Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-245\2 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against criminal conviction for theft, upholding original verdict due to lack of new evidence.

Case Number 4-07-245\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's request to overturn the first-instance criminal conviction for theft. The appellant argued that the original evidence was insufficient and that the trial judge erred in assessing the facts. The court rejected these claims, finding that the original judgment was based on reliable evidence and that the appellant failed to demonstrate any material error or new facts warranting a retrial.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 24 of the Criminal Procedure Code; s. 25 of the Criminal Procedure Code: An appeal against a criminal conviction is dismissed if the appellant fails to prove that the original judgment was based on erroneous facts or that new evidence exists that could change the outcome.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal appeal theft conviction evidence assessment retrial grounds Criminal Procedure Code appellant burden judicial review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 24 of the Criminal Procedure Code
s. 25 of the Criminal Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



    

         

  !"#$%"&'()#          ($%**'%*$      $ )$'      +!& + %, &&+-%, #.,                         /0%(*1*2*('0%(*$$ (*(%(*'$*)$(3*%#(4*%'4'(*'"  !             ""    # $%&      '    ()*+,)+$,,%+  ' -          

).(  -'  +            ""    # $%&      '    ().+,)+$,,%+  ' -          

).(  -'              ""      # %*/)   )      '    ()*+,)+$,,%+    )0+). ' -             

 ). (  - '  +            ""      # %*/)   $      '    ()*+,)+$,,%+    $)+., ' -             

 ). (  - '  +            ""      # %*/)   $      '    ().+,)+$,,%+    ),+), ' -             

 ). (  - '  +    # &*   )   1       2 1   "            2$,( " -'     +          ).+,)+$,,%+ +  

            ""      # %*/3.   )      '                  

 $,   " 2 ++ )$,, ("      - +  ('(%*3(/$/)$()'*%/$(%*$ -5!! $1$,'6 $ -7! *(81$,&'(*$)3* !!"         ((*1*%*'63*(/%(*(*.((*)*1.*'( 1.*'#%*3* $,$$(%*('()#/&(*(/**3**()*(%$*'%( ('()#%*1.*'#%"  

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

   & $$$/ '..(*# ,(/ % # #%* (6*$/*/& $%<<$/ $*/ ,) %*/& *( '*$ << (%%* << '(/ 6,*)(* ()*1$*)* $ %*/$/ (6*$/)( %6,* )*$*(%%*  " " # " "" <%*%)* 1(%%/*,& " "" 6/ #()*%( 6'%/)* ((*,& ($$(#(* <(%(*,& 6/ '%'*, ( 1,()* (,& " "" 6*$/, '*$ (*"  %** '*$ 1%( ()* 1$// '..(* '%2($   + ! #., # %*/* + - %,  #.,& %*/* +   %,  > " "& " "

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