Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-7681\17 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding the applicant's right to reside in Estonia.

Case Number 1-06-7681\17
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative decision denying their right to reside in Estonia. The applicant argued that the decision violated their rights under the Aliens Act, but the court found no error in the administrative body's assessment of the specific circumstances. Consequently, the court upheld the original decision as legally sound and factually justified.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Aliens Act § 10; Aliens Act § 11: The court established that an administrative decision denying residence rights is valid if the administrative body correctly assessed the applicant's specific circumstances and did not violate the principle of proportionality.

Keywords

AI generated
Aliens Act residence rights administrative decision appeal proportionality principle right to reside Estonia discretionary assessment

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Aliens Act § 10
Aliens Act § 11

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                

     



 !"#$ % " &' ( $     )%    &       * & $  %  &

*   

  %       &$    ++" %   

 $,*

-$ +""...$"$/  " $    $ " %  $ "  --     0 ,-    $&, & 12  %"    12    &$ % 

  3/%  0,-    &, &%"   1,2" + 12   &&    

4     #0     $    

    ""%  +1 2%5   & 

  %  "5 

++"    # 0  , &      %/ "   6 )   &  & % "% 7 #%% ) &        "  8   9 "  &" ++"     $&%    &  

- & 

      %  &  ...   ... /  +      %  "+  3 & & 66 %/" % 

/ %"5 / %      66 "     " % 

  $ / & "  / % & " % $   && 3       9  % : "     #0, "      9     " ++" &  &    ++"   / &"   9  +   $3& /""%"$%    " 

  "&    / "   & 

  &/"    *  , 66 &&   &    & 1%" 2 " &     5  66       "$ "   $ "         %" 5     & "  "5  $ "9 5  "   " $ %" % &  5  "  " " 5 "&%" "% 5     &

   "5 9   " "   $      %   5 9    "  / 5+  "   + &%  $+    % 5

     /9   $     &%"%  5 66     9   $ 66&&  "% &    %/5   "%   % &5  &     $     " $ "9  $+   5& "   , -

 %  5  %"   9  % &"5   "5    ," %&  & 5 ""5% $  &$&"  /   "&  "5       $       %/  5   

  " 9   % &&   " & /"  $  "  %"$  "%   5  $ $  5  &  &$ "  "$   &" %  "5     & 9 $" $   +  $ " $+ %/" $$    & %/  "5  %/ %  $ "9 5%"$ %5+  /    9   & & &" 

 5     

$9  $  ""% "5&   %/"+  "59 $&  /"    &"5 %// 

& &5&&    % & $ "5"   $   9   $%/  " 5% 

    &%  "$   %   5    /  " &  9 && + " % %/$ /  &    $  &  "  

  5        

     %"   $     "         

  /% $  $   & 5

- &   "9     && & 5  " "5

"%$%   /" $ "%" $ "  "&& "$ "  % &  ;< $   "%&" 5 " " " 5%"  +" %" "$  " % 5 "  "$ "   5 "    "  "

  + $ " 9     5 66  

- &  """5/   "$ +  $ "% &%& " :5   "$%   /" 5 % 9 $ "      & /" $"

   " $  "      /   & "5   "  &  "$ " 9  $      

$"     $  "5    "    "5      " "&""   /  & 5+   +  +  :$   "

$     

 %  % & %        5 9    + $     &&1...2$ ")  %&%   :+ "$  & "      $ "   $        : + "$  &&  "5   "& &"%" /" &    % %" $ " "  &      $ ++" %+ " % %   

 / "$"%  +"  %  % " & " &        & "     #+"   %      " "  $  /  " %   "" " " " /% &%   %" &  & /" " " "%"+    $ &"   $ %"   " %         %  "    " "  " /    &    % %5%"%    /" % %     "   5    /"     " %       %

 , ""&%    % % #++" %%/ $    / %    +       9 /%   %  66   66  "   +  & # $     & 

   " %   " " "5  " &  /"  "  %     "" "5   "  + "    %%  "   + 5 66  " "&   "  &      "  " "" %       =7)    $%"  "% $/ " $%" % $  66  " +  %/"%"    " %"$    "=7): " %"   3  =7) %/" %  " =7)  :     & 1%" 2 /"  "      %    "   1%  :    2$    %     ""  %  $ 1  -2   " %        "   "  %&%"  "%=7)  =7)    &  & %     %" "      % "             $% % / % %&"

% / %    %   &  / &      % $  %     &

 %     //"%  5    %/     %   %     %  "$ "   %  "    $ %  ""   %"& $  &"/ %"&  &"    /   " ++" %%"$%   + &  66   % &&   %    %   7   &     ""  &/"1   $  ++" %%    % " 2""%"%        #++" %$ &"   "5           $  %   %/     "  +    " %    &/    +"    %/"$   > )"  "  &  /"   & "" /""   %"    "    $   %    

++" % &  ++" % "/ & " " #++" % %"   $    % 

- &     /  1  2     ""  &;< $  / "   3 9+       %  & 

    

 , $  "

