  $ '00( ( (  (  (  ,!( %"   ( (  % &,  *  (!(4( "" " "   ( ( ( ,!(  ( 00 (!,$ '   /()*'!  (  (  ( 2;; +$0+ ' 4 (( ' (" 

)*' (  ,!(   + 3 (# $ %  < (  (  $  (" < (  (  $ 

  "5"  00  )*' ( ,$ ' ( %   ( $   ( $  " (!( 1  " "  &,  +

! 5"5" 6" "  ( ( ( ,!(  ( 00 (!,$  '   /()*'! "" 6" " (  (  ( 2;; + !$0+ ' 4 (( '  (" <'(  %(  (  (! (  ( $ % $  33% (  / (%  ' ( !8/ ( ) *' 1 ,$ %   (     ',   2  5 (( 0% ,$ ' ( %  %  

(  ($ % (  (   $  ("   ( ( )*' (  ,!( " < (  (   $  

  "" 6" " 00   ) *' (    $  ,$ ' ( %    % 3 %   88% ...... >3

  $( /   !( ' %  ( (  %" " 6" "  +

  '(  ( (! 3 +$%("  < (  (   $  !  ) *' (   % % ,$ ' ( %% ! ( % %  ( ")*'( (( % ( 00 %3 %  88%" (0% )    " ) *' ( ! ( ,$ %    (%  ' ( (% $  ,! %  (  (" ......( *, / ...... >3

  $  ...... ?! %  (  (  ) *'   01/ ( ' (  !%('   %    / !% %

+(% !,$ (  %%( ", (     %!1 (( (0  ($ ,!!  (+ " #(  (% ,!( $ (+  $  %( 0 $ % ! ( ,$ % )    

,(( ( 0 "    ( 1/()*'!  0%(% + (%/  <#26 +  (  

(  (  ( '  (( + ' $ ' (,! ( 

 ( ")*'  !

%  ( ,+    $  ( ( 00 % ,$' ( %% (  (  (  % %" )*'

 (* )  (  '  $0( (' '('%( "  <#26 +$0+! +  ( (  ( '  (( + ' $ ' (,! (    (   "0 $  00  (  '(   (,!!(   ,!+ " ) 

 (0 $  00  (  01   ( % 0( $ # $ %

 < (  (   $    (   + 00 1/ ( ) *'

 ( (  95 ,!!(   ,!  "" "5" 5" "  26 + (  (10(  ('  00 (!   # $ %

< (  (   $  (/)*' ($ (  ( % ( ((  % $ ( (  +* )  ("    0  00 ((+(  ( 26 +!"