Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-06-876\7 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding refusal of residence permit for non-EU national. Appeal rejected due to lack of evidence for humanitarian grounds. Decision upheld based on statutory requirements.

Case Number 4-06-876\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Viru County Court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the refusal of a residence permit. The applicant argued for a permit based on humanitarian grounds, but the administrative body found no sufficient evidence to support this claim. The court upheld the refusal, ruling that the statutory requirements for granting a residence permit were not met.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Residence Act 2004; s. 11 of the Residence Act 2004: A residence permit may be granted on humanitarian grounds only if the applicant provides sufficient evidence of the specific circumstances justifying such an exception, which was not established in this case.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit refusal humanitarian grounds administrative appeal burden of proof non-EU national

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Residence Act 2004
s. 11 of the Residence Act 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

     

                    

     ! "            ! "        #       " $%" &  !'           " "(    )*+,*+)-+ .*-+,,+)-+ +               .//"   0)-)    "   !  +          //"  .  *1+*)+)-+  )).   . 

"       " "   &   )2.      " .          . !   33"      "!   +         '  "                    .+   0)-)    " +          "    //" "//"    " / .  *1+*)+)-+ +              "+ 4      "  "    !   "++   "     .33 "    +( "!  "    " + 

   "      !       " + (    ""   .     "     +        " " .   "    "     !  "     " +   "   .   

  33     ! +  "   33 ". ".  "   "    "  +&    !  . "      "+     "  "+ & 

33 "  "   !        " ++     .     ! . 

  +( "  "    "     "+&    !   +      "   .     . 33   +  &   "   .     "   ++"  " .     33 "   " 

  " !  +5 "   "   ".   !       0 )-)     '   " "+            '  ".  

""     "+       /   " 6 "  .  "  / .     "       ( 7 +   "  "+   "     !     '     "  ++ ("    "     !      " .  "  ""  +  "   33 ". " "  "  +   " ! 

33 "



     " +&          + ! " !    

"   + 6   ( 7 .  "  / .   

          + ( "  "  "+&  

    +&     "   " !  "        

+ 

   .

   .  "!   "  "      +      .    + 6  ' '. " / . *1+*)+)-+ +       33 "++ ( "    "    "  '             "  !  + (" "! .   ". " "  +( "   "          " !   +   "    "  "     "+ ("         " .    + ( " /  "   "  " +  33 "  "       !        " +  " 

 "    "+ 

   "  " !  +  "  " !             + &   "   " "'   +&  "        + 6    4 .  "  / .    !     33   )-+ +  " /  ! 7 ( "7" 

  +        "+(          "     .        " 33"  !   "   

++   /  .      "+   "     33 "./  "  .   " "         + ( "   "     ". !  "    " ++ ("   " "  . !        "      "+ .       "    +&  

 "  "     !

 +     "      ".   "   "   33   +           +4      /!   ! 7+   "           .  " /   ".  "        " .    .          '  "  0)-)  +

.           "   0 )-)    "     .+ +                     + 4  

33    " '                   .         33 ".!          "  "  "  "   "    "+        .  "" 08-.   //   .        ! ".    "    "    "!"  +       "    ".   "   "      "+  "   !  

      "" ".     "      "   "     " +      08-      .  "     " " //"     .        // "  !   " ! " +      .   33     33.         . !  !               +  5  " .  "" 0,*96,,,. 

     "   //"  0)-)    "   !      "  " )*# /:   / .+ ,)      +      "  4  "       "  ;  !    )),*)<992-*-   " = 5 !  ,*))<19>-*,,.

 1,-8*12+  

 " 

           "      #(     :    +  ? 

"     4    !           #(    : ",8!              !  .  "          !        9!            +                @  .