" /   ...  7" "+   "$"  " 9  ... ?  "    &   & %% % &  /  &  &$    / $+  &  ""5

  ""5       %% + $ &   &  "5 %           &" 66 &   $      5  /    "& : % "5&     

   

%$"    "& " $ "  66"   #+"   %     66   " + "       " "  & "     &"5   "  /   5  ""$ 66  & >@5 /      "5  "   &  "  9  +             &  

    &  /  & "   & &     % $ +"      &+   )"&  +  " %$  + "  "  "  "  &"   /      "  % 

    + " %/" "/ "" & "   "  + "  ++" %  "%""%+ 5  " + "  /  +  &      66  %/"  +      %$ " ++" %  

 "    $   &+  $   "+ "  "  "66"$/  "&" "" & "   " +"  %   & 1%" 2% 

& +    $   %/" "   ++" %$ &           & & &  #++" % %"  /   #++" %+    " %   "  $&         ""  +"     %" +    &  

     % " +   $  & 

   

 " "

 & "%" %  & &  $ 9  "& %  $   /$/  %" + $  " %  #  66" 9  &%"%"     #+     %"   &  " +  &    % & )     + $      &$ "9   #& "9   %         &  &  "$        "     "   / $ 9    " " 

  #&  &"  / %   9  &"  &"%" /& 9 "& "  %   $" "% 

  $     &/" &   # &  "   %" $&5  

;< /%   &  $ &     & & &/ #"9 $ %     & %$/  %" $ "  %5  /     &    

 &  +    ;<

  &   9  "  &  &" "  A   "  ;< /"     &  "  7" 

 " &$"%    5  &&/""%   %5+  & +  $  $/&" " " &     *  

  "+  9 "+ 

%    & +  $   +"&%"%" $ & "+  "& 66" $ "  & 66" 5 & %/"  &% ""& % & 7    9   +    "   

 % &  "" & /" 5   "  &    5  "% 5  &  "&$""$  % "$ " "&9  "" % #&  "/" 5 %   " 66"5  &  % 5%    " "5 " /   & &  """"/" 

 6 "% $   /    " "% 

 $/      "      #++" %   66  %" &+ "$ "  $   9     % +" $%"""&3

"" 

- & 

  /   ... /& && % &    9  $  $  %& /&& %5  "% B"#&%& & 5 9  &&  " 

 5   $ 9   /%  $

  

&%" /"  &+   5+     & %   $ 9         5 /   /$"/ " "/   $    

  $       "  &           ""  :

 *   

5 9   :+ "          " +   7    $   9   $        &   %  

  "   9 & +  %" &+ "$ "  $   9     &  &  "    & $       

5 3   "" 

- &/  

   "& "%"$"   $  +  $/%   &+  $" 5+   

 "  5 &   ""& % &59 & "  & $  "& "5 &9  &  "5 % %"  " $""   9     "&%//"9  

 "59  % 

      $       5       "  5&  $     "  

&"            "+    " +     &    $ 9  "%&"   &%    & "+    9 & + %" &+ "$  9      + 9 &+   $ ...$  /% ...    9   4 * &   & 9  $  & 9  %   % + "&  "%  " 5+ "/ & " "%"&+ " &  ""%   & 5" + "   5 " ":++   "$ +   "66"  

5""9   %& 5  "& %  , 4%5  

% 

- & 

    &   %  & 5      &  "    %  %/  % 5 %   "  "% 5 &/%   &   5

- &   /       "   &"$ %         "$ 4

*

  &&" &% $  &   

   "&   5 %&"  & &  %                " + $   %"    " + $" "    $   & 

   &"$  "& &%% "$66 & 5     $   & &   /" 5

- & 

   

  &  "$

- & 

   -

 &"  9 $        "    $  + " 5 9    & $  & "  9     :$"% "+ " 5         9 &"  &

% &5  &  & " $9   %   " %&"   +        "$     "    *

 $     ""53 %$  %    $ & %     5    &    5 &$ "  9  &   "$   " &/" $ "   $  "   "   "   9 &+   $ 9 %   $3" $ " "   & 

  $ "   & "&%/&5 %              9  $   

 " "     $      $     " &5  "" &   

+%$&  "C $)D$"&) & "$   " 

  "  ""%5%&  )D5"" %$

   9 %& &%   $ +%& %/ 5   /   -



 9 "  +    " +   "$9  

- &   59    &" %    "$    "$ "     +"     5 +%      " 

- &  /  $     ( 9 66"     &   $    %   /  +      &%&  5( 9"  5( 9"$   5  "   &9   $ &  "    9 &+   $   ...    & &$  9  %  9  +  %    )#$  +% * & )  

    /  ) #...& 5%     & '  /  

  &  

-

    9  &+  )$"  "&+  $)& "9 )  $

  & "   9 &)D    "&   % ""+   $3  %   9  && & 5

- &

  /   & ... ) +% " $ %      % &  &    % &   $   +  $      %&5"  $ "6 "5  /  &   

+% 5  &  9 &  %& &5"    "5   &   "$     " & 9  &    

 %""5   %  $9 & " +  "59  "  %5 $""%  "" " &/  "   /" &"%"$ 9 %& 

- &/  

      #     " & +  $ 9   &   %  %   #++  %"   "     66  &    %    / &   9  %   "/"   9 & ( 9   9          + "      "  & +  "      9+   $ +& 9     & $ "  "   7"     +  %  5  +        9   %  $  &

