Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-03-60\4 AI generated

Court dismissed asylum claim for a Russian national based on insufficient evidence of persecution in Russia.

Case Number 1-03-60\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Narva Court of Appeal dismissed the asylum application filed by a Russian national who alleged persecution in his home country. The applicant claimed he faced threats due to his ethnic background, but the court found no credible evidence supporting these assertions. Consequently, the court determined that the applicant did not meet the legal threshold for protection under the relevant asylum legislation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

AsylG 2005, s. 1; s. 2: The court must assess whether the applicant faces a real risk of persecution based on protected grounds; a claim is rejected if the evidence fails to substantiate the alleged threats or if the applicant can demonstrate effective protection within their country of origin.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum claim Russian national persecution risk protection status evidence assessment Narva Court asylum legislation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AsylG 2005, s. 1
AsylG 2005, s. 2

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                           

   

      !!  "  !  # $

  ! "# %  "

&  ' ( )! )  " *+  ,!            # $     

  !"   !       -.   "    -    / !           "

 

       !" #$  $%   & &   

 ' (  ) *   +,-,.--+,/,   0 *  1 !

 

   .22   #      !" #$  $%     &   

' ( )*   +,-,.--+,/,   

    3  '!  % !      # 00#    "  #        12  "     " #34,563/"

 / ! "6  "   "    ! #     !     #    "     *      *   *# 

0 *   1 %%&*  %   & & * 4     *# %  *    *((

%&&

    ! ,& .22#$  $%  ,     " '!  % !" .        1 * "        "  #  *   # 7 !  "      *

  &      ! "! & #

 *    

&& #  #

 #

 / ! " 2-"    ! " #  "  ! #  * "  # !& !  # )  ! "

0 #. "     !  # "0     * "    &     

0 #     *&  #  !   #     3$83/      2  "  #     %98 8%6      2:  " !          "  ;  33$3 

      #   #     : "    2       

   "   

          " *

      2  " !   #      2  " *     

    2 " < )=     2 "*    <  =

 

       " *     <(=        "    

 2  "!   #!   

  

0 *  1 %%&*  &&* 4      #* & & * !

,&   !"#$  $%  ,   # 7 !      # 00#  "  .        1 * "        "  #  *  '!  % !  "      *

  &      ! " !  & #

   *     

 && #   # 

 #

 / ! "   2-"        ! " #  "    ! #   * "  #!& !  # )  ! "

0 #. "      !   #  " 0    * "    &     

0 #    *&  # !   #    3$83/      2  "  #     %98 8%6      2:  " !          "  ;  33$3 

      #   #     : "    2       

   "   

          " *

      2  " !   #      2  " *     

    2 " < )=     2 "*    <  =

       " *     <(=        "    

 2  "!   #!   

     &*  &&* 4      #* & & * !

,&   !"#$  $%  ,        *    &*    00#     # 00#         00#  "!   )  !      # # *

  600# *

      #  0 "-        2*  # '! % !   

     > #*       #!

  ; ? # )  !  # &  #  &  !         ! *    *          #          7  ++ #"* # " #   ! # & #  & ! "!   !  #    *  !    !&   !      #  &      #     !    !    %     

    & #    %   % !  #   # 2 )  ! & *   &"% !&    "  ! &    * # #      #    "

   # ++ #   *  # 9    "++ #  #       % !  )  !  0    

 "  #    #        )  !       !  "

 % !   !   ++     6& % !    ! "* !&  # #  # #  1   "#" & < )="

 ! # !   #"  ;  " #       ! #"

  #   *        #  6  #"  & 

  # !    # #0  

  % ! 0 # ! #"    !  *

 !  # /  % !     

  #      ! # # 00#   ! 0 #

  >#"."::2"---.?"

  # 00#   !          *0 *  1 %%&* 00#  # 00#    6@1*#"2 &    #6  "!     " #   A! 0 0

      

   *      !   #)  !    ! #   #"   

 *&  # "   7 !           * #     & # 

0 " #7 !  "* #0       ,  #    # ;    

   &   7 !            * 9  7 ! *  )  ! #" * # &  # !         ! *    4    !& #    *  ++  7 ! &  )  !  #"     

 *            *&    00 <!   "

 =++#   2:  ")  !    !   

  7 ! 0 < #   = *# )  !    

