Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-1038\3 AI generated

Court dismissed asylum claim for a Russian national who failed to prove a well-founded fear of persecution.

Case Number 1-07-1038\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu District Court dismissed the asylum application filed by a Russian national who claimed persecution based on his ethnic background. The applicant argued that he faced threats due to his nationality and alleged membership in a specific group, but the court found his evidence insufficient to establish a well-founded fear of persecution. Consequently, the court ruled that the applicant did not meet the legal threshold for granting asylum protection under the relevant statutes.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Asylussead 1994, § 1; § 2: An asylum claim is only granted if the applicant can substantiate a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion; mere nationality or vague allegations without concrete evidence of specific threats do not satisfy this requirement.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum claim well-founded fear Russian nationality persecution grounds particular social group Pärnu District Court immigration law

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Asylussead 1994, § 1
Asylussead 1994, § 2

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                     

          

    !" #  

     $"$%&'(")")*    + ,-- .,, ,, +/+0+  ,-1 /   

+-# /0,1  

   1 -/+22/+ ,3$/,%!4#%")-1# . , 22/+ ,  3 %") -1  #1+ -,55,,, -,             ++/ %((6!6!%7   /+7 81+/7  

  +/ %")!6!647   /+7 ,$ ,++/,1 9      !"#  22/+ + /1 -/3%")-1#1+#8+  --,-+,+  ) 5,. - , '- .-  ++ ,+,  5,.+, -,  -/+,-, -.5,."+*7%))+  22/+ + /1 -/3%!4#1+#8+  --,-+,+ !



  5,.- ,'- .- ++,+, 5,.+, -, -/+,-,-. 5,."+*76!+   3 (6 -1 #1+ -++  + ,/ # -++ + , 8+  -+, +  ) 5,.'%))*-2,/.++  .++/+   3 (& -1 #1+ ,,-.1+ , -// ,1 &4!) + "!)  " 5,.,!5,.-1,/ /+ ,-7,,1-0/+,-,!4 5,.'!)4*2,/  .++/2,2,/+ 3((-1,- -/+,-,+ + #- /,+1+,- #1,.- 9 • ) +!"&"+7 • )5+--+!"&"+7 • )+!"&"+7 • )#+!"&"+7 • )#-+!"&"+7 • )1 +!"&"+7 • ),5 ,0+!"&"+7 • ) 0+!"&"+7 • ).,0+!"&"+7 • )/, ,0+!"&"+7 • )#+!&&&+  8,/,- -+,,,-/ 2+ /  #8 +,-  22/+ + /.3%")-1#1+#8+  --,-+,+ !) 5,.- ,'- .- ++,+, 5,.+, -, -/+,-,-. 5,.)+*7'!)* ,+   .++/+  3 (& -1 #1+ ,,-.1+ , -// ,1 "4!) + "!)  "! 5,. , !( 5,. -1,/  / + , -7 ,,1 -0 /+,-, %6 5,.'"*2  ,+ ,/+ 8,/  # 2+ /   , #8 +,- # 1 / . , +,-,  / #!!) 

-#8+ 1 -/+- ++1+ -/,,/')6*.++  ,-+/+ # ++1+8+10+,, '!4(7)"*  2/2,2,/#)" +1+ 8,/+ ,+ '6(47&)*,-+ ,+   /2, ,+ #&)

-#8+ .,- ++1+ -/,, /')6*.++ ,+    ,-+/# + 8,/+ ,+ '!4"7(*/2,2,/,+ ,#(

-+, + ,  /   #- .8+ . .-  +,  / 1:+-,   , #8 +, , ,  /++ ,,++ .,-/.,-,   , + ;+51!!%6"4(.8+51!!!%""&((,-/,-, +/.++ ,0,6(6&)&+1,-1+ 9<1 -/.8+.7$"$ %&7-+,+ =  / #  ++1+ 8+10+ +1 + 8,/+ , +  ,,  / % 5,. #- ,-,.   , #8 +,  - ,

/++ ,,++ .,-/.,-, !!%6&"   , + ;+51 .8+ !!!%""&(( 51

   ,-/,-,+/.++ ,0,!&64(4(+1,-1+ 9=1 -/.8+ .,7$"$%&7++-,, -,-/=  + -+, +  # / -+,/ 8/,/ 5-, +, - ,  ,1,-   /7  , 8, + ,,, -, -0+.+++,   + +-, + ,,, -, - +,  ,  /         5,-- ++8+1, +,.+  , / -,+#-+- ,+ ,5,. #- 5,-- + ,+  ,  -, +#-+-  ) 5,. #- - , 5,. 7 +-  ,, -,5-,-.8+-+  ./  ,1  $       %       22/+  ,,--,7,  ,7-, ,,-,.- . .-  --+,/, 3 4 -1 !! 8, ,-,  -,/ 5+++ , /+  ,/ +,-, ++-+ --+,1+ +,7 +  . .-  --+,/, 3 6 -1  5 ! --+ + -,+, 8 .7 ,--+.>,-,,/+22+,,,1+-!),5 ,0+ + 0++1+ 