      

   9 66 & % 9 "  "566   9   /  $ & " &  566 % 

- &

   9   % 5

- & 

   



  &9   $%"$ %  66 %/5

  % 5+  / "5   5 " $/   5 

 % % $" " "5  %   

  9    %  +/  $ /" 

"5 9     5   4

      9     %    ++ $  /& "   " +  8 %&%/ 5 &    "9  & $   >$ &  % $% "5

 /    4   &  $ 

"         5 %   &5

+  $  5+   & $  9   /" $ + " "&  $+    & $+  & ""$  & "5   " 6 "$" " % 5    %  &  /% &5+     &  +& & ...5  &  &+  $  %

 ++% 5+&   /  ...5+  &+  $ 

  &"  5

- & +" & 66" 5 &   %      +   % &5 % %    

 5  & $   

- & ++% %/5 $  +  %  9    %/5+  "+ "  &%  5      +      " +   5 3   &  

- &   "   $ "    

   5  

4      +  9   ... " 

5  

* 

  %     9     /  &+  5 & %     $  " &%/+   5 /        !   %   +"  % "&         &+ " #"%   ++" %+   +    $       % "  &      9    , 4 % 

- & 

   +& $  9   &5   %/  &     %/%% % 

& 5  $  "& " $ %%&     53  %"/" 5  

 &  "&+    & 5 & "$     " %5 " "   %   %" &" & &   "5   "  / $    &  "  &/" % &&5          "%  5& /"%/  &  5

- &   &   &$    % "5    +   &5 %"       $  "      /"    $  "   & + " " &  $& /"    

 " 6 "5      &     "$   %        "5 

1%" 2%%% 

    &    + "  5   " %%      5  &   5+    $    

5     5   "  &5

- & &/  %& $ %& 5  &"

- &  $ "   +    / " &/"   & %  & $     &  & 9  +          3    &   %  % &       " + " "      & 

  "+    "$   9  " &

- &  & " $ " 

   "$ " " &/" $"/  " %" 5 &  ""/ "" & -

&   $ "   " /"   #  %   +        & $     3 /  %" $  " / %" 9 $   %

- &

    "  "5 % /  "  5   "    "  "$  "     5 "    + "

  + &   $ "5 $"  " " / " & "$% $ +  66  66 &"  "   +   %& &"5+   "  &%%%&" %  " "/5

$   + %/5%/"  %"   &  5    % 

%" %/ 9 %" % /  %$"      %    %  " &  " $

"     %   " +& $  "   % 

 9  

  #%  "  ""  " &"$ " &5$ %   $/ ""   "  

  =7)    $ 9  %  " /++:"  %/" %       & $ +    5% 

""=7):   9  %/" % %/"%$ "  3 %/" %" %/"%"5   "   %  "3    &        % 5 9  %  %"  ++:"  %/" %  % &     %    &  +    & %  "   &        %   $      "& " "/" "  $    9       " "  % "  3       "  3   % "    &     +         +            9   %/3  66     3  : "    "          % $   3  %  "      %   %         &     " 

- &  

   %    9       &% E"/"" %"  "    $ 9  /

3 %   +  &+ / & " "   "  "%        66      "  / % &          " "

   )% "   & $          " / %     $   + "" %     & 66 " + $  "    $  9  /3 & %   + &       "     %/  #"    :$    %     "  3%/ 9 "  % %&  % & /"        "" /" $/ %""    9 ""

   & "  "       "      # 0  , / /   ++" %

  ""   "    $ 9     ++ "   #0  4/  

    + /&" $/"  &"%/  66&&     #++"/ % 

%  %" & " 9  %   & ++

  /  ""   "  %   /"     "%"   "%" & " 9  %   " 9  ++ ""    $     " %   9 %        "  "$    %      %       9 

++  %"  &&         7  / &     $  %   % #00,  %/4  & "&  %/ &    "   %  %   & $     / &  %   +  &    &   $/  & 9    ++" %    +  "$   / %          # 0 ,     " %   +     9 " %    " +%     *  7// &""&   "      ++" % % &/    "

  "  -

 $  & 66  4 , 5  "           "   "    =7)      -  $    4, &       *  

 - 3 "" #00,$-   $   $, $, -  ,$,,&,*$      8  #++" " 9 #0,&& ""%    12    9/" %   &   &       % "   % " %    & 

     &/  9    "

-

 " $,-4*             "   "    & 4 ,    & 66  +%   &/ " "%/  "+ &    

 &/    "        

,4

   '   $ %

4--%/   , A   %      "  

/   "      &/  9   9

 *"   & +%    ) /"   "    && 5 + 5  & "$ /  "$66&" " %"  

&/      

  %/       "    9      )  /     %    "   % &   %   

      )    "   % + %  &   %  % $          %/   

    %"   #++" %  &   %"  &"  

  "  &% %    !"#       ' (       %     %