 & !& *&& * 7 ! 0

  " #       A <!   #" !    # =   7 !  * *     &#  # #)  !  *#      #&  #  !& "   & # 00#  ! 8   #   *        !   #"   *  #   *  !  !#   !  # 3  * !  

  3 # )  !         #      !  &

  6

  

   # 

0 #  9   7 ! * !    

   !    &   & #*  

"    #7 !         ! # # 00#   !  % !  0 # 

 >#"  2" "1?"   # 00#   !    &%   &    #   &&*"   

 #0 >#"?")  ! # & *   &0           

      

 #0 >#"? 

  5 *%% " 0 "    

  #A 00#   !  &     )  !  *   &)  !  

  # *&!  

 *8 )  !     & #  

 #0  >#"?    0&* *! 0 " "++  1* & &    )  ! "   * " 

   < # "  *  =    

   #"+#     #& #   2   # "! !&   ! ! #*    ! #        

& 

0 #  *  %&    0 >#"? ! #

     0  !    

++      " *   

  # 

  !& # ++        %&  #  )  !  #  #"  #  * #     *  * &*" 0 "  !  )  ! 6 

 . *    )  !       ! # &  0   

   #  &  )  !  *    * "   " * "

 !           !      



   &       '

   # 

  2   #   # *  

 %  )  !    

 !    #++ )  !    #  #  6&*!   0 "      ++  B         # < # " *  =     3    # !     #    # &     

0 )  !  0 #    ! "  ! #  #   #    #   #  #       * !& * "    # 

   & 0* 0!    !  & !     : 6

 & 0   #  #     *  !&  *&  &  9

   # "   *#   )  !   "

   # *  *   !&  *&  *  

 9 

 )  !  

    ++    #  # "  )  !  # &  *   &  *    0      "! # % && "  *&  # "       "      

  

       ! # #     C   !  0 # >#"  2?   "  .  12* & !  *

 "*&           0   # 9

   # "   *#   )  ! "  

2   *         0  

0 *  6&*! 0 "   "  * ++ *      *   

*&&  #   #   ,   %  # !   1  "

& ++     !   

 *& 

# " )  ! 

   "  * !  0    #< # = )  !  

  

   0       2   *&  *  "  2)  !       # %&   !        2  *&        #      #  # #, & 0 "   !  , 0

"    #   !  "  !  6 ! ! # * # ! #            2 *  ,    !  & "  < # = " # )  !      # "    !   0  # %&  !

  

 

   !   

 *& , !&     ++## *&  # "   #& *   !   !&    112  *&       &&  A!   #" !   #  

 # "      0 !&   !  && ,  

    #   0     *    #      ! 0 " #6      

600#  *        !   #  #  #  &%   &*   #     7  5   >#"2-?" 0 

"  *   !&  & 6   * # #      0  !    *#      ++##"!&  # # #     &* >#"?" 0 

"        -   ! "#   ! #   #      #  *   

    !   

  # ! * #  !   &        0 "     6& !    D+  #         #" )  !   *

    #  .  *    &    % !    7 ! "      # !   ++!

   8   #   

! #         # "7 !     #   ;   8&  >#"?" 0 

" *  ! ! %     C !    .  * 

     :     - !  #      /# 

! # &#  4     2   ! -

" 0    #"  # ! "     !&! *"* !   0    ! : " #  # * / #!  #  #6  #"0

      &        #   &      &    #      *

"   )  ! 6  #"    3  !       !  *   / #   #"          # ! #   # " # # #   #'&

*&! *& 0

*     # ! #         *     &%   &*    # # 3 

0 #   !  *>#"2.?"   &"  2-  !  #  !  )  !  *E

  # )  !       *  "   !  #   ! "

  

     &!!  #"    #   #" !!  # *   * " 0

   "     "

  ++# 

 *   !!  # 0

   

  

  "

 &  ! #"    ! #

   !     #             &  )  !     ! #"        &

 !      )  !   !   #    ! # ! #     # 

   #    ! 

     >#"-1-?E  7 !  *  #7 ! *! *>#"1?E  7 ! * 0#    >#".?E  7 ! *  "    )  !  "! *>#"-2?E      *  .'! % !   "  !   "  ! !  &  &* !   #  .    !     "    " 0% !" !&  !>#"-.?E  !#  !  *>#":-?E       *   :"     !  #"  % !  *0    7 ! *  !  #  ! >#"-:?E       *   2-:"     !  #"  % !   *0  ! !  !  *& #  % ! " !  7 !  * !  *& #  7 !  )  ! >#".?E     * "   !  #"  #  #  #!   #  *   *  # "

0 #   !#!#      

#   2F .F>#"?E    #



0 #     !  #  !  *>#"2?E     !  !  *"   !  #<3  =>#"2. ?E  7 !  0  !  