&4-++ + 5+++  7+-+2--+,  /58# ,-. .- --+,/,3"-1 + -,+,+ ,-0 / 5+++ ,1 ,--++/1 -/ #  ., ,,,7+--, -,, -0  5+++  , + 0+++ +,  7,,+-/ ,/-+7, 5+++  + -,+,+ ,-0 / "4!),--&6#--+/1 -/#  +, /., 1 -. ?! ',1+ ,,++ "%6* 1+,1 @1,- ',1+ ,,++ A!"4&* ,,$-++ +,,#,-#!!)$-++ +,, +,5,/ /5+++ ,1

-/>+#,/+,--0+ -5+++5 + + 0++1+ , + 0++++1,- ,/+ ,-- 4 #- - /,,, , .-- 5++-- 2- ., # +1- 0+7+/ .7+1/5+++ .>,.-/,,

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

   ?!',1+ ,,++"%6*1+,1@1,-',1+ ,,++A!"4&*7)$ -++ +,, 5/,-+, 5,/ / +.++ 1 -/>+ #,/+,- -0+ - 5+++5 + + 0++1+ , + 0++++1,- ,/+,--(6#-04 ., $ ,-,,

 .- --+,/,3"-1)-++.++7+--,5 , -+67,1,7  +.++ ., -+  ++ 6%( + '))B)!B6CD"!!B!B))* 2-,  --+$7 0$ # 2 , +++ ,/, 3 6( -1 ( -,,.  +++ (& + '6CB)!B*(&/,- '6%(C(&*7,+2,/,-                                   + ,7--,&&!6#8 / "!%  ,1 3$/,"-1)#)#36&J-1#1+22/+8+ , /+1,--,- -+364-,- -++ ,.8, /-, 8+1 @@ / ,+-, ,.  ,-+++  -/.-, +-$ @@  ;$ ?,1 +/ @@-,5+1  ! -,- - , %!% + !6 ,1,.#+, +-+1- ,!6/, / @@-,5+1,- ### +-  @@,+ /.+/ #  ,1 ,+  ,+-, ,.  ,-+++, -/+,1,--,17, --+# ;?,1 +/9 • .,.-# #&&!6;?,1 +/+,- +2+1-, < K =.,46!&(++1 • &&!6 0  # ..,-+,   5/+  ,-,,  6! !12-  /0- +,,+1 5 ++,L • ., .-# # !64!6  ; ?,1 +/ +,-  +2+1-,   < =.,46!6666++1 • !64!60 #..,-+,  5/+ ,-,,6!("" 1.,:+-,, 5 ++,L • 4!6 ++ ; ?,1 +/ ,+/# +2+11  <?M= -,5+1  4#  /.8+2-  /- /1 ,--++,7. .8 +,# +, ;?,1 +/5- L • )4!6 ++;?,1 +/,+/#+2+11<?M=-,5+1( #  /.8+2-  /- /1 ,--++,7. .8 +,# +,; ?,1 +/5- L • )4!6 ++;?,1 +/,+/#+2+11<5=-,5+1 %C4C6 #  / .8+ 2-  / - /1 ,--++,7 .  .8 +, #  +,;?,1 +/5- L • !64!6;?,1 +/,+/#+2+11<=-,5+1) 2-  /-#2-  /-:+-,, +,;?,1 +/5- L--+# .,  #  4&!6  ,-, $ .,  6& +2+1-,   

+++1 6 1 2-  /  :+-,, ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  !)4(7+L • .,  #  !&!6  ,-, $ .,  G 6 +2+1-, G-+ ; (&! 1 #  / ., ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  !66!7&+L • .,  #  !)&!6  ,-, $ .,  G 6! +2+1-, G-+ ; &4" 1 #  / ., ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  %"6(7+L



       

   • ., #!(&!6 ,-, $ ., 64+2+1-,  

+++1!12-  /:+-,,#!12-  /.,:+-,,,,  +, ;$-,?,1 +/!)4(7+L • .,  #  !"&!6  ,-, $ .,  G 6% +2+1-, G-+ ; 4)) 1 #  / ., ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  %4667)+L • .,  #  %&!6  ,-, $ .,  6! +2+1-, /+ ?+ 1 + ,, @@/,,,  +,;$-,?,1 +/6")7 +L • ., #%&!6 ,-, $ .,6!!+2+1-,G-+ ; 1 +  ,, @@/, ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  ))7 +L • .,  #  %&!6  ,-, $ .,  6!% +2+1-,  ,:+ - + 1 + ,, @@/,#-+ @@/,'N*,,  +,;$-,?,1 +/ !647)+L • ., #%4!6 ,-, $ ., 6!+2+1-,  

+++1%12-  /:+-,,#12-  /.,:+-,,,,  +, ;$-,?,1 +/!)4(7+L • ., #44!6 ,-, $ .,?6+2+1-,?+ ; &4( 1 #  /  ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  %!"")7(& +L • ., #4!6 ,-, $ ., 6!+2+1-,  

+++1!12-  /:+-,,#!12-  /.,:+-,,,,  +, ;$-,?,1 +/!)4(7+L • ., #"4!6 ,-, $ .,6!+2+1-,   ("61#  /.,,,  +,;$-,?,1 +/!(!6)7)( +L • ., #!64!6 ,-, $ .,6%+2+1-,   (%41#  /.,,,  +,;$-,?,1 +/!6&&!7(( +L • ., #%4!6 ,-, $ .,6!)+2+1-,G-+ ; ,5 ,0+  ,, @@/, ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  ))7 +L • .,  #  %4!6  ,-, $ .,  6!( +2+1-, /+ ?+  ,5 ,0+  ,, @@/, ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  &7+L • .,  #  %4!6  ,-, $ .,  6!" +2+1-,  ,:+ - +  ,5 ,0+  ,, @@/, ,,  +, ;$-, ?,1 +/  &7+ --+#  -/#.,+-&&!6O%4!6;?,1 +/+,-  .,+/ & /   %)"&((7& + # --+#  ..,-+,   5/+ ,-, +!/+18-+;?,1 +/+,- 6-,5+1  ;?,1 +/,+/+,1-0+++ ,- ,+ ,++ ,17+--, -,,8-+ +8+1+ #   + ,+ .+/ -,5+1+/7  +  5+/+/, +/, # 0 ,/, +/, --+# +,1 ; ?,1 +/ ,+/# ,1 , 1

-/ +-+,-  # : +-+,-  + + 1 -/ ;$ ?,1 +/  ,+-, , .  , -+++  -/.+/ 2-,/,+/ +1 + , 2, ,+ +//    , + +, 8.-,.+/-8+-+,- +-+-7+2+1.+  +  @@-,###+/#  ++.,- 2+1.-+ ,.  ,-+++ -/+ 

                !!    "            "          #$

         

 >,22/+  ,,--,7,  ,-+,/+22+,,,1+-"4!) 

 +, / ., 1   ',1+ ,,++1+1 (%% A* - /,,, , .-- 5++-- 2- .  # +1- 0+  #- , .-- 1,/+ -,.+,,.; , ++-1+#/,,$-++ +,#,-#!!)$ -++ +, +7&4-++ + 5+++  7+,+-/. .- --+,/,34-1!! 8, ,-, /++-+--+,1+ +,7+. .- --+,/,36-15! --++ -,+,8 .7+1-+,,1. .- --+,/,3"-1+ -,+, + ,-0 /  5+++ , -+.5,-,5+++ ,20,-/++ 9

 7,,+-/ ,/-+7, 5+++ -++ -,+,+ ,-0 /7 +, /., 1  ',1+ ,,++1+1 (%% A* .++, $-++ +, # ,-# !!)$-++ +,  +7  )4-++ + #-,,,-++,- .   +1 ,,+-/ ,/-+7, 5+++ -++ -,+,+ ,-0 /7 +, /., 1 -. ?( ',1+ ,,++1+1 !"( P*7 -, $-++ +,  +7  % -++ +  #- +++.--+1+2- 5,, ,,%.;5, ,#/, 

 .-  --+,/, 3 " -1 ) -+ 5+++  , 1,7  5+++ , ., -+  ++ 6%")"&6 + 2-,  --+$7 0$ # 2 , +++ ,/, 3 6( -1 ( -,,. +++6)!)(+4(/,- 7,+2,/,-                                     & &'  

  1 -/ # .  + +/ ,/ 22/+ +,  @ # 22/+  . , + # , #,-,-  8-+/ -,55,7 +--, ,-  5@ 8/+ 922/+ + / -/3$/,%")-1#%!4+ ,8+  -+,+ .22/+ + /3%")-1#1+#8+ -+, +  

-# 8+   -/+-  ++1+ -/,, /  ) 6 +7 + #  !4(7)" +#+ 8,/+ ,+  ,6(47&)'!&(667)9!D4769 6Q6(47&)*

-#8+ ,- ++1+ -/,,/)6+#+ 8,/+ ,+  , !4"7('47696Q!4"7(* 8,/ #,- 2+ /# 1 / , #!!)  

   -,+/+7, 22/+  .22/+ + +,#-,55,8-++, , 8,-+,  , .-/ ++-# ,, -,+,-  #1+ / -,55,,, -,  ,+/ A+//,  3 !6& -1  5 6 #1+ -,0 ++ 22/+ + / # 8+  --, -,55,,+  

   +.++-1+,+  /,+-, -/ -,0+,8/22/+8+ , -     

,-- .,,   +