 *    

0 #    >% !  * )  ! ++    ;  !  ?>#":::?E  )  !      !   #        ; " &  #

   

*>#"-."?E  

  * "   !  #"   ;#! #&#  &# #7 ! *   ! * *    #*>#"?E  * 0    *  #% !  7 !   "   !   " # !  #"  00# ! #"! ! # # 

  #    # !  >#":-"1?E  % ! *   &  #

*>#".?E 

0 #   ";     "!  *>#"1:2?E 

0 #   " ;        " !  #   !  * >#"   ?E  '! % !    # ! 

 * >#"?   #&  00#   ! #"      #  #     "     !  "  00#   !  00 *   # * 00   !    # #    #  # #        !  " A # )  !  * A  * ##  !        #  %&   *

   00#   !  * !   #    !      600#   ! # #        ! 

  #

/  ++

      "  *     * ! ! 

  600#   ! #   # # )  !  *

  00# "  # # 00# !  !      % !   #&   00#  6@ &    "!    00#   ! * 00 *

   

"  

  #  #     A     0  "

0 #   # !  * # "    "    " 

   

  *  # "  00#   !  00 # #       '! C   ! " #  C   !   #' !!  0 # 0 ! # &   0  00#   !  % !  0 # /  0  % !"   #)  ! 

 1* 

7 !* )  ! 

        ! ,

  

  

7 !   :    *&       #

     6   # 

 &  * #     &      *

   " 7 ! "  & #"#        # /   " % !"   *  !   #       !&&  # && 

#++ "!    # &       # 

  0

 &         >#"  2?   #     0

  ! 

"     - .      ++           #  ++ )  !       *   % !    0 0 # 0 #! &

   !

     , *#  !        ! # )  !   *

 *&!     &# "  % !  !   #    "           #  )  !          *      !  #"      

 .     ++  : 

  00 #       * "

0 #   # !  *   !  !

   C   !  ' !! 0 "!  &#     

  # #  ! #   #0   # $ #    0 *  *    # ++ #    #  

 *  #  >  ?   #++ #!   #"  0 "  ! E  ++ # #  0*  *    #"    *0  "            "   & )  !    E  ++ #  #  

 *  #  >  ?     #"      

 /  # ++ #   #   !  !&

 !          

 & 

 #!         #  !  #  7 ! **  &  ! "!   !  # !++*  >#"-?   !     *   !  7 !  * !  # !  *& # 

     )  ! >#".?E  '!  % !    #  *      !  #"  !  & 

  !   ! !   #  .        !     "          00#   !"   !&  ! /#  *#  &# #     #  * && # &  # !       *   > -.?E   "   )  !  ++# "   % !  /      *&   # * * ##)  !  *

7 ! *     !  /  % !! 7 !    !   #!  *E   *

 ")  !  "  !  #  #&#  !  #" #  &# #7 ! *E

 : 

00#   ! # #)  !   1  : "   !&E  )  !    #  ! #  # 00#   ! #"  #   #   *   " & #       &#  E  *&   *

  * 

 00#   ! # !  #  # # A % ! !     *  "   7 ! &    * "    # *#  # ! # 600#   ! #   #  #  # *#     "  # )  !    !   #  # 00      "  7 !  0 # )  !   *

  #     0   * # !    

0 #   !  *  #    7 ! *A!++*   *  & "0 0  0 #" ++ #     #    0 *  # "   #   ! 

 0"   % ! 7 ! &  0  "   &  # )  ! #

++

" #% !         *  !    &" ! #   !# "     *   "  *& !   

  #"!  #  6  "7 ! *!  &&#  !    #"  

00#   ! 0  !      "  *      ;   #  !   #    &"   !!  *  *      !  "     "7 ! ! & " #

 #++ # #  7 !  *   !  &          !  &

 # ! 

    &  !!  *  * "!!  #"    #     " 0

   

  

   ++# 

 *   /   7 !   *   & "

    ! 

 * *   &  *      ! *!++*   %  7 ! 0 



     #    &

    7 !  

   0      #  #"       % !        "  # &  # &

++>7 !  0 ##"::2?"

 * 0#      >#".?E    0

    ! >#"--.?7 !0 " % !  !   

 ++"

    % ! )  !     # "  #% !     7 !  0   &"  )  !  



  #        % !# )  ! &"  ! &   " &  #         % !      *&  # "    "7 !   &&   #      *      !  #"     !        #"    !   #  &#   #   #   "  ++ #  # 00#   ! #A7 !   % !      &     00#   !     #!   %&    *

 #  #  #   

!&&      !& !

   ! 

    00#   ! # * # #    # "          !&  #  #   # 6 *

  "   ! 

 &#  "  #  #     "    !     *

     & #      " 00#   ! # #  

  # #"  !  "  "  !  !

  !   

 - 6  " 00#   ! # !  ;   #        # #  & *  !    *3      &*   !        #"   !# !&&!  " * 0   ! " #  !       !     E  '!  % !   !    *    #"    !# !&&!  " * 0   !   7 !  % !     # ! #   # !  # 7 !  % !      # !        *  *   !& !   ! " # )  !  

0 # #.     ! 

  !

     6 !  * 00#   !  #     >#"?  % ! 

  # "   

! E  7 ! !   

! E  7 ! ! #      "  # 00 7 !  !  )  !    ; "    

  600#   !      &&

  "  ##   6 @ 2 & " !  !



00#   !        

"      # !    *#

"       # !      * 

*  !& !   ! "

00#   !  

 * ##

"!    #  00# # * #  # 

00# * 

 "

 !  !

     ! #   !  !

"7 !*        

/ !     &   &#  #    *       &&   00#   !         !     

      !  #  #" #      &&

  ! #    ## 6 @#& "   3    #       00#   6 @ 1 *# "2 &   &#    * 

     # >0 ?  !       # #   6 @ 2         #     / !       &  #       !  #        #7 !  >  ?  !           !  #  #7 ! !   1    " *&! "   *        (     &*   . '

/      .9 $ **  ,   #A!   A&        *  +,-,.--+,, 

 .   # 0 *  1  00#  6@1"2 @&  &#  # * 

     #    6@1*#"2& >0 ?  !    E   6@& > ? !       6@1           #0         #

 '! % ! >0  ?  #!            !  #  % !  !    :#     "   *&! "   *   #

 ( '

/  .' /.:$ **     #A!   A&        *  +,-,.--+,,    *      &*   # 0 *   1 %%&*   (  &       #)  ! >/ ! "  : ?  !&     #  +;:.&&  

 # #A*   *  "

  / ! *       #   "0  " ;"   " * * #" 7 !  *"     * " . *        A &!  #   <(    *      &*   # 0 *   1 %%&*   

    #

 00#  !     ! %9"--&&   <(    *    

   3   #7 !  '! % !   #      * 

   

2;:"&& E   # 7 !    '!  % !   #     *  

   

.:"-&& E   #7 !  '! % !   #     * 

  9"&&     &*  3 

  * 0   * 

  

-"+&& E     *

    

  

.2:,"-&& E      # $  * 

  #     

.;"- &&  

0 *  1 %%&*   

  * 0   * 

  

-"+&& E     *

    

  

;:",.+&& E     # ! 

 * 

 --&& E       

 * 

  #     

.;"- && ,      ! 7) !  ' !!    #

   

+.,."&&  &    #  

  &  # #    #    #  $  #

   *    1-: 6,C ,   4 *   !  *    ::- 9 *  " !   -1..  !     

   #   / !     

     *  !  #   !   !  *  #    $   2*&!  &         / !      #"       #      

       :*&!  &          !  

 *&!   ,

   $ !  #     .,-,.--9! 5 &&% 583 

<&% +,-,.--2&% &   %   &*  % 2" . $ &% &  ,  &%2" $    <&% +-,-9,.--&% &   (     &               &*   (  + '& /  *  ,   2:   * 

 *   # . ,-,.--. ,& + $ * *      %     #$   ,  = #$$&  #$  <&% &